Chapter 6 Lectures: Applyng Newton's Laws: Kinetic and Static Friction Examples

Critical Angle of Inclination and Empirical Determination of Static Friction

  • Initial System Parameters on an Incline:

    • Mass of the box: m=55 kgm = 55\,\text{kg}.

    • Initial state of the box: At rest (v0=0 m/sv_0 = 0\,\text{m/s}).

    • Initial incline angle: θ=25∘\theta = 25^\circ.

    • Coefficient of kinetic friction: μk=0.230\mu_k = 0.230.

    • Coefficient of static friction: μs=0.540\mu_s = 0.540.

  • Threshold Condition for Impending Motion:

    • As the angle of inclination θ\theta is gradually increased beyond 25∘25^\circ, the component of gravitational force acting parallel to the surface increases until it overcomes the maximum static friction force.

    • The box begins to slide when the tangent of the incline angle equals or exceeds the coefficient of static friction:         tan⁡(θ)≥μs\tan(\theta) \ge \mu_s

    • At the exact threshold where the block just starts to slide, maximum static friction is engaged:         tan⁡(θ)=μs\tan(\theta) = \mu_s

  • Derivation from the Free-Body Diagram:

    • A rotated Cartesian coordinate system is defined where the xx-axis is parallel to the inclined plane (pointing down the slope) and the yy-axis is perpendicular to the plane.

    • Three forces act upon the object:

      • Normal force (nn), directed in the positive perpendicular direction (+y+y).

      • Static friction force (fsf_s), directed up the incline in the negative parallel direction (−x-x).

      • Gravitational force (mgmg), acting vertically downward.

    • Resolving the gravitational force into perpendicular and parallel components:

      • Perpendicular component: wy=mgcos⁡(θ)w_y = mg\cos(\theta)

      • Parallel component: wx=mgsin⁡(θ)w_x = mg\sin(\theta)

    • Equilibrium equations along each axis before motion begins (ax=0a_x = 0, ay=0a_y = 0):         ∑Fy=n−mgcos⁡(θ)=0  ⟹  n=mgcos⁡(θ)\sum F_y = n - mg\cos(\theta) = 0 \implies n = mg\cos(\theta)         ∑Fx=mgsin⁡(θ)−fs=0  ⟹  fs=mgsin⁡(θ)\sum F_x = mg\sin(\theta) - f_s = 0 \implies f_s = mg\sin(\theta)

    • At the point of slip, static friction reaches its theoretical maximum, fs,max⁡=μsnf_{s,\max} = \mu_s n:         mgsin⁡(θ)=μs(mgcos⁡(θ))mg\sin(\theta) = \mu_s (mg\cos(\theta))

    • Dividing both sides by mgcos⁡(θ)mg\cos(\theta) yields the critical angle relationship:         sin⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)=μs  ⟹  tan⁡(θ)=μs\frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = \mu_s \implies \tan(\theta) = \mu_s

  • Empirical Measurement of Static Friction:

    • This equation provides an experimental method to measure the coefficient of static friction between any two interacting surfaces.

    • By placing an object made of a given material onto an incline and elevating the angle θ\theta slowly until sliding initiates, the critical slip angle determines μs\mu_s directly.

  • Numerical Calculation:

    • Solving for the critical slip angle θ\theta using the given static friction coefficient:         θ=arctan⁡(μs)=arctan⁡(0.540)=28.4∘\theta = \arctan(\mu_s) = \arctan(0.540) = 28.4^\circ

    • At θ=28.4∘\theta = 28.4^\circ, the applied gravitational force down the incline overcomes maximum static friction, initiating sliding.

Qualitative Mechanics of Pushing Versus Pulling with Friction

  • Comparative Problem Definition:

    • A child seated on a sled (treated together as a combined single mass mm) is transported across snow with surface friction.

    • Two distinct modes of force application at an identical angle θ\theta relative to the horizontal are compared:

      • Case A: Pushing downward at an angle θ\theta below the horizontal.

      • Case B: Pulling upward via a rope at an angle θ\theta above the horizontal.

    • Objective: Determine which method requires exerting less force magnitude (FF) to cause horizontal motion.

  • Free-Body Diagram Analysis for Case A (Pushing Downward):

    • Gravitational force (mgmg) acts directly downward.

    • Applied pushing force (FF) has components directed forward (+x+x) and downward (−y-y):

      • Horizontal component: Fx=Fcos⁡(θ)F_x = F\cos(\theta)

      • Vertical component: Fy=Fsin⁡(θ)F_y = F\sin(\theta)

    • Vertical equilibrium condition (ay=0a_y = 0):         ∑Fy=n−mg−Fsin⁡(θ)=0  ⟹  n=mg+Fsin⁡(θ)\sum F_y = n - mg - F\sin(\theta) = 0 \implies n = mg + F\sin(\theta)

    • Because the downward push actively presses the mass into the snow, the normal force nn is greater than the weight (n>mgn > mg).

    • Kinetic friction magnitude is defined by fk=μknf_k = \mu_k n. Because nn increases, the kinetic friction opposing motion increases correspondingly.

    • The horizontal force component Fcos⁡(θ)F\cos(\theta) must overcome this enlarged frictional force.

  • Free-Body Diagram Analysis for Case B (Pulling Upward):

    • Gravitational force (mgmg) acts directly downward.

    • Applied pulling force (FF) has components directed forward (+x+x) and upward (+y+y):

      • Horizontal component: Fx=Fcos⁡(θ)F_x = F\cos(\theta)

      • Vertical component: Fy=Fsin⁡(θ)F_y = F\sin(\theta)

    • Vertical equilibrium condition (ay=0a_y = 0):         ∑Fy=n+Fsin⁡(θ)−mg=0  ⟹  n=mg−Fsin⁡(θ)\sum F_y = n + F\sin(\theta) - mg = 0 \implies n = mg - F\sin(\theta)

    • Because the upward pull partially supports the weight of the mass, the ground contact force is relieved, making the normal force smaller than the weight (n<mgn < mg).

    • Because nn decreases, the resulting kinetic friction force fk=μknf_k = \mu_k n decreases.

  • Qualitative Conclusion and Practical Real-World Analogy:

    • Pulling upward requires less force than pushing downward because it reduces the normal force, directly reducing surface friction.

    • Analogy: Dragging a heavy bucket across the floor is physically difficult due to high friction. If an external helper partially lifts upward on the bucket, dragging becomes significantly easier because decreasing the normal force immediately reduces the friction force against the floor.

Analytical Derivation of Pushing Versus Pulling Forces

  • Derivation for Case A: Pushing Below the Horizontal:

    • Coordinate system: Horizontal right as positive xx, vertical up as positive yy.

    • Vertical equilibrium (ay=0a_y = 0):         ∑Fy=n−mg−Fy=0\sum F_y = n - mg - F_y = 0         n=mg+Fsin⁡(θ)n = mg + F\sin(\theta)

    • Horizontal motion governed by Newton's second law (∑Fx=max\sum F_x = m a_x):         ∑Fx=Fx−fk=max\sum F_x = F_x - f_k = m a_x         Fcos⁡(θ)−μkn=maxF\cos(\theta) - \mu_k n = m a_x

    • Substituting the expression for the normal force nn:         Fcos⁡(θ)−μk(mg+Fsin⁡(θ))=maxF\cos(\theta) - \mu_k (mg + F\sin(\theta)) = m a_x         Fcos⁡(θ)−μkFsin⁡(θ)−μkmg=maxF\cos(\theta) - \mu_k F\sin(\theta) - \mu_k mg = m a_x

    • Isolating and factoring the applied force FF:         F(cos⁡(θ)−μksin⁡(θ))=max+μkmgF(\cos(\theta) - \mu_k\sin(\theta)) = m a_x + \mu_k mg         Fpush=m(ax+μkg)cos⁡(θ)−μksin⁡(θ)F_{\text{push}} = \frac{m(a_x + \mu_k g)}{\cos(\theta) - \mu_k\sin(\theta)}

  • Derivation for Case B: Pulling Above the Horizontal:

    • Vertical equilibrium (ay=0a_y = 0):         ∑Fy=n+Fy−mg=0\sum F_y = n + F_y - mg = 0         n=mg−Fsin⁡(θ)n = mg - F\sin(\theta)

    • Horizontal motion governed by Newton's second law (∑Fx=max\sum F_x = m a_x):         ∑Fx=Fx−fk=max\sum F_x = F_x - f_k = m a_x         Fcos⁡(θ)−μkn=maxF\cos(\theta) - \mu_k n = m a_x

    • Substituting the expression for the normal force nn:         Fcos⁡(θ)−μk(mg−Fsin⁡(θ))=maxF\cos(\theta) - \mu_k (mg - F\sin(\theta)) = m a_x         Fcos⁡(θ)+μkFsin⁡(θ)−μkmg=maxF\cos(\theta) + \mu_k F\sin(\theta) - \mu_k mg = m a_x

    • Isolating and factoring the applied force FF:         F(cos⁡(θ)+μksin⁡(θ))=max+μkmgF(\cos(\theta) + \mu_k\sin(\theta)) = m a_x + \mu_k mg         Fpull=m(ax+μkg)cos⁡(θ)+μksin⁡(θ)F_{\text{pull}} = \frac{m(a_x + \mu_k g)}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_k\sin(\theta)}

  • Rigorous Mathematical Comparison of Force Magnitudes:

    • The numerators of both expressions are identical: m(ax+μkg)m(a_x + \mu_k g).

    • The pulling force has denominator Dpull=cos⁡(θ)+μksin⁡(θ)D_{\text{pull}} = \cos(\theta) + \mu_k\sin(\theta).

    • The pushing force has denominator Dpush=cos⁡(θ)−μksin⁡(θ)D_{\text{push}} = \cos(\theta) - \mu_k\sin(\theta).

    • Domain constraints: For practical pulling/pushing configurations, the angle is restricted to 0∘<θ<90∘0^\circ < \theta < 90^\circ.

    • Behavior of trigonometric terms on this interval:

      • cos⁡(θ)>0\cos(\theta) > 0

      • sin⁡(θ)>0\sin(\theta) > 0

      • The friction coefficient is positive (μk>0\mu_k > 0).

    • Comparing the denominators:         cos⁡(θ)+μksin⁡(θ)>cos⁡(θ)−μksin⁡(θ)\cos(\theta) + \mu_k\sin(\theta) > \cos(\theta) - \mu_k\sin(\theta)

    • Because the denominator for pulling is strictly greater than the denominator for pushing, dividing the identical numerator by a larger value yields a smaller overall force:         Fpull<FpushF_{\text{pull}} < F_{\text{push}}

    • This confirms analytically that pulling requires less force than pushing.

Quantitative Application: Pulling a Crate Under Static and Kinetic Conditions

  • Problem Specification:

    • Mass of the crate: m=125 kgm = 125\,\text{kg}.

    • Pulling angle above horizontal: θ=25∘\theta = 25^\circ.

    • Coefficients of friction between floor and crate:

      • μs=0.540\mu_s = 0.540

      • μk=0.230\mu_k = 0.230

    • Initial state: Crate is initially at rest (v0=0 m/sv_0 = 0\,\text{m/s}).

  • Part 1: Force Required to Initiate Motion (Static Friction Regime):

    • Condition: Overcome maximum static friction (fs,max⁡=μsnf_{s,\max} = \mu_s n) so that horizontal acceleration becomes positive (ax>0a_x > 0).

    • Newton's second law applied to horizontal threshold:         Fx>fs,max⁡F_x > f_{s,\max}         Fcos⁡(θ)>μsnF\cos(\theta) > \mu_s n

    • Normal force with upward pulling force component:         n=mg−Fsin⁡(θ)n = mg - F\sin(\theta)

    • Substitution into the inequality:         Fcos⁡(θ)>μs(mg−Fsin⁡(θ))F\cos(\theta) > \mu_s (mg - F\sin(\theta))         Fcos⁡(θ)+μsFsin⁡(θ)>μsmgF\cos(\theta) + \mu_s F\sin(\theta) > \mu_s mg         F(cos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ))>μsmgF(\cos(\theta) + \mu_s\sin(\theta)) > \mu_s mg         F>μsmgcos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ)F > \frac{\mu_s mg}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_s\sin(\theta)}

    • Substituting the numerical values (m=125 kgm = 125\,\text{kg}, θ=25∘\theta = 25^\circ, μs=0.540\mu_s = 0.540):         F>583 NF > 583\,\text{N}

    • A minimum tension force strictly exceeding 583 N583\,\text{N} is required to break static equilibrium and initiate crate motion.

  • Part 2: Force Required to Maintain Given Acceleration (Kinetic Friction Regime):

    • Condition: The crate is already in motion; motion is governed by kinetic friction (μk=0.230\mu_k = 0.230).

    • Desired constant horizontal acceleration: ax=3.75 m/s2a_x = 3.75\,\text{m/s}^2.

    • Analytical expression for pulling force during acceleration:         F=m(ax+μkg)cos⁡(θ)+μksin⁡(θ)F = \frac{m(a_x + \mu_k g)}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_k\sin(\theta)}

    • Substituting numerical values:

      • m=125 kgm = 125\,\text{kg}

      • ax=3.75 m/s2a_x = 3.75\,\text{m/s}^2

      • μk=0.230\mu_k = 0.230

      • θ=25∘\theta = 25^\circ

    • Resulting tension force:         F=748 NF = 748\,\text{N}

    • A continuous pulling force of 748 N748\,\text{N} must be exerted on the rope to maintain an acceleration of 3.75 m/s23.75\,\text{m/s}^2 while overcoming kinetic friction.