Molecular Modeling Procedure - Detailed Study Notes

MOLECULAR MODELING PROCEDURE – PART 1 AVOGADRO

Overview of Avogadro
  • What is Avogadro?
    Avogadro is a free cross-platform molecular editor designed for building, visualizing, and performing calculations on molecular structures.
    If Avogadro is not pre-installed, it can be downloaded from the official website.

Part 1: Minimization and Conformational Analysis
Objective
  • To minimize the energy of a molecule using several different initial conformations.

  • To determine the dihedral angle for the carbon atoms in 3-methyloctane.

Strategy
  • Draw 3-methyloctane in various conformations with different dihedral angles across the carbon backbone.

  • Minimize each structure to find the lowest energy conformation accessible from each starting point.

Drawing 3-Methyloctane
  1. Start a New File

    • Navigate: File ➔ New

    • A blank black screen will display with "Tool Settings" and "Display Settings" toolbars.

  2. Set Up Drawing Tools

    • In "Tool Settings", select the pencil icon.

    • Set element to "carbon" and bond type to "single".

  3. Construct the Molecule

    • Click on the black screen to place a sp3 carbon atom (methane).

    • Change one H atom to create C-CH3, forming ethane.

    • Continue this process to draw pentane in a zig-zag structure.

    • Add methyl groups to C(2).

    • Optimize Geometry: Go to Extensions ➔ Optimize Geometry to adjust bond lengths slightly.

  4. Measure Dihedral Angle

    • Select the "Click to Measure" icon.

    • Click in order on C(1), C(2), C(3), and C(4) to display the dihedral angle in the lower left corner.

Minimization of 3-Methyloctane
  1. Changing Conformations

    • Adjust the conformation of 3-methyloctane so that the dihedral angle between C(1) and C(4) is between 2° and 5°.

    • Use the "Bond Centric Manipulation Tool" to rotate the C(2)-C(3) bond appropriately.

    • Use the "Navigation Tool" (star icon) to view the structure from various angles.

  2. Minimize Structure

    • Select Force Field:

      • Navigate: Extensions ➔ Molecular Mechanics ➔ Set Up for Field…

      • Choose MMF94 and retain default settings.

    • Optimize Geometry again: Extensions ➔ Optimize Geometry

      • Repeat until the dihedral angle is stable (typically 3-4 iterations).

    • Confirm minimized structure by calculating energy:

      • Navigate: Extensions ➔ Molecular Mechanics ➔ Calculate Energy

    • When energy is minimized, it will remain constant.

  3. Reporting Results

    • Record the dihedral angle and export a high-quality image of the minimized structure:

      • File ➔ Export ➔ Graphics ➔ .png

    • Crop the image to fit the worksheet.

  4. Repeat Process

    • Follow the above steps for other dihedral angles from the worksheet.

    • Select the correct dihedral angle, minimized energy, and choose the descriptor (eclipsed, gauche, anti).

Part 2: Minimization of Cycloalkanes and Bond Angle/Distance Measurements
Objective
  • Minimize cyclobutane and cyclopentane conformations.

  • Measure bond lengths, bond angles, and evaluate potential transannular steric interactions.

Cyclobutane Minimization and Measurement
  1. Building Cyclobutane

    • Create a new window: File ➔ New

    • Draw butane with the pencil tool and connect terminal C atoms to form the ring, or insert a preconstructed cyclobutane ring from:

      • Insert ➔ Fragment ➔ Cyclic Alkanes ➔ cyclobutane.cml ➔ Insert

    • Deselect atoms following insertion: Select ➔ None

  2. Minimize Structure

    • Navigation: Extensions ➔ Molecular Mechanics ➔ Conformer Search

    • Select "Systematic rotor search" in the dialog.

    • Verify that results match individual minimization if needed.

  3. Measure Bonds and Angles

    • Use the "Click to Measure" icon for:

      • C-H and C-C bond lengths

      • Specific bond angles

      • Through-space distances directly.

  4. Report Results

    • Export image of the minimized cyclobutane structure:

      • Paste the image into the worksheet with the same perspective as the line structure.

    • Record calculated angles, lengths, and distances in the worksheet.

  5. Repeat for Cyclopentane

    • Follow similar steps for cyclopentane and complete worksheet questions accordingly.

Part 3: Determination of Relative Energies of Dimethylcyclohexanes
Objective
  • Identify the minimum energy conformation of dimethylcyclohexane isomers.

Drawing and Minimizing Structures
  1. Construct cis-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane

    • Create new build window and draw the desired structure.

    • Minimize the chair conformation of cyclohexane derivatives:

      • Use inserted structures or draw directly.

      • Change hydrogens to methyl groups as applicable.

  2. Calculate Energy

    • Ensure it is the global minimum by performing chair flips.

    • Record total energies for each minimized structure.

  3. Measure Through-Space Distances

    • Use the "Click to Measure" tool for specified distances.

Additional Structures
  1. Additional Isomers

    • Create and minimize necessary structures such as trans-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane and evaluate their energies similarly.

  2. 1,3-Dimethylcyclopentane

    • Follow similar steps for the cyclopentane derivative.

  3. Document Results

    • Copy .png images of minimized structures into worksheets and record energies and measurements.

Part 4: Comparison of Energies to Experimental Data
Objective
  • Quantify substituent A values from energies of monosubstituted cyclohexanes.

Procedure
  1. Draw Axial and Equatorial Forms

    • Structures include:

      • Fluorocyclohexane

      • Cyclopropylcyclohexane

      • Trichloromethylcyclohexane

    • Calculate minimized energies for each structure.

  2. Calculate A Values

    • Use axial and equatorial energy values to calculate A values:
      A=extΔGA = - ext{ΔG}

    • Ensure consistency in units and dimensional analysis for ΔG in kcal/mol.

  3. Record Findings

    • Note down all calculated A values and minimized structures in the worksheet.

Part 5: Evaluation of t-Butylcyclohexane
Measurement of Parameters
  1. Through-Space Distance Measurement

    • Use Click to Measure tool to find distance between an axial H and the closest H on the t-butyl group.

  2. Record Bond Angle

    • Calculate the C-C-C bond angle using the tool and document this in the worksheet.

ChemDraw Structures for Decalin Derivatives
  1. Structural Representation

    • Create chair conformations for cis-decalin and trans-decalin using ChemDraw with specific settings (ACS 1996).

  2. Modeling in Avogadro

    • Structure perspectives must match between ChemDraw and Avogadro.

    • Export 3D .png images of structures for worksheet placement.

Newmann Projections
  1. Identify Low-Energy Conformation

    • Perform rotation around the C(2)-C(3) bond.

    • Document the Newman projection closely aligned with minimized structure from Avogadro.

Summary of Procedures
  • Each part consists of building structures in Avogadro, minimizing them through defined techniques, measuring required angles and distances, and accurately reporting findings in digital worksheets.