Contracts Exam-Focused Study Guide
Core Framework and Foundation of Contract Law
Definition of a Contract: A contract is a legally enforceable set of promises. A breach gives the injured party a legal remedy, or the law may recognize a duty to perform.
Core Contract Framework:
Offer
Acceptance
Consideration
Capacity
Legality
Governing Law Division:
Common Law: Generally governs contracts involving services, real estate, and intangibles.
Examples: Hiring a lawyer; buying a house; hiring someone to mow a lawn.
Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) Article 2: Governs sales of goods, which are defined as movable, tangible objects.
Example: Buying a car.
Five Requirements for a Valid and Enforceable Contract
Offer: A proposal that creates a power of acceptance.
Acceptance: Unequivocal assent to the offer.
Consideration: Legally sufficient value exchanged through bargaining.
Capacity: Parties have legal ability to contract.
Legality: The purpose of the agreement is legal.
Objective Theory of Contracts
Standard of Intent: Courts generally look at the parties' objective words and conduct rather than undisclosed subjective intentions.
Reasonable Person Standard: The core evaluative question is what a reasonable person would understand from the parties' behavior.
Meeting of the Minds: The parties must objectively demonstrate agreement on the essential terms of the contract.
Contract Classifications
Bilateral vs. Unilateral Contracts:
Bilateral Contract: A promise exchanged for a promise. The contract is formed immediately when the promises are exchanged. (Memory trick: Bi = two promises).
Unilateral Contract: A promise exchanged for an act or performance. Acceptance occurs through completing the requested performance. (Memory trick: Uni = one promise + performance).
Express vs. Implied Contracts:
Express Contract: Terms are explicitly stated, either orally or in writing, unless a law requires a writing.
Implied-in-Fact Contract: A real contract inferred from conduct where the parties' behavior demonstrates actual assent. Elements required:
The plaintiff furnished a service or property.
The plaintiff expected payment.
The defendant knew or should have known that payment was expected.
Implied-in-Law Contract (Quasi-Contract): Not a true agreement. A court imposes an obligation to prevent unjust enrichment. The standard remedy is the reasonable value of the benefit provided, known as quantum meruit.
Key Distinction: Implied-in-fact requires actual assent through conduct, whereas implied-in-law involves no actual agreement and serves as a court-created equitable remedy.
Contract Enforceability Classifications
Valid Contract: A legally enforceable contract that meets all necessary requirements.
Voidable Contract: A contract exists, but one or both parties have the legal right to avoid or cancel performance.
Examples: Contracts involving minors, mental incompetence, duress, or undue influence.
Unenforceable Contract: An agreement appears valid on its face, but a statute or other law prevents court enforcement.
Example: A required writing under the Statute of Frauds is missing.
Void Contract: No legally enforceable contract ever existed from its inception.
Terminology Note: Avoid using the redundant phrasing null and void on legal examinations.
The Offer and Rules of Termination
Definition and Elements: An offer is a proposal that demonstrates serious objective intent, contains sufficiently definite terms, is communicated to the offeree, and creates the power of acceptance.
Statements That Are Generally Not Offers:
Opinions
Statements of future intent
Preliminary negotiations
Invitations to bid
Auctions
Advertisements
Price lists
Advertisement Exception: Advertisements are generally treated as invitations to make an offer. An exception exists when the advertisement is sufficiently definite, demonstrates explicit intent to be bound, and specifies a requested performance.
Master of the Offer Rule: The offeror generally controls the terms of the offer, including the specified method of acceptance and deadlines. If the offer specifies how acceptance must occur, those instructions must be followed.
Termination of an Offer:
Revocation: The offeror withdraws the offer before acceptance occurs.
Rejection: The offeree rejects the offer.
Counteroffer: The offeree changes the terms. Under common law, a counteroffer generally rejects the original offer and creates a new offer.
Death or Incapacity: Generally terminates an offer prior to acceptance.
Destruction: Destruction of the subject matter terminates the offer.
Lapse of Time: An offer expires at its stated deadline, or after a reasonable time if no explicit deadline is specified.
Option Contracts: An option contract gives the offeree a right to accept during a specified period. When an option is supported by consideration, the offer becomes irrevocable during that period.
Example: Jones pays Smith $100 for a 30-day option. Smith generally cannot revoke the offer during those 30 days.
Acceptance Rules
Definition: Acceptance is unequivocal assent to the terms of the offer.
Mode of Acceptance:
Bilateral Acceptance: Accomplished through a return promise.
Unilateral Acceptance: Accomplished through the requested performance.
Mirror Image Rule: Under common law, acceptance must match the offer exactly. Any changed or added term operates as a counteroffer.
Silence as Acceptance: Silence is generally not acceptance. Recognized exceptions include:
Course of dealing between the parties.
Receipt of goods with an opportunity to reject them.
Knowledge that payment is expected.
Prior agreement between parties that silence constitutes acceptance.
Mailbox Rule: The default rule is that a properly dispatched acceptance is effective when sent (dispatched), not when received, unless the offer specifies otherwise or an exception applies.
Example: If Jones properly mails an acceptance on Tuesday and Smith attempts to revoke on Wednesday, the contract was already formed on Tuesday.
Electronic Signatures: Electronic signatures are legally valid. A contract is not automatically invalid because a signature is not handwritten in ink. Other contract requirements and statutory rules still apply.
Consideration and Enforcement Rules
Two Major Elements of Consideration:
Legally sufficient value.
A bargained-for exchange.
Forms of Legally Sufficient Value: May involve a benefit, a detriment, a promise to act, a promise to refrain from acting, or forbearance (giving up a legal right).
Case Reference (Hamer v. Sidway): Refraining from a legal right (forbearance) constitutes legally sufficient consideration.
Sufficiency vs. Adequacy of Consideration:
Sufficiency: Evaluates whether legally sufficient consideration exists.
Adequacy: Evaluates whether the items exchanged are economically equal. Courts generally do not require equal economic value unless the transaction raises concerns such as unconscionability.
Promises That Do Not Constitute Consideration:
Illusory Promise: Appears to be a promise but leaves the promisor with no real commitment.
Preexisting Duty: A promise to perform an action one is already legally obligated to do is generally not new consideration.
Past Consideration: An act completed prior to a later promise is not valid consideration (past consideration is no consideration).
Accord and Satisfaction:
Liquidated Debt: The debt amount is fixed, settled, and undisputed. Paying less than the full amount generally does not create an accord and satisfaction without new consideration.
Unliquidated Debt: The debt amount is disputed or uncertain. A compromise provides consideration because each side surrenders its right to pursue its disputed position.
Example: A contractor claims $10,000 and a customer claims $7,000. They agree to settle for $8,000. This compromise constitutes valid consideration.
Specific Legal Doctrines, Defenses, and Statutes
Non-Compete Agreements: Generally require three elements:
Consideration provided at the time of signing.
Protection of a legitimate business interest.
Reasonableness in scope, geography, and time.
Note: Non-compete law is highly jurisdiction- and time-dependent.
Statute of Frauds: Specifies that certain contracts must be in writing to be enforceable. Memory aid MY LEGS:
Marriage-related agreements
Year (contracts that cannot be performed within one year)
Land contracts
Executor agreements
Goods priced above the applicable UCC threshold
Suretyship (promising to pay the debt of another)
Part Performance: Serves as an exception to a writing requirement, particularly in land transactions, where substantial performance provides evidence that an agreement existed.
Capacity and Legality:
Capacity: Certain parties, such as minors and persons lacking sufficient mental capacity, have limited ability to form binding contracts.
Legality: The purpose of the agreement must be legal. Agreements to perform illegal acts are unenforceable.
Defenses to Enforcement:
Fraud: Intentional or reckless misrepresentation that induces reasonable reliance and causes harm.
Duress: Improper threats or coercion forcing a person into an agreement.
Undue Influence: Improper pressure or exploitation of a relationship of trust or dependence.
Mistake: Certain material mistakes can affect enforceability.
Improper Form: Missing a writing required by the Statute of Frauds.
Promissory Estoppel: Provides a legal remedy when traditional consideration is missing. Elements required:
Clear promise
Foreseeable reliance
Actual reliance
Detriment suffered
Enforcement required to avoid injustice
Unjust Enrichment / Quasi-Contract: Occurs when one party receives a benefit at another's expense and fairness or law prevents keeping it without payment. Associated with implied-in-law contracts. The standard remedy is quantum meruit (reasonable value of the benefit received).
Case Summaries and Problem Scenarios
Key Case Highlights:
Hamer v. Sidway: Giving up a legal right (forbearance) constitutes valid consideration.
Sho-Pro v. Brown: Focuses on consideration and legally sufficient consideration principles.
Travis v. V3 Express Carwash: Covers summary judgment, core contract elements, Statute of Frauds, part performance, fraud, promissory estoppel, and unjust enrichment.
Smith's Freezer Problem Scenarios:
Smith dies before Jones accepts; Jones is unaware of the death: Death generally terminates an offer automatically before acceptance. No contract is formed.
Smith promises to keep the offer open until Oct. 31: A promise to keep an offer open is generally revocable unless supported by consideration or an exception making it irrevocable.
Fire destroys the freezer before acceptance: Destruction of the specific subject matter terminates the offer. No contract is formed.
Jones pays $100 for a 30-day option; Smith dies; Jones accepts: The $100 payment creates a binding option contract. The offer is irrevocable during the 30-day option period, allowing Jones to exercise acceptance according to its terms despite Smith's death.
Lena Hospital Problem Scenario: An implied-in-fact contract may exist because Lena received medical care, was aware of the ongoing services, and could reasonably understand that payment was expected. If actual assent cannot be established, the agency could pursue recovery under unjust enrichment / quasi-contract for the reasonable value of the benefit.
Butler Roofing Problem Scenario: Analysis depends on whether Butler knew of and authorized the additional leak repair and whether circumstances objectively showed an expectation of payment. An implied-in-fact contract exists if conduct demonstrates assent. If no actual agreement existed, unjust enrichment provides an alternative theory if Butler knowingly retained a valuable benefit.
Summary Judgment Standard: Allows a court to resolve a case without a full trial when there is no genuine dispute of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Its core purpose is to avoid unnecessary trials when material facts are not genuinely disputed.
High-Priority Memorization List
Offer + Acceptance + Consideration + Capacity + Legality: Core contract elements.
Bilateral: Promise for a promise.
Unilateral: Promise for performance.
Express Contract: Terms explicitly stated.
Implied-in-Fact Contract: Assent inferred from conduct.
Implied-in-Law Contract: Imposed by court to prevent unjust enrichment.
Counteroffer: Changes terms and terminates the original offer under common law.
Mailbox Rule: Acceptance is generally effective when sent.
Silence: Generally not acceptance.
Preexisting Duty: Generally not legal consideration.
Past Consideration: Generally no consideration.
Forbearance: Giving up a legal right constitutes consideration.
Void: No enforceable contract ever existed.
Voidable: A protected party has the option to avoid enforcement.
Unenforceable: Legal rule or statute prevents enforcement.
Promissory Estoppel: Clear promise + foreseeable reliance + actual reliance + detriment + injustice avoided.
Quasi-Contract: Remedy to prevent unjust enrichment.
Statute of Frauds: Requires certain agreements to be in writing.
Questions and Discussion
Question 1: What are the five requirements for a valid and enforceable contract?
Answer: Offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity, and legality.
Question 2: What is the difference between bilateral and unilateral contracts?
Answer: Bilateral = promise for a promise. Unilateral = promise for an act/performance.
Question 3: What is the objective theory?
Answer: Courts generally determine intent from objective words and conduct rather than undisclosed subjective intent.
Question 4: What is the difference between implied-in-fact and implied-in-law contracts?
Answer: Implied-in-fact involves actual assent inferred from conduct. Implied-in-law is court-created to prevent unjust enrichment and does not require actual agreement.
Question 5: What is the Mirror Image Rule?
Answer: Under common law, acceptance must match the offer; a changed term generally creates a counteroffer.
Question 6: Is silence acceptance?
Answer: Generally no, subject to recognized exceptions.
Question 7: When is acceptance effective under the Mailbox Rule?
Answer: Generally when properly dispatched, unless an exception or different instruction applies.
Question 8: What are the two elements of consideration?
Answer: Legally sufficient value and a bargained-for exchange.
Question 9: Why is a preexisting duty not consideration?
Answer: The person is already legally obligated to perform, so no new legal detriment/value is exchanged.
Question 10: What is past consideration?
Answer: A prior act that was completed before the promise; generally it is not consideration.
Question 11: What is quantum meruit?
Answer: A remedy generally based on the reasonable value of services or benefits provided.
Question 12: What is the difference between void and voidable?
Answer: Void means no enforceable contract exists; voidable means a protected party can choose to avoid an otherwise existing contract.
One-Minute Review
Summary Equation:
Element Summaries:
Offer: Serious, definite, communicated.
Acceptance: Unequivocal / mirror image.
Consideration: Bargained-for legal value.
Capacity: Legally capable.
Legality: Legal purpose.
Key Operational Rules:
Bilateral = Promise for promise.
Unilateral = Promise for performance.
Implied-in-fact = Conduct + assent.
Implied-in-law = Court-created + unjust enrichment.
Mailbox Rule = Acceptance generally effective when sent.
Past Consideration = No consideration.
Preexisting Duty = No new consideration.
Forbearance = Can be valid consideration.