13_schller et al
Page 1
Evaluation of Alternative Drive Systems
Focus: Driving patterns in Germany, China, and Malaysia
Authors: M. Schüller, S. Tewiele, T. Bruckmann, D. Schramm
Institution: University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany
Email contacts are provided.
Abstract
Global mobility requirements are evolving towards environmental and resource conservation.
Automotive development is increasingly oriented towards alternative energy sources to lower emissions.
Emission reductions depend on various factors:
Energy mix structure
Climate conditions
Vehicle usage profile (trip numbers, durations, lengths, velocity distribution)
Real-world driving data from the German RuhrautoE project is analyzed to differentiate criteria between countries.
A comparison is drawn between costs and emissions, particularly between Germany and China, with a brief outlook on Malaysia.
Key Findings:
Consumption for alternative propulsion systems is generally higher in real driving conditions than NEDC test cycles.
In Germany and China, electric vehicles (EVs) present the lowest consumption costs. In Malaysia, LPG vehicles perform best.
EVs can reduce well-to-wheel emissions by 82% in Germany, but not in China due to high fossil fuel dependency in electricity generation.
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) shows EVs are not always financially viable across all countries discussed.
Keywords
Green energy technology, electric mobility, driving patterns, total cost of ownership, China, Malaysia, drive train.
Page 2
Introduction
Urbanization and population growth increase mobility demands, leading to higher energy consumption and CO2 emissions.
This creates a global challenge for sustainable mobility solutions.
Current vehicle strategies prioritize:
Optimization of conventional drives
Development of alternative and electric drive systems
User behavior impacts energy consumption based on road type, driving conditions, etc., necessitating real usage profiles for accurate data.
Cost analysis incorporates:
Purchase costs
Maintenance costs
Operation costs (Total Costs of Ownership or TCO models)
TCO varies greatly across regions due to differences in cost structures.
Methods and Materials
Dataset
Driving data collected via GPS in Germany's Rhine-Ruhr region, representative of a major urban area.
Total of 40,000 km recorded over 3,300 trips, capturing details like velocity and location.
A mix of EVs and hybrids used in a car-sharing program allows for diverse driving style representation.
Page 3
Vehicle Propulsion Systems
The study compares:
Conventional vehicles
Alternative fuel vehicles
Electric and hybrid vehicles
All models used are based on real vehicle series, with some fictitious for powertrain comparisons.
Different parameters based on propulsion included for comparability.
Mass models assess the effect of alternative drive integration on vehicle weight and required battery sizes.
Evaluation Criteria
Evaluated based on:
Energy consumption
Emissions
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Assumes electric vehicles can complete trips independently of battery capacity, always fully charged at the trip’s start.
Consumption Overview
Real driving data provides a more accurate representation of fuel and electricity consumption.
Comparative analysis uses unit costs derived from regional pricing, with significant differences in fuel costs between Germany and China.
Page 4
Emissions
Global legislative focus on vehicle emissions, particularly greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
Gasoline and diesel emissions must consider both direct tank-to-wheel (TTW) and indirect well-to-tank (WTT) impacts.
Comparison of GHG emissions in Germany and China reveal higher Chinese emissions due to fossil integrity in energy mix.
Well-to-Wheel Emission Factors
Fuel Type | Germany | China |
|---|---|---|
Diesel | 3.150 kgCO2e/l | 3.635 kgCO2e/l |
Gasoline | 2.800 kgCO2e/l | 3.109 kgCO2e/l |
LPG | 1.900 kgCO2e/l | 2.002 kgCO2e/l |
CNG | 3.070 kgCO2e/kg | 4.234 kgCO2e/kg |
Electricity | 0.593 kgCO2e/kWh | 0.982 kgCO2e/kWh |
Page 5
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
TCO evaluated over a 12-year period with 25,000 km annual mileage.
Includes:
Purchase prices
Costs varying significantly between Germany and China due to local pricing frames.
Assumptions taken for TCO models for different vehicle types including ICEs, PHEVs, and BEVs.
Purchase Costs
Type | Germany | China |
|---|---|---|
ICEV (Gasoline) | Average | |
BEV | Higher due to import taxes | |
PHEV | High |
Page 6
Additional Costs
Considering maintenance, insurance, and operational costs in TCO.
High variability in policy and market between countries affects TCO predictions.
Key Insight: In many scenarios, EVs remain costlier than conventional options over period evaluated despite lower operational costs.
Page 7
Results and Discussion
Consumption Analysis: Real data shows ICEVs and BEVs consume significantly more than NEDC standards, while PHEVs show reduced consumption due to higher electric run.
Emission Analysis: Germany becomes a strong market for electrification due to its cleaner energy mix, while China faces challenges in transitioning to a sustainable solution due to fossil dependency.
Page 8
Yearly TCO Calculation
Comparative costs highlight the financial burden associated with BEVs and PHEVs when matched against conventional vehicles, notably in China.
Subsidies in China enhance EV’s attractiveness but they still face profitability challenges compared to ICEs.
Page 9
Proposal for Malaysia
Limited real-world studies on alternative drives in Malaysia prompt a necessity for assessing local patterns.
Preliminary costs indicate cheaper operational costs for BEVs but still high purchase prices based on import taxation.
Malaysian Energy Mix and Emissions
Predominantly coal and natural gas, with modest renewable contributions.
Future Projections: The development of renewables is slow, posing challenges for GHG mitigation strategies.
Page 10
Excise Duties and TCO in Malaysia
Duties: High excise charges based on engine displacement vastly inflate the cost of imported vehicles in Malaysia.
Insurance: Compulsory and optional coverages add to the financial burden for prospective vehicle owners.
Page 11
Conclusions
The study emphasizes the importance of local conditions for evaluating vehicle drive systems.
Real-world driving data provides insights suggesting that while electrics can lower fuel costs, emissions reduction in coal-heavy regions requires significant energy mix transitions.
Final note: The viability of EVs heavily weighs on local energy policies, economic conditions, and historical trends in vehicle adoption.