Introduction to Research Designs and Paradigms
Learning Outcomes and Presentation Scope
By the end of this presentation, learners will be able to perform the following:
Define the concepts related to research design.
Outline both quantitative and qualitative research designs.
Differentiate between research design and research methodology.
Differentiate between research design and research methods.
Critique research designs within various research papers.
Select the appropriate research design for a specific research problem.
Key Terminological Distinctions
Methodology:
This represents the theoritical or philosophical position of the study that informs the choice of research methods and techniques used to collect and analyze data.
Design:
This constitutes the plan used to answer the specific research questions.
Methods:
This refers to the strategy used to implement the plan, described as "the doing part" of the research.
Approach:
This signifies the type of research being conducted. Examples include:
Qualitative.
Quantitative.
Mixed methods.
Multi-methods.
Conceptualizing Research Design
Definition of Research Design:
A research design is defined as a blueprint intended to guide the research process. It lays out the specific steps for moving from the initial research purpose or questions to the final outcomes (Abutabenjeh and Jaradat, 2018).
Structural Hierarchy:
Research designs are categorized under general research approaches. These approaches flow directly from the researcher's chosen philosophical positions or methodology.
Primary Approaches:
Qualitative.
Quantitative.
Mixed methods.
Multi-methods.
Characteristics of Qualitative Research Designs
Primary Focus:
Qualitative designs focus on exploring meaning or understanding a process.
Variable Measurement:
Variables in these designs are measured qualitatively rather than numerically.
Focus Areas:
Perceptions.
Experiences.
Social interactions.
Beliefs.
Attitudes.
Grounded Theory
Scope:
Grounded theory focuses on social structures, social interactions, and specific processes.
Research Example: Ramirez and Badger (2014).
Objective: To explore the social-psychological processes of men suffering from depression.
Outcome: The researchers uncovered distinct stages through which men navigated during their experiences with depression.
Phenomenological Studies
Scope:
These studies focus on the "lived experience," meaning, essence, and individual experiences of a phenomenon.
Research Example: Enwall and co-researchers (2014).
Methodology: Conducted in-depth interviews.
Objective: To explore the lived experience of suffering from recurring ovarian cancer.
Ethnographic Studies
+Scope:
Ethnography investigates culture, cultural behavior, roles, and lifeways.
Research Example: Broadbent and colleagues (2014).
Methodology: Conducted fieldwork.
Objective: To investigate the emergency department triage environment and how that environment effects triage practices for clients with mental illness.
Narrative Design
Definition:
Narrative inquiry is a qualitative research form where the stories themselves serve as the raw data for the study.
Applications:
This design is utilized across many disciplines to gain insights into culture, historical experiences, identity, and specific lifestyles.
Case Study Design
Core Concept:
The case study approach enables in-depth, multi-faceted explorations of complex issues within their real-life settings.
Design Philosophy:
It is based on the need to explore an event or phenomenon in depth within its natural context.
Because of this focus on context, it is sometimes referred to as a "naturalistic" design.
Functional Uses:
Case studies can be employed to explain, describe, or explore phenomena in the everyday contexts in which they naturally occur.
Descriptive Designs
Core Purpose:
The goal is to provide straightforward descriptions of perceptions and experiences (Sandelowski, 2010).
Context of Use:
They are particularly useful in research areas where very little is currently known about the topic under investigation.
Presentation of Findings:
This design is considered the most appropriate when the researcher wants to present findings in a way that directly reflects or closely resembles the terminology used in the original research question.
Analysis Level:
No deep or complex analysis of data is performed in these designs.