Study Notes for Torts 1: Intentional Torts and the Distinction Between Trespass and Case.
2021LAW/7721LAW: Torts 1 - Week 2, Module 1: Intentional Torts and the Distinction Between Trespass and Case
Module Overview
Trimester: 1, 2021
Focus: This module explores intentional torts, particularly distinguishing between trespass and case.
Objectives
By the end of this topic, students will:
Introduce the difference between trespass and case.
Understand, identify, and discuss the tort of passing off.
Apply the elements of passing off in practical scenarios.
Understand the relevance of the doctrine of precedent and the hierarchy of courts when answering hypothetical questions.
Continue to develop legal reasoning skills and the ability to solve hypothetical problems.
Prepare a letter to a client as part of practical application.
Required Readings
Textbook: Focus Torts
9th edition: Chapter 16 (pp. 845 – 848)
8th edition: Chapter 16 (pp. 849 – 852)
Key Concepts
Trespass and Case
Historical Context:
Definition: Refers to a writ in respect of forcible interference with a person or their property which may disturb the king's peace.
Trespass:
Characterized as:
Direct: Involves immediate interference with rights.
Actionable per se: No proof of damage suffered is required (i.e., the mere act is enough for an action).
Action on the Case:
Originally termed as trespass on the case.
Characterized as:
Indirect: Involves a more remote or indirect action causing harm.
Damage must be suffered: Legal action is contingent on demonstrable damage.
Geographic Distinctions
England:
Trespass: Refers primarily to intentional actions.
Action on the Case: Concerns unintentional actions.
Australia:
Trespass: Identified as direct actions.
Action on the Case: Identified as indirect actions.
General Principles:
Cases of negligence may also be categorized under either trespass or case, indicating direct unintentional interference causing damage.
Classification of Torts
Intentional, Negligent, and Strict Liability Torts:
Trespass:
Now considered a term encompassing a category of torts with overlapping requirements (such as trespass to land, trespass to goods, and trespass to the person).
Intentional Torts:
Require an intentional act, but not the intention to cause damage.
Negligence:
Based on a breach of duty; need not be intentional, but requires actual damage.
Strict Liability:
A category where liability is assigned regardless of fault or intention.