Study Notes for Torts 1: Intentional Torts and the Distinction Between Trespass and Case.

2021LAW/7721LAW: Torts 1 - Week 2, Module 1: Intentional Torts and the Distinction Between Trespass and Case

Module Overview

  • Trimester: 1, 2021

  • Focus: This module explores intentional torts, particularly distinguishing between trespass and case.

Objectives

By the end of this topic, students will:

  • Introduce the difference between trespass and case.

  • Understand, identify, and discuss the tort of passing off.

  • Apply the elements of passing off in practical scenarios.

  • Understand the relevance of the doctrine of precedent and the hierarchy of courts when answering hypothetical questions.

  • Continue to develop legal reasoning skills and the ability to solve hypothetical problems.

  • Prepare a letter to a client as part of practical application.

Required Readings

  • Textbook: Focus Torts

    • 9th edition: Chapter 16 (pp. 845 – 848)

    • 8th edition: Chapter 16 (pp. 849 – 852)

Key Concepts

Trespass and Case
  • Historical Context:

    • Definition: Refers to a writ in respect of forcible interference with a person or their property which may disturb the king's peace.

    • Trespass:

      • Characterized as:

      • Direct: Involves immediate interference with rights.

      • Actionable per se: No proof of damage suffered is required (i.e., the mere act is enough for an action).

    • Action on the Case:

      • Originally termed as trespass on the case.

      • Characterized as:

      • Indirect: Involves a more remote or indirect action causing harm.

      • Damage must be suffered: Legal action is contingent on demonstrable damage.

Geographic Distinctions
  • England:

    • Trespass: Refers primarily to intentional actions.

    • Action on the Case: Concerns unintentional actions.

  • Australia:

    • Trespass: Identified as direct actions.

    • Action on the Case: Identified as indirect actions.

  • General Principles:

    • Cases of negligence may also be categorized under either trespass or case, indicating direct unintentional interference causing damage.

Classification of Torts
  • Intentional, Negligent, and Strict Liability Torts:

    • Trespass:

    • Now considered a term encompassing a category of torts with overlapping requirements (such as trespass to land, trespass to goods, and trespass to the person).

    • Intentional Torts:

    • Require an intentional act, but not the intention to cause damage.

    • Negligence:

    • Based on a breach of duty; need not be intentional, but requires actual damage.

    • Strict Liability:

    • A category where liability is assigned regardless of fault or intention.