LGBTQ Biases and Structural Challenges in Criminal Jury Trials

Legal Status, Civil Rights, and Disparities in Everyday Life

  • Recent Legal Advancements:

    • In Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), the United States Supreme Court recognized the fundamental constitutional right of same-sex couples to marry.
    • Approximately 2020 states and the District of Columbia have enacted comprehensive civil rights statutes that prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity across employment, housing, and public accommodations.
  • Persistent Inequalities and Systemic Vulnerability:

    • Despite statutory advances, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) individuals routinely face systemic marginalization and discrimination in employment, housing, education, and access to commercial public spaces.
    • Within the criminal justice system, persistent structural obstacles and cultural prejudices continue to undermine institutional legitimacy, due process, and equal protection for LGBTQ individuals appearing as defendants, victims, witnesses, or prospective jurors.

Historical Criminalization and Decriminalization of LGBTQ Identities

  • Universal Sodomy Prohibitions:

    • Prior to 1961, sodomy was criminalized in every state in the United States.
    • While sodomy statutes were written with varying scope, law enforcement enforced them disproportionately against gay men and lesbians, creating an enduring societal conflation of nonheterosexual identity with inherent criminality.
  • Municipal Anti-Cross-Dressing Ordinances:

    • Transgender and gender-nonconforming individuals were systematically criminalized under municipal ordinances prohibiting cross-dressing or public gender nonconformity.
    • These ordinances were legally grounded in doctrines treating transgender individuals as fraudulent, deceitful, and direct threats to the established public order for transgressing binary gender norms.
  • The Decriminalization Trajectory:

    • The decriminalization movement commenced in 1961, propelled significantly during the 1970s when over 2020 states adopted the American Law Institute's Model Penal Code in whole or in part.
    • Bowers v. Hardwick (1986): The US Supreme Court dealt a severe setback to gay rights by upholding the constitutionality of Georgia's criminal sodomy statute. This decision halted federal judicial challenges across more than 2020 states and prompted several state supreme courts to affirm state-level prohibitions.
    • Between 1986 and 2003, progressive state legislative repeals and state constitutional court rulings eliminated sodomy laws in multiple jurisdictions, reducing the number of states retaining such laws to 1313 by 2003.
    • Lawrence v. Texas (2003): The US Supreme Court explicitly overruled Hardwick, striking down remaining sodomy laws to the extent that they applied to private, consensual, noncommercial sexual conduct between consenting adults.
    • Contemporary Residual Statutes: Approximately 1212 states have never formally repealed their unconstitutional sodomy statutes from the penal code. Law enforcement personnel continue to occasionally enforce these defunct provisions in discriminatory and unconstitutional manners against LGBTQ individuals.

Psychiatric Pathologization and the Legacy of "Sexual Psychopath" Laws

  • Pathologization in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM):

    • During the 1940s, evolving clinical concepts of psychopathy merged with an emerging medical consensus defining homosexuality as a distinct psychological illness.
    • In 1952, the American Psychiatric Association (APA) codified homosexuality as a mental disorder in the first edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). At this time, medical classifications conflated nonheterosexual sexual orientations with non-cisgender gender identities.
  • State Sexual Psychopath Legislation:

    • Between the 1940s and early 1970s, more than half of US states passed "sexual psychopath laws," which enabled the mandatory incarceration and indeterminate involuntary civil commitment of LGBTQ persons.
    • Certain statutes empowered juries to declare any criminally charged defendant a "sexual psychopath," remanding them into the custody of state public health departments until "cured."
    • Other jurisdictions authorized the civil commitment of individuals identified as sexual psychopaths indefinitely, irrespective of whether an actual crime had been committed or charged.
    • Although nominally addressing violent offenses such as rape or child molestation, these laws were disproportionately weaponized against LGBTQ individuals, cementing cultural stereotypes of queer people as predatory sexual deviants.
    • To avert penal confinement under sodomy statutes or indefinite civil commitment under sexual psychopath statutes, many individuals underwent involuntary, invasive psychiatric procedures designed to alter their sexual orientation or gender presentation.
  • De-Pathologization Reforms for Sexual Orientation:

    • The APA removed homosexuality from the DSM in 1973, coinciding with widespread state-level repeals of sexual psychopath legislation during the early 1970s.
    • Empirical Research Influence: Groundbreaking empirical investigations by Alfred Kinsey and Evelyn Hooker refuted the illness model. Kinsey's surveys (1948, 1953) established that same-sex sexual behaviors were widespread throughout the general population. Hooker's objective psychological testing (1955–1965) demonstrated that nonheterosexual men exhibited no inherent personality maladjustment or elevated psychological pathology relative to heterosexual controls.
    • Activist Interventions: Early homophile groups (the Mattachine Society, the Daughters of Bilitis) fostered scientific dialogue in the 1950s. By 1971, radicalized activists—influenced by the broader Civil Rights and anti-war movements—directly disrupted the APA's annual convention, compelling the formal psychiatric reassessment and 1973 declassification.
  • Evolution of Diagnostic Labels for Gender Identity:

    • The 1973 DSM de-pathologization did not extend to transgender identity. In 1980, the APA introduced "gender identity disorders" into the DSM.
    • In 2013, the APA replaced "gender identity disorders" with "gender dysphoria" in the DSM. This diagnostic evolution was explicitly designed to mitigate pathologizing stigma for individuals whose gender identity does not align with their sex assigned at birth, while preserving institutional medical coverage for gender-affirming healthcare interventions.

Empirical Research on Anti-LGBTQ Bias and Discrimination in Court Systems

  • The Lambda Legal National Study (2014):

    • Administered a nationwide survey of N=2,376N = 2{,}376 LGBTQ individuals and persons living with HIV assessing courtroom experiences.
    • 43%43\% (n=965n = 965) had participated directly in the court system within the previous 55 years as attorneys, litigants, jurors, or witnesses.
    • 19%19\% of court-involved participants reported hearing a judge, trial attorney, or judicial staff member make overtly disparaging remarks regarding their own or someone else's sexual orientation or gender identity.
    • Intersectional Disparities in Hearing Negative Judicial Remarks:
      • Respondents with physical or mental disabilities: 24%24\%;
      • Low-income respondents: 28%28\%;
      • Respondents of color: 30%30\%;
      • Transgender and gender-nonconforming (GNC) respondents: 33%33\%;
      • Transgender and GNC respondents of color: 53%53\%.
    • Irrelevant Inquiries and Nonconsensual Outing:
      • 16%16\% of court-involved respondents reported having their sexual orientation or gender identity injected into proceedings despite complete irrelevance to legal issues.
      • 11%11\% experienced nonconsensual public disclosure ("outing") in open court.
      • Subgroup breakdown for irrelevant disclosure: disabled (25%25\%), low-income (28%28\%), people of color (25%25\%), transgender/GNC (26%26\%).
      • Subgroup breakdown for nonconsensual outing: disabled (16%16\%), low-income (20%20\%), people of color (14%14\%), transgender/GNC (21%21\%).
    • Role-Based Disparities (Sample: 19%19\% attorneys, 44%44\% jurors, 61%61\% parties, 21%21\% witnesses):
      • Hearing discriminatory language: attorneys (32%32\%), witnesses (28%28\%), parties (22%22\%), jurors (12%12\%).
      • Irrelevant disclosure of sexual orientation/gender identity: witnesses (30%30\%), parties (24%24\%), attorneys (13%13\%), jurors (7%7\%).
  • California State Courts Study (Judicial Council of California, 2001):

    • Surveyed 1,2251{,}225 lesbian and gay court users alongside 1,5251{,}525 court employees (6464 of whom identified as lesbian, gay, or bisexual).
    • Court User Findings:
      • Nearly half (∼50%\sim 50\%) concluded California courts failed to provide fair treatment to gay men and lesbians;
      • 56%56\% personally witnessed or experienced negative anti-gay comments or actions;
      • In cases where sexual orientation was raised: 56%56\% preferred not to disclose their sexual orientation, 29%29\% had their sexual orientation disclosed by third parties without permission, and 25%25\% felt legally compelled to disclose against their wishes;
      • 38%38\% felt actively threatened in the courtroom environment due to their sexual orientation.
    • Court Employee Findings:
      • 20%20\% (one in five) witnessed derogatory language directed at sexual minorities in open court by judicial officers, lawyers, or court staff;
      • Outside open court, court personnel observed anti-gay ridicule or jokes (32%32\%), negative comments (28%28\%), and derogatory slurs (21%21\%);
      • LGB court personnel were nearly 4×4\times more likely to report experiencing hostile, anti-LGBTQ actions or comments than heterosexual personnel.
  • New Jersey Supreme Court Task Force Study (2001):

    • Surveyed N=2,594N = 2{,}594 legal professionals and court personnel (1,9171{,}917 disclosed sexual orientation: 93%93\% heterosexual, 6%6\% gay/lesbian, <1%<1\% bisexual).
    • LGB respondents were almost 7×7\times more likely than heterosexual peers to report direct observations or experiences of anti-gay bias against litigants or witnesses.
    • Offensive remarks and anti-gay humor constituted the most widely observed expressions of bias.
    • Impact on Substantive Outcomes: 61%61\% of LGB respondents who participated in court litigation believed sexual orientation bias affected the substantive legal outcome of the cases, compared to only 6%6\% of heterosexual respondents. Disparities remained consistent across criminal, civil, and domestic relations proceedings.

Constitutional Guarantees and LGBTQ Challenges in Criminal Jury Selection

  • Sixth Amendment Standards of Juror Impartiality:

    • The Sixth Amendment guarantees criminal defendants an "impartial jury."
    • The Supreme Court operationalizes impartiality through two distinct doctrinal prongs: selecting jurors who can conscientiously and properly apply substantive law to trial evidence (Lockhart v. McCree, 1986), and drawing the venire from a representative, fair cross-section of the local community (Taylor v. Louisiana, 1975).
  • The Dual Screening Architecture of Voir Dire:

    • Challenges for Cause: Counsel may make an unlimited number of challenges to excuse prospective jurors who demonstrate statutory disqualification, lack mental or physical capacity, or manifest actual bias that prevents impartial evaluation of trial evidence.
      • Certain trial courts sustain cause challenges when a prospective juror's anti-LGBTQ prejudice prevents neutral deliberation.
      • Other courts deny cause challenges if the juror undergoes judicial "rehabilitative questioning"—wherein prospective jurors who voice anti-LGBTQ animus affirm upon direct judicial inquiry that they can set aside their personal beliefs to weigh evidence objectively.
    • Peremptory Challenges: A strictly allotted number of strikes exercisable without presenting legal cause or explanation.
  • Constitutional Jurisprudence of Peremptory Challenges:

    • Batson v. Kentucky (1986): Prohibited peremptory strikes based upon the race of prospective jurors under the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause.
    • J.E.B. v. Alabama ex rel. T.B. (1994): Extended the Batson framework to bar peremptory strikes predicated on biological gender.
    • The US Supreme Court has not resolved whether Batson extends to sexual orientation or gender identity.
    • SmithKline Beecham Corp. v. Abbott Laboratories (9th Cir. 2014): The first federal appellate ruling holding that Batson prohibits peremptory strikes based on sexual orientation. This precedent applies solely to federal civil and criminal trials across the nine states within the Ninth Circuit.
    • State-Level Protections: Statutory bans on sexual orientation-based peremptory challenges exist in four states (California, Colorado, Minnesota, and Oregon), accompanied by narrow state appellate rulings in a small number of additional jurisdictions.
    • Federal Legislative Attempts: Congressional measures—specifically the Jury ACCESS Act and the Juror Non-Discrimination Act (reintroduced in March 2017)—seek to codify federal statutory protections barring discrimination in jury selection based on sexual orientation or gender identity. In most state and federal courts, however, striking jurors based on LGBTQ identity remains legally permissible.

Questioning Strategies and Typologies of Anti-LGBTQ Juror Bias

  • Triggers for Inquiring Into LGBTQ Issues During Voir Dire:

    • Cases involving charges inherently connected to sexuality or gender identity (e.g., anti-LGBTQ hate crimes);
    • Cases where LGBTQ identity is legally irrelevant to the charges, but trial evidence, testimony, or party identification will reveal that a defendant, victim, or primary witness is LGBTQ;
    • Cases where an openly LGBTQ individual is summoned into the venire, raising peers-of-one's-community representation concerns.
  • Risks Associated with Voir Dire on LGBTQ Topics:

    • Inquiring into sexual orientation or gender identity infringes on prospective jurors' privacy, particularly given that queer identities are often invisible or nonobvious;
    • Questioning can inadvertently out a previously closeted victim, defendant, or trial witness against their express will;
    • Questioning risks highlighting LGBTQ or LGBTQ-allied jurors, exposing them to targeted, discriminatory peremptory strikes by opposing counsel.
  • Lee's Typology of Homophobic Jurors (2008):

    • Category 1 (Explicit Homophobes): Venirepersons who exhibit conscious anti-LGBTQ prejudice and openly articulate moral, religious, or personal disapproval during judicial questioning.
    • Category 2 (Closet Homophobes): Venirepersons who hold conscious anti-LGBTQ antipathy but deliberately mask their attitudes during open-court voir dire due to social desirability pressures.
    • Category 3 (Implicit Homophobes): Venirepersons who genuinely endorse abstract values of legal equality but harbor subconscious implicit biases that systematically disadvantage LGBTQ individuals during evaluation of evidence.
  • Three Comparative Voir Dire Questioning Frameworks:

    • 1. "Hard" (Pointed) Questioning: Employs direct, confrontational questions concerning controversial socio-political topics (e.g., asking if a photograph of two men kissing provokes discomfort, or probing stances on same-sex marriage and hate crime statutes). Effective for exposing Category 1 (explicit) homophobes, but wholly ineffective for detecting Category 2 or 3 jurors, while exposing LGBTQ-supportive jurors to peremptory strikes.
    • 2. "Soft" Questioning: Focuses on noncontroversial, normative baseline inquiries (e.g., inquiring whether jurors would mind living next to a same-sex couple, working alongside a gay colleague, or allowing employment discrimination). Overland (2009) estimates that 10%10\% to 20%20\% of potential jurors openly answer affirmatively to these noncontroversial bias prompts.
    • 3. "Proxy" Questioning: Based on Sherrod and Nardi's (1998) empirical study of N>3,500N > 3{,}500 adults across 1515 states. Rather than inquiring directly about homophobia, counsel queries demographic, lifestyle, and philosophical markers.
      • Strongest statistical predictors of elevated anti-gay bias: lack of close lesbian or gay personal friends, rigid adherence to traditional/old-fashioned values, political conservatism, and regular weekly attendance at religious services.
      • Serves as an effective tool for identifying Category 2 (closet) and Category 3 (implicit) homophobes who would otherwise evade hard or soft direct questioning.

The Gay and Trans "Panic" Defenses: Mechanics, Case Law, and Reform

  • Doctrinal Architecture of Panic Defenses:

    • Gay and trans panic defenses are not independent, freestanding affirmative defenses. Rather, they operate as evidentiary arguments advanced to satisfy elements of traditional, established criminal defenses:
      • Provocation (Heat of Passion): The defendant contends that the revelation, discovery, or potential disclosure of the victim's sexual orientation or gender identity constituted adequate provocation sufficient to cause a reasonable person to lose self-control and kill in a sudden heat of passion, downgrading murder to voluntary manslaughter.
      • Diminished Capacity: The defendant asserts that the discovery or potential disclosure of the victim's LGBTQ identity triggered an acute mental breakdown or temporary psychiatric defect, negating the requisite specific intent or malice aforethought.
      • Self-Defense: The defendant claims that the discovery or potential disclosure of the victim's LGBTQ identity generated an honest, objectively reasonable belief that they were in imminent peril of death or serious bodily injury, thereby justifying lethal defensive force against a nonviolent advance.
    • Theoretical Genesis: The defenses derive historically from the 1920s clinical concept of "homosexual panic disorder"—initially formulated to categorize acute psychological distress exhibited by World War I veterans fighting latent same-sex desires. In the 1960s, criminal defense attorneys introduced the concept to argue that nonviolent same-sex romantic advances induced catastrophic, blameless panic.
  • Prevalence in Judicial Opinions:

    • Research by the Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law indicates that gay and trans panic defenses have been formally asserted in published court opinions across approximately half of US states.
    • Because the vast majority of state criminal trials do not produce published judicial opinions, and because acquitted defendants or those convicted of lesser charges do not appeal, published appellate opinions substantially underestimate the true prevalence of the defense.
  • The Gwen Araujo Case (People v. Merel, 2009):

    • In October 2002, 17-year-old transgender teenager Gwen Araujo was killed at a California gathering by four men. Two of the men had engaged in consensual sexual intimacy with Araujo. When she declined vaginal intercourse, the men suspected she was biologically male. Upon forcibly confirming her birth sex, the four men subjected Araujo to an extended beating, strangulation, bludgeoning with a shovel and can, tied her wrists and ankles, wrapped her body in bedding, and buried her in a remote campsite 100100 miles away.
    • At trial, two defendants asserted the trans panic provocation defense, asserting that discovering Araujo was biologically male induced an uncontrollable heat of passion.
    • First Trial: The jury deadlocked on whether to convict of first-degree or second-degree murder, producing a mistrial.
    • Retrial: The jury accepted the panic defense framing, acquitting two defendants of first-degree murder and hate crime allegations, returning verdicts of second-degree murder. The third co-defendant ultimately entered a negotiated plea to voluntary manslaughter, while the fourth had pled to manslaughter in exchange for state testimony.
  • Legislative and Institutional Interventions:

    • Gwen Araujo Justice for Victims Act (California, 2006): The first state statutory measure addressing panic arguments, authorizing judges to give explicit curative jury instructions that bias, prejudice, or animus based on sexual orientation or gender identity must not infect juror deliberations.
    • American Bar Association Resolution 113A (2013): Formally urged federal, state, local, and tribal legislative bodies to enact statutes banning the use of gay and trans panic arguments.
    • California Penal Code Section 192(f)(1) (2014 Amendment): California formally banned panic defenses by redefining voluntary manslaughter: for purposes of sudden quarrel or heat of passion, provocation is legally and objectively unreasonable if it resulted from the discovery of, knowledge about, or potential disclosure of the victim's actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
    • Broader National Landscape: Illinois subsequently enacted similar statutory prohibitions, with related measures introduced in multiple other states; nevertheless, gay and trans panic defenses remain legally valid in the overwhelming majority of American jurisdictions.
  • Proposed Doctrinal Solutions:

    • Critique of Total Bans (Lee, 2008, 2013): Cynthia Lee cautions that completely banning the defense may drive criminal defense practitioners to deploy subtle, covert, or coded homophobic and transphobic tropes that are harder to identify and rebut. Lee advocates aggressive voir dire bias extraction coupled with direct prosecution arguments during opening and closing statements that deconstruct heteronormative double standards.
    • The LGBTQ "Shield Rule" Model (Strader et al., 2015): An evidence-based mechanism modeled on rape shield statutes that bars admissibility of: (1) evidence of a victim's prior sexual history beyond the immediate transaction; (2) evidence of a victim's sexual orientation or gender identity offered to prove they incited the defendant; and (3) reputation or opinion evidence concerning the victim's sexual conduct or identity. A key advantage of this model is its structural applicability across non-homicide criminal charges, such as battery or assault.

Empirical Findings on Mock Juror Decision-Making in Panic Defense Cases

  • Ragatz and Russell (2010) Provocation Experiment:

    • Investigated defendant sex, defendant sexual orientation, and mock juror sex in a sample of over 450450 online participants evaluating a heat-of-passion domestic homicide involving infidelity.
    • Heterosexual defendants were rated significantly higher than gay or lesbian defendants on satisfying the legal criteria necessary to establish provocation or mitigating circumstances.
    • Lesbian defendants were rated the lowest of all groups in satisfying mitigating legal elements, demonstrating that jurors show greater willingness to reduce homicide charges to manslaughter for heterosexual perpetrators than for sexual minorities.
  • Salerno et al. (2015) Political Ideology and Moral Outrage Study:

    • Examined N=74N = 74 jury-eligible, multiethnic adults randomized to evaluate a homicide trial involving either a gay panic claim (lethal retaliation to a nonviolent same-sex advance) or a baseline non-gay-panic provocation claim.
    • Conservative mock jurors exhibited significantly lower punitiveness toward defendants in the gay panic condition than toward defendants in the control provocation condition.
    • The gay panic defense produced no significant shift in punitiveness among liberal jurors.
    • Mechanistic Mediator: Mediational analysis revealed that differences were governed by levels of moral outrage. Conservative jurors experienced significantly reduced moral outrage toward a killer when the victim made a same-sex advance, whereas liberal jurors maintained uniform moral outrage irrespective of the victim's sexual orientation.

Anti-LGBTQ Bias in Specific Criminal Case Contexts: Hate Crimes, Intimate Partner Violence, and Sexual Offenses

  • Bias and Challenges in Hate Crime Prosecutions:

    • Statutory Gaps: As of May 2018, only 1717 states and the District of Columbia maintained hate crime legislation covering both sexual orientation and gender identity, while 1313 states protected sexual orientation exclusively.
    • Prevalence and Underreporting: In 2016, official FBI Uniform Crime Reporting documented over 1,3001{,}300 anti-LGBTQ hate crime victims, representing approximately 20%20\% of all federally reported bias crimes. Due to historical police abuses and well-documented mistrust of criminal authorities, these statistics undercount true victim prevalence.
    • Mock Juror Perception Studies: Plumm et al. (2010) presented mock jurors with a hate crime trial varying crime venue (local bar vs. gay bar) and victim "provocation" (buying a drink, placing an arm around the defendant, asking the defendant to dance):
      • Jurors harboring favorable baseline attitudes toward the LGBTQ community attributed significantly less blame to the victim;
      • When crimes occurred in a gay bar, jurors attributed heightened culpability to the defendant and decreased culpability to the victim;
      • The presence of nonviolent social "provocation" significantly increased mock juror attribution of blame to the victim, regardless of physical venue;
      • Extralegal factors—including preexisting homophobia, physical environment, and benign social interaction—routinely contaminate juror assessments of legal guilt.
    • Systemic Gatekeeping: Severe evidentiary burdens requiring prosecutors to prove subjective bias motive beyond a reasonable doubt, paired with heavy caseloads, routinely cause prosecutors to dismiss hate crime enhancements or trade them away during plea bargaining.
  • Bias in Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Cases:

    • Although intimate partner violence occurs within LGBTQ relationships at rates comparable to or exceeding those in heterosexual relationships, it is chronically overlooked by institutional actors.
    • Mock Juror Double Standards: Wasarhaley et al. (2015) and Poorman et al. (2003) demonstrated that jurors evaluate domestic disputes through heteronormative assumptions. When female same-sex partners do not conform to traditional male-aggressor and female-victim archetypes, jurors systematically minimize trauma, blame victims, and doubt lesbian victims' credibility.
    • Institutional Vulnerability: Statutes in several states fail to cover or explicitly exclude same-sex intimate partners from obtaining civil protection orders (ABA, 2014). LGBTQ parents experiencing IPV frequently refrain from seeking judicial intervention out of fear that prejudiced judges will terminate their parental rights.
  • Bias in Sexual Offense Adjudications:

    • Child Sexual Abuse Prosecutions: Historic pathologization created an enduring stereotype conflating homosexuality with pedophilia. Wiley and Bottoms (2009, 2013) demonstrated that mock jurors presented with identical case facts were significantly more likely to convict a defendant of child sexual abuse if the defendant was described as gay rather than heterosexual.
      • Gay defendants were assigned higher guilt probabilities, lower perceived credibility, and heightened legal culpability;
      • Participants who reported higher levels of religiosity or possessed stronger baseline anti-gay prejudices showed the highest probability of convicting gay defendants on ambiguous evidence.
    • Adult Sexual Assault Prosecutions: Hill (2000) demonstrated that mock jurors assigned the highest rates of criminal guilt when a gay male defendant was accused of sexually assaulting a heterosexual male victim, but assigned the lowest guilt ratings when a gay male defendant was accused of assaulting another gay man. Mock jurors also attribute more blame to LGBTQ rape victims and characterize sexual violence against them as less legally serious (Davies & Rogers, 2006; Davies & Hudson, 2011).
    • Undercover Lewd Conduct Stings: Police departments have historically utilized undercover entrapment stings targeting men seeking sex in public or semi-public spaces. Most defendants plead guilty to avoid public outing and family humiliation. In cases that reach trial, the entrapment defense requires proving lack of "predisposition" to commit the offense. Juries assessing predisposition evaluate the defendant's character and moral reputation, allowing juror prejudice against gay men to dictate convictions.