UNIT 3: Civil Liberties & Civil Rights
Civil Liberties
Roots: The Bill of Rights
Difference
Civil liberties - protections from the gov (ex. Bill of Rights)
Civil rights - protections by the gov (14th Amend)
Views on the Bill of Rights
Fed: against
Unnecessary
Dangerous
Impractical
Anti-Fed: for
Needed
Prevent an oppressive government
Distrust of central power
Compromise
9th Amend - rights not specifically listed in the Const belong to the people
10th Amend - powers not delegated to the fed gov are reserved for st or the pppl
14 Amend - st are still under the incorporation doctrine
states cannot deprive ppl of stuff w/o due process
substantive: fundamental rights not explicit in the Const
states must guarantee the rights stated in the Bill of Rights
selective incorporation: only “fundamental” rights are applied to states on case by case
fundamental rights: rights protected by the bill of rights
[mf] Warren Court: expanding civ lib through selective incorp
The First Amendment - Religion
The Establishment Clause - no fed religion
Lemon test:
legitimate secular purpose
neither advances nor inhibits relig
does not foster excessive gov entanglement w/ relig
The Free Exercise Clause - prohibits US gov from interfering with a citizen’s right to practice their relig
Engel v. Vitea (1962)
NY authorized short, voluntary prayer
Ruled in favor of Engel; the prayer violated the Establishment Clause
Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972)
Amish parents refuse to send kids to school past 8th grade
Law ruled unconstitutional, violating the Free Exercise Clause
The First Amendment - Speech & Press
Limits
Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798 laws that restrict speech critical of the government and allow President to deport dangerous non-citizens
Prior Restraint - limiting speech or expression before it occurs is deemed unconstitutional
Slavery: suppression against abolitionists
Suspension of the writ of habeas corpus (custodian of a person in custody must bring them to court)
Espionage Act (1917) - interfering w/ military operations or supporting US enemies is treason
Clear and Present Danger Test - allows the gov to restrict speech that poses a clear threat to national security
Direct Incitement Test - speech is protected unless it incites imminent lawless action
Schenck v. US (1919)
Schenck disturbed leaflets urging resistance to the draft
Ruled against Schenck; his actions threatened “clear and present danger”
New York Times Co v. US (1971)
Gov attempted to block publication of Pentagon papers that revealed how the American public was misled
Ruled in favor of NYT
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969)
Students wore black armbands to school to protest the Vietnam War, and were suspended; Tinker family challenged it
Ruled in favor of the Tinkers; schools do not overrule their right to free speech
Protected forms of speech
Symbolic speech - nonverbal or nonwritten actions
Hate speech - offensive discourse targeting a group or individual based on inherent characteristics and that may threaten social peace
Unprotected forms of speech
Libel - written statements that defame a person
Slander - untrue statements that defame a person
Fighting words - words that inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of peace
Obscenity - material that is offensive and lacks serious value
Roots (Second Amendment): The Bill of Rights
Alterations
US v. Miller (1939): the government can regulate firearm modification
DC v. Heller (2008): the individual’s right to possess firearms for self-defense
McDonald v. Chicago (2010)
Chicago banned handguns
Ruled in favor of McDonald; the Second Amendment is incorporated into state doctrine
Protections for the accused
Writ of Habeas Corpus
Ex Post Facto laws - no laws that retroactively change punishments
Bills of attainder - laws that pro
Due process Rights
4 Am - protection against unreasonable searches and seizures
5 Am - protects against self-incrim and double jeopardy
6 Am - guarantees a fair trial including the right to counsel and an impartial jury
8 Am - prohibits cruel and unusual punishment
Searches w/o a Warrant (allowed)
Exceptions include consent, plain view, exigent circumstances, and lawful arrests
“Reasonable suspicion”: allows limited searches
“Stop-and-frisk”: A brief, non-intrusive police stop and pat-down for weapons
Aspects of the 5 Am: self-incrimination
Grand jury: citizens that determine whether there is enough evidence for a trail
“Pleading the fifth”: exercising the right to self-incriminate
Miranda v. Arizona (1966)
Ernesto Mirada confessed to crimes being informed of his rights
Ruled in favor of Miranda; alleged criminals must be made aware of their rights
Burger Court
In contrast to the prior Warren Court, reflected judicial restraint
Aspects of the 5 Am: Double Jeopardy
Prevents individuals from being tried twice for the same offense in the same jurisdiction
The Exclusionary Rule
Def: police cannot use illegally seized evidence at trial
Aspect of the 6 Am: the right to counsel
Gideon v. Wainwright (1963)
Gideon accused of stealing and denied counsel in a trial
Ruled in favor of Gideon; citizens have a right to a lawyer (public defender)
Aspect of the 6 Am: jury trials
“impartial” jurors: a group of the accused’s peers who act as fact-finding, deliberative body to determine guilt or innocence
Peremptory challenges - challenges that don’t need causes (used to discriminate)
Right to confront witnesses (not absolute) - you can, but don’t have to, be in the same room and see who is accusing you
8 Am: cruel and unusual punishments
Question of constitutionality (Death penalty and life sentences, solitary confinement)
Protecting the wrongly convicted (DNA testing, federal appeals)
9 Am: implied rights
Privacy (abortion)
Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) - birth control
Roe v. Wade (1965) - women have a right to abortion
Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) - greater regulation of abortion
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022) - overturned Roe v. Wade
LGBTQ+
Lawrence v. Texas (2003) - struck down laws against same-sex intimacy
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) - right to same-sex marriage
Reforms to combat terroism (post-9/11)
USA PATRIOT Act (2001) - greater surveillance, impacting the 1 and 4 Am
Violates free speech
Respect for religious practices were ignored
Violates protection from unreasonable search and seizrue
Military Commissions Acts - limited habeas corpus
Guantanamo Bay Detentions - concerns abt indefinite detention
Testing the limits of liberties
Civil Rights
Roots: First Civil
Figures and Events
F Douglas - abolition
E Cady Stanton and L Mott - womans rights conv at Seneca Falls
Seneca Falls Conv (1848) - prod the declaration of sentiments
Scott v. Sanford (1857)
Dred Scott argued that because he lived on free land, we became a free man
Ruled in favor of Sanford; blacks can’t argue in the Supreme Court because they aren’t ppl (obviously)
Civil War
Emancipation Proclamation freed slaves in Confed states
13 Am - abolished slavery
More
14 Am - equal prot under the law
15 Am - af am can vote
Poll taxes - voting restrictions targeting af am
Grandfather clause - exempted certain voters from literacy tests based on ancestry
S B. Anthony - leader in women’s suffrage
Civil Rights Act of 1875 - outlawed racial discrim in pub places
Jim Crow Laws - enforced racial seg
Plessy v. Ferguson
Plessy argued that having train cars separated by race is bad
Rules in favor of Ferguson; establishes “separate but equal”
Suffrage
National Am Woman Suffrage Association (NASWA): creates by S B. Anthony in 1890
National Woman’s Party (NWP): militant suffrage organization 1915
19 Am - white women can vote
Equality
The NAACP challenged the constitutionality of Jim Crow laws w/ test cases
NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund (LDF) was the legal arm of the NAACP that litigated Brown V. Board n other civil rights cases
Thurgood Marshall - leading civil rights leader
Brown v. Board of Education
Brown argued that segregating public education is unconstitutional
Ruled in favor of Brown; “separate but equal” is inherently unequal
Legal protections for Civil Rights
School Desegregration
Public schools proceed to desegregate “with all deliberate speed”
Little Rock Nine faced resistance; Eisenhower sent fed troops’
Montgomery Bus Boycott
Rosa Parks - NAACP youth adviser, challenged constitutionality of segregated buses
MLK Jr. - led the Montgomery Improvement Association, proponent of nonviolence
African-American led movement to boycott the bus system demonstrating the power of nonviolent protest
New Groups
SNCC (Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee) played a crucial role in the Civil Rights Movement, empowering young activists and organizing grassroots efforts like Freedom Ride
SCLC (Southern Christian Leadership Conference), led by MLKJ, was a cornerstone of the Civil Rights Movement
Civil Rights Act of 1964
Passed under JFK who embraced civil rights
Wide ranging leg that outlawed segregation
No discrimination in voting
Barred discrimination in public accommodations
Authorized DOJ to sue → desegregate public facilities
Provided withholding of fed funds
No discrimination in empl*yment based on race, creed, color, religion, nation of origin, or sex
EEOC to monitor and enforce bans on empl*yment discrimination'
Title VII: Addressed w*rkplace
Sexual harassment is sex discrim (diff sex, same sex)
Law firms are also included
Voluntary programs to redress historical sex discrimination
Title IX: provisions that bar educational institutions that receive fed funds to discriminate against female students
School boards are held accountable for harassment
Retaliatory lawsuit by coaches for their sports team
Remedies for Sex Disc
National Organization for Women (NOW) advocates for gender equality
Equal Pay Act of 1963
Smaller (but still present) wage gap b/w man and women
Equal Rights Amendment
Prop in every Congress since 1923
US and states cannot deny equality based on race and sex
Other Groups
Hispanic Am
LULAC is the largest Hispanic advocacy org.
Dolores Huerta and Cesar Chavez organized the United Farm Workers Union
MALDEF (similar to the NAACP) brought test cases to SCOTUS to undo Hispanic Am discrim
American Ind
Disenfranchised
NARF (similar to the NAACP)
Asian Am
Chinese Exclusion Act prohibit Chinese immigration in 1882
Korematsu v. US (1994) validates jap internment
Civil Liberties Act redressed these atrocities in 1988
Freedom of expression, in every area we can