UNIT 3: Civil Liberties & Civil Rights

Civil Liberties

Roots: The Bill of Rights

  • Difference

    • Civil liberties - protections from the gov (ex. Bill of Rights)

    • Civil rights - protections by the gov (14th Amend)

  • Views on the Bill of Rights

    • Fed: against

      • Unnecessary

      • Dangerous

      • Impractical

    • Anti-Fed: for

      • Needed

      • Prevent an oppressive government

      • Distrust of central power

    • Compromise

      • 9th Amend - rights not specifically listed in the Const belong to the people

      • 10th Amend - powers not delegated to the fed gov are reserved for st or the pppl

      • 14 Amend - st are still under the incorporation doctrine

        • states cannot deprive ppl of stuff w/o due process

          • substantive: fundamental rights not explicit in the Const

        • states must guarantee the rights stated in the Bill of Rights

        • selective incorporation: only “fundamental” rights are applied to states on case by case

        • fundamental rights: rights protected by the bill of rights

        • [mf] Warren Court: expanding civ lib through selective incorp

The First Amendment - Religion

  • The Establishment Clause - no fed religion

    • Lemon test:

      1. legitimate secular purpose

      2. neither advances nor inhibits relig

      3. does not foster excessive gov entanglement w/ relig

  • The Free Exercise Clause - prohibits US gov from interfering with a citizen’s right to practice their relig

  • Engel v. Vitea (1962)

    • NY authorized short, voluntary prayer

    • Ruled in favor of Engel; the prayer violated the Establishment Clause

  • Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972)

    • Amish parents refuse to send kids to school past 8th grade

    • Law ruled unconstitutional, violating the Free Exercise Clause

The First Amendment - Speech & Press

  • Limits

    • Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798 laws that restrict speech critical of the government and allow President to deport dangerous non-citizens

      • Prior Restraint - limiting speech or expression before it occurs is deemed unconstitutional

    • Slavery: suppression against abolitionists

    • Suspension of the writ of habeas corpus (custodian of a person in custody must bring them to court)

    • Espionage Act (1917) - interfering w/ military operations or supporting US enemies is treason

    • Clear and Present Danger Test - allows the gov to restrict speech that poses a clear threat to national security

    • Direct Incitement Test - speech is protected unless it incites imminent lawless action

  • Schenck v. US (1919)

    • Schenck disturbed leaflets urging resistance to the draft

    • Ruled against Schenck; his actions threatened “clear and present danger”

  • New York Times Co v. US (1971)

    • Gov attempted to block publication of Pentagon papers that revealed how the American public was misled

    • Ruled in favor of NYT

  • Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969)

    • Students wore black armbands to school to protest the Vietnam War, and were suspended; Tinker family challenged it

    • Ruled in favor of the Tinkers; schools do not overrule their right to free speech

  • Protected forms of speech

    • Symbolic speech - nonverbal or nonwritten actions

    • Hate speech - offensive discourse targeting a group or individual based on inherent characteristics and that may threaten social peace

  • Unprotected forms of speech

    • Libel - written statements that defame a person

    • Slander - untrue statements that defame a person

    • Fighting words - words that inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of peace

    • Obscenity - material that is offensive and lacks serious value


Roots (Second Amendment): The Bill of Rights

  • Alterations

    • US v. Miller (1939): the government can regulate firearm modification

    • DC v. Heller (2008): the individual’s right to possess firearms for self-defense

  • McDonald v. Chicago (2010)

    • Chicago banned handguns

    • Ruled in favor of McDonald; the Second Amendment is incorporated into state doctrine

  • Protections for the accused

    • Writ of Habeas Corpus

    • Ex Post Facto laws - no laws that retroactively change punishments

    • Bills of attainder - laws that pro

  • Due process Rights

    • 4 Am - protection against unreasonable searches and seizures

    • 5 Am - protects against self-incrim and double jeopardy

    • 6 Am - guarantees a fair trial including the right to counsel and an impartial jury

    • 8 Am - prohibits cruel and unusual punishment

  • Searches w/o a Warrant (allowed)

    • Exceptions include consent, plain view, exigent circumstances, and lawful arrests

    • “Reasonable suspicion”: allows limited searches

    • “Stop-and-frisk”: A brief, non-intrusive police stop and pat-down for weapons

  • Aspects of the 5 Am: self-incrimination

    • Grand jury: citizens that determine whether there is enough evidence for a trail

    • “Pleading the fifth”: exercising the right to self-incriminate

    • Miranda v. Arizona (1966)

      • Ernesto Mirada confessed to crimes being informed of his rights

      • Ruled in favor of Miranda; alleged criminals must be made aware of their rights

  • Burger Court

    • In contrast to the prior Warren Court, reflected judicial restraint

  • Aspects of the 5 Am: Double Jeopardy

    • Prevents individuals from being tried twice for the same offense in the same jurisdiction

  • The Exclusionary Rule

    • Def: police cannot use illegally seized evidence at trial

  • Aspect of the 6 Am: the right to counsel

    • Gideon v. Wainwright (1963)

      • Gideon accused of stealing and denied counsel in a trial

      • Ruled in favor of Gideon; citizens have a right to a lawyer (public defender)

  • Aspect of the 6 Am: jury trials

    • “impartial” jurors: a group of the accused’s peers who act as fact-finding, deliberative body to determine guilt or innocence

    • Peremptory challenges - challenges that don’t need causes (used to discriminate)

    • Right to confront witnesses (not absolute) - you can, but don’t have to, be in the same room and see who is accusing you

  • 8 Am: cruel and unusual punishments

    • Question of constitutionality (Death penalty and life sentences, solitary confinement)

    • Protecting the wrongly convicted (DNA testing, federal appeals)

  • 9 Am: implied rights

    • Privacy (abortion)

      • Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) - birth control

      • Roe v. Wade (1965) - women have a right to abortion

      • Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) - greater regulation of abortion

      • Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022) - overturned Roe v. Wade

    • LGBTQ+

      • Lawrence v. Texas (2003) - struck down laws against same-sex intimacy

      • Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) - right to same-sex marriage

  • Reforms to combat terroism (post-9/11)

    • USA PATRIOT Act (2001) - greater surveillance, impacting the 1 and 4 Am

      • Violates free speech

      • Respect for religious practices were ignored

      • Violates protection from unreasonable search and seizrue

    • Military Commissions Acts - limited habeas corpus

    • Guantanamo Bay Detentions - concerns abt indefinite detention

Testing the limits of liberties

Civil Rights

Roots: First Civil

  • Figures and Events

    • F Douglas - abolition

    • E Cady Stanton and L Mott - womans rights conv at Seneca Falls

      • Seneca Falls Conv (1848) - prod the declaration of sentiments

    • Scott v. Sanford (1857)

      • Dred Scott argued that because he lived on free land, we became a free man

      • Ruled in favor of Sanford; blacks can’t argue in the Supreme Court because they aren’t ppl (obviously)

    • Civil War

      • Emancipation Proclamation freed slaves in Confed states

      • 13 Am - abolished slavery

    • More

      • 14 Am - equal prot under the law

      • 15 Am - af am can vote

        • Poll taxes - voting restrictions targeting af am

        • Grandfather clause - exempted certain voters from literacy tests based on ancestry

      • S B. Anthony - leader in women’s suffrage

      • Civil Rights Act of 1875 - outlawed racial discrim in pub places

      • Jim Crow Laws - enforced racial seg

    • Plessy v. Ferguson

      • Plessy argued that having train cars separated by race is bad

      • Rules in favor of Ferguson; establishes “separate but equal”

    • Suffrage

      • National Am Woman Suffrage Association (NASWA): creates by S B. Anthony in 1890

      • National Woman’s Party (NWP): militant suffrage organization 1915

      • 19 Am - white women can vote

    • Equality

      • The NAACP challenged the constitutionality of Jim Crow laws w/ test cases

      • NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund (LDF) was the legal arm of the NAACP that litigated Brown V. Board n other civil rights cases

      • Thurgood Marshall - leading civil rights leader

    • Brown v. Board of Education

      • Brown argued that segregating public education is unconstitutional

      • Ruled in favor of Brown; “separate but equal” is inherently unequal

    • Legal protections for Civil Rights

      • School Desegregration

        • Public schools proceed to desegregate “with all deliberate speed”

        • Little Rock Nine faced resistance; Eisenhower sent fed troops’

      • Montgomery Bus Boycott

        • Rosa Parks - NAACP youth adviser, challenged constitutionality of segregated buses

        • MLK Jr. - led the Montgomery Improvement Association, proponent of nonviolence

        • African-American led movement to boycott the bus system demonstrating the power of nonviolent protest

      • New Groups

        • SNCC (Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee) played a crucial role in the Civil Rights Movement, empowering young activists and organizing grassroots efforts like Freedom Ride

        • SCLC (Southern Christian Leadership Conference), led by MLKJ, was a cornerstone of the Civil Rights Movement

    • Civil Rights Act of 1964

      • Passed under JFK who embraced civil rights

      • Wide ranging leg that outlawed segregation

        • No discrimination in voting

        • Barred discrimination in public accommodations

        • Authorized DOJ to sue → desegregate public facilities

        • Provided withholding of fed funds

        • No discrimination in empl*yment based on race, creed, color, religion, nation of origin, or sex

        • EEOC to monitor and enforce bans on empl*yment discrimination'

      • Title VII: Addressed w*rkplace

        • Sexual harassment is sex discrim (diff sex, same sex)

        • Law firms are also included

        • Voluntary programs to redress historical sex discrimination

      • Title IX: provisions that bar educational institutions that receive fed funds to discriminate against female students

        • School boards are held accountable for harassment

        • Retaliatory lawsuit by coaches for their sports team

    • Remedies for Sex Disc

      • National Organization for Women (NOW) advocates for gender equality

      • Equal Pay Act of 1963

        • Smaller (but still present) wage gap b/w man and women

      • Equal Rights Amendment

        • Prop in every Congress since 1923

        • US and states cannot deny equality based on race and sex

Other Groups

  • Hispanic Am

    • LULAC is the largest Hispanic advocacy org.

    • Dolores Huerta and Cesar Chavez organized the United Farm Workers Union

    • MALDEF (similar to the NAACP) brought test cases to SCOTUS to undo Hispanic Am discrim

  • American Ind

    • Disenfranchised

    • NARF (similar to the NAACP)

  • Asian Am

    • Chinese Exclusion Act prohibit Chinese immigration in 1882

    • Korematsu v. US (1994) validates jap internment

    • Civil Liberties Act redressed these atrocities in 1988

Freedom of expression, in every area we can