Study Notes on Environmental Influence vs. Genetics in Psychology

The Role of Environment vs. Genetics in Human Development

Introduction

  • Debate exists regarding whether biology (genetics) or experiences (environment) play a more crucial role in shaping individuals.

  • Notable opposition to the idea of genetics determining destiny comes from psychologist John Watson.

John Watson and Behaviorism

  • Watson argues against eugenics, which posits that human beings are bound by their genetic makeup.

  • He contends that humans are predominantly shaped by their environment, suggesting that genetics do not predetermine behavior.

  • The concept of tabula rasa (blank slate):

    • Watson believes that individuals are born as empty vessels, and nearly all behaviors, including instinctual ones such as fear, are learned through experiences.

  • To provide evidence for his theories, Watson conducts a significant experiment on an infant known as Little Albert.

The Little Albert Experiment

  • The experiment is designed to demonstrate that fears can be conditioned rather than inherited.

  • Initial Observations:

    • Little Albert shows no fear towards a burning newspaper or a white rat upon their first encounters.

  • Conditioning Phase:

    • Watson repeatedly presents the rat while producing a loud clanging noise, something that distresses Albert.

    • This pairing of the rat with a disturbing noise leads to a learned fear of the rat and generalization to all furry objects.

  • In Watson’s conclusion, the success of this experiment supports his theory that fears are learned behaviors.

Popularization of Behaviorism

  • Watson coins the term Behaviorism and advocates for an active parental role in shaping children's environments.

  • He views the home as a laboratory where parents can scientifically shape their children.

B.F. Skinner and Operant Conditioning

  • Building on Watson's work, psychologist B.F. Skinner further investigates the importance of environment in behavior development.

  • Skinner postulates that altering the environment can effectively change individual behaviors.

  • Skinner's Background:

    • Skinner was inventive during his childhood, creating gadgets to improve daily tasks.

  • During World War II, he developed a device for the US military that involved training pigeons to guide missiles, although the military did not implement it at that time.

Core Concepts of Operant Conditioning

  • Definition: Operant conditioning is a learning process through which the consequences of a behavior either strengthen or weaken that behavior.

  • Experiment with Pigeons:

    • Skinner uses hungry pigeons in controlled environments to demonstrate operant conditioning.

    • As the pigeon moves randomly, specific movements (e.g., turning its head) are positively reinforced with food.

    • Over time, pigeons learn to perform more complex behaviors through reinforcement, ultimately demonstrating that behaviors can be conditioned step by step.

Implications for Human Behavior

  • Skinner believes the principles of operant conditioning, which successfully train pigeons, can also be applied to humans.

  • Educational Success:

    • Education can be enhanced by breaking down complex tasks into smaller steps and reinforcing behavior positively, demonstrating the extensibility of Skinner’s theories.

  • Philosophical View: Skinner's work leads to the idea that humans can be developed in countless ways when environments are manipulated correctly.

Aggressive Modeling and Social Learning

  • Children exposed to aggressive modeling demonstrate increased attraction to guns and hostile behaviors.

  • Contrary to prior beliefs, observing aggression does not drain aggressive impulses but instead reinforces and can increase them.

  • Relevant experiments reveal that children who witnessed aggressive behaviors adopted that language and behavior patterns when interacting with play materials.

Gender and Stereotypes in Play

  • An observational study of children interacting with toys highlights how gender stereotypes influence choice.

  • Example of a child initially assigned a sex (e.g. 'girl') modifies their play behavior and perceptions, indicating underlying societal conditioning.

  • Key Takeaway: Even subconscious factors, such as gender norms, influence individual preferences and reactions in play settings.