The Pronunciation of Difference and Racism in Language
The Pronunciation of Difference
Introduction to Racism and Inequality
Racist Acts in Society:
Examples of racist behavior include an angry man yelling at a restaurant employee for speaking Spanish, a white woman calling the police on her Black neighbor's child, and a baseball player mocking an Asian player.
Ubiquity of Racism:
Such incidents are prevalent and recorded in videos, reflecting the belief that racism is entrenched in American society despite views that suggest its resolution post-Civil Rights Movement or after the election of Barack Obama.
Questions arise about how individuals perceive racism as a diminishing issue in the face of overwhelming evidence.
Individual Racists vs. Systemic Racism
Folk Theory of Racism:
Jane Hill (2008) describes the notion that racial inequality stems solely from individual acts committed by racists, which implies that the decline of individual racists will lead to a total eradication of racism.
This viewpoint diverts attention from the broader institutional, structural, and systemic roots of racism, as articulated by Feagin & McKinney (2005).
Institutional Racism:
Racial inequality is embedded in social structures; thus, social systems perpetuate “color-blind racism” (Bonilla-Silva, 2003), where racism is denied under the guise of fairness.
Institutions, not just individuals, are responsible for maintaining inequalities across various social domains such as education, healthcare, and justice.
The Complicity of Society
Impact of Viral Racist Behavior Videos:
These videos can create a false sense of progress by making individuals feel superior to those shown in the footage, supporting the belief that they are separate from the problem of racism.
Rather than addressing the systemic issues, individuals may feel content with merely not identifying as a racist.
Distracting Discussions:
Adam Hodges (2016) discusses the “hunt for racists language game” which focuses on identifying individual racists and thus distracts from broader patterns of structural racism.
The Role of Language in Racism
Language and Racism:
Language serves dual roles in both perpetuating and resisting racism. It is essential for understanding how societal inequality is produced, reproduced, and negotiated.
The language surrounding events, such as the killing of Trayvon Martin in 2012, has lasting implications.
Trayvon Martin Case:
Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch member, fatally shot Martin, unarmed and merely holding snacks.
The 911 call and the portrayal of Zimmerman as a white man illustrate societal racial narratives that oversimplify complex issues.
Media Representation & Misinterpretation:
Media focused on Zimmerman's alleged utterance of a slur escalated the situation beyond its systemic context.
Discussions about the term “cracker” and what it imputed on Martin's racial stance further perpetuated misguided views based on folk theory.
Impact of Language Variations
Rachel Jeantel’s Testimony:
Linguists Rickford and King (2016) analyzed Jeantel’s non-standard English, showing that her variation was structured and rule-based but misinterpreted by jurors.
Jurors biases based on her language resulted in ignoring her testimony, demonstrating how societal expectations of language can reproduce inequalities.
Language as a Tool of Social Inequality:
Language is not just a means of communication but shapes perceptions based on race, leading to differential treatment.
Discourse Structural Racism
Discourse vs. Discourse:
Linguists distinguish between “little-d discourse” (everyday interactions) and “big-D Discourse” (broad narratives influencing societal norms).
Each can reinforce or challenge societal racism, as shown in the media response to Trayvon Martin's case.
Racial Discourse and Its Consequences
Perceived Threat and Fear:
Racial discourse fosters fear of Blackness, affecting social interactions and potentially justifying violence against Black individuals in hypothetical situations described in media narratives.
The Black Lives Matter Movement:
Founded in 2013 to address violence against Black communities and challenge societal disregard for Black lives.
The phrase “Black Lives Matter” serves as a linguistic counter-narrative, demanding recognition of Black humanity.
Linguistic Variation and Social Perception
Volume, Speaking Rate, and More:
The volume and speed of speech, along with lexical choices, carry significant social meanings which can affect perceptions of a speaker's identity.
Understanding Language Ideology:
Language ideologies, according to Irvine (1989), encompass belief systems reflecting social and linguistic relationships which have moral/political interests attached.
Language-Specific Stereotypes:
Prejudices against certain dialects, accents, and pronunciations often bear socio-economic implications.
Historical Context of Language and Racism
The Legacy of Racism:
The historical context provides a backdrop for understanding current racial ideologies, illustrated through events like the Red Summer of 1919.
Lynching and mass violence against African Americans serve as a dark reminder of entrenched discrimination.
1915’s Birth of a Nation:
The film reintroduced racist stereotypes, leading to increased violence against African Americans, evident in various forms of discrimination today.
Conclusion: Race, Language, and Social Dynamics
Inextricable Ties:
The connections between language and racial perceptions are evident across multiple societal systems, including education, healthcare, and criminal justice.
Understanding how language underpins social dynamics is crucial in addressing and resisting forms of racism and discrimination.