Notes on Audit Scope Limitations and Qualified Opinions

Conditions Beyond Client's Control

  • Instances affecting accounting records include:

  • Loss, destruction, or indefinite seizure by authorities.

  • Timing and Nature of Auditor’s Work:

  • Auditors may be appointed after client’s balance sheet date.

  • This can hinder evidence collection on opening inventory due to:

    • Cutoff procedures may not be feasible.
    • Physical examination of inventory may be limited.

Auditors and Client-Imposed Scope Restrictions

  • CAS 705 (Par. 11-13): Highlights the escalated actions auditors should take in response to a client-imposed scope limitation.

  • Important procedures are not possible, contributing to the risk associated with obtaining evidence.

  • Qualified Opinion:

  • When evidence concerning completeness of revenues (e.g., donations for non-profits) is lacking, auditors issue a qualified opinion.

  • Example:

    • Great Cause Charity Foundation illustrates a situation where revenue verification was limited.

Figure 19-9: Opinion Due to Scope Limitation

  • Qualified Opinion:

  • The report retains the unmodified opening paragraph.

  • Basis for Qualified Opinion:

  • Revenue from fundraising activities isn’t verifiable.

  • Verification limited to amounts recorded in financial records.

  • As a result, auditors couldn't determine necessary adjustments for:

    • Revenues
    • Excess of revenue over expenses in statements
    • Current and net assets in financial position statements.

Conclusion of Audit Report

  • Qualified Opinion Summary:
  • "Except for possible effects of matters in the Basis for Qualified Opinion, the financial statements present fairly the financial position of Great Cause Foundation as at August 31, 2024."
  • Adherence to Canadian accounting standards for not-for-profit organizations is noted in the conclusion.