Untitled
Partnerships for Ethical Decision-Making
The session begins with the significance of partnering with various colleges and organizations to facilitate discussions on ethics and decision-making. This collaboration is aimed at providing participants with tools not only for personal decision-making but also for facilitating ethical decisions in group settings.
Introduction of the Change Student Ethics Committee
The Change Student Ethics Committee is highlighted as a student-led initiative that fosters discussions and engagements about ethics on a student-to-student basis.
The speaker expresses personal admiration for this committee, emphasizing their role in the broader conversation about ethical practices.
Defining Ethics
To engage effectively in discussions about ethics, a functional definition is necessary. Ethics can be complex and includes various dimensions.
Engaging Activities to Explore Experiences
Participants are prompted to share their experiences learning to drive to initiate a sense of connection and engagement.
Questions include making and model of the car, year it was made, and where they learned to drive, to assess the diversity of experiences.
Example Questions:
Raise your hand if:
The car you learned to drive was silver, blue, white, made by an American automaker, or a Japanese automaker.
You learned to drive stick.
This exercise illustrates the differences in experiences and backgrounds, paralleling how individuals develop ethical understanding.
Comparison: Learning to Drive and Ethical Decision Making
The speaker draws an analogy between learning to drive and learning to make ethical decisions.
Two Key Points:
Everyone learns to make decisions from different sources and contexts, just as individuals learn to drive on diverse vehicles.
The variation in experiences results in different approaches to decision-making, particularly ethical ones.
Addressing Resistance to Discuss Ethics
The speaker anticipates potential reluctance from participants, questioning the relevance of ethics discussions due to differing opinions.
A parallel to driving is made: all individuals share roads and rely on shared understanding (like traffic laws and lines) as part of communal ethics in decision-making.
Understanding Ethics: Root Origins
Ethics is derived from both Latin and Greek roots.
Greek Root: Ethos
Definition: Ethos relates to character.
Discussion points include qualities that define a person: personality, values, decision-making processes, and behaviors.
Latin Root: Mores
Definition: Mores pertains to customs and traditions.
Traditions are identified as repeated collective decisions that shape community identity, with examples from Clemson University.
Conceptualizing Ethics in Decision-Making
Ethics Defined
A working definition is framed: Ethics in personal and professional contexts involves utilizing one’s character, values, and upbringing to guide repeated decision-making.
Initial Skill Level in Ethical Decision-Making
Participants are acknowledged for their existing skills in ethical decision-making, emphasizing their development as students at Clemson.
Ethical evaluations are often complex and do not always have straightforward solutions, raising the idea of ethical dilemmas.
Ethical Dilemmas
An ethical dilemma involves a scenario where the right course of action isn’t clear, often requiring trade-offs and difficult choices.
Examples might include political decision-making where interests of different parties conflict even when both claim to aim for the good of society.
STAR Model for Ethical Decision-Making
The STAR Model is an effective four-step framework employed to tackle ethical dilemmas:
Step 1: Stop
Identifying the ethical issues.
Recognizing stakeholders involved.
Generating multiple possible solutions to the problem.
Step 2: Test
Applying questions to evaluate the potential solutions based on ethical standards to determine the best course of action.
Tests Include:
Harm Test: Identifying which option does the least harm to stakeholders.
Legality Test: Assessing if the solution complies with legal standards and guidelines.
Precedent Test: Considering whether the chosen course of action sets a problematic precedent.
Respect Test: Evaluating if respected individuals would approve of the decision.
Golden Rule Test: Considering how stakeholders would feel if they were on the receiving end of the decision.
Peer/Colleague Test: Gathering opinions from trusted colleagues about the proposed solutions.
Step 3: Act
The importance of executing the chosen solution effectively is emphasized, including communication strategies to advocate the choice made.
Step 4: Reflect
After an action has been taken, reflecting on outcomes helps assess what worked well, what did not, and how the process could be improved in future decision-making scenarios.
Practical Application of the STAR Model
Scenario Overview
Participants are assigned as assistant project managers at Delta Build amid a construction project that faces a shipment delay.
Crisis involves the need to decide on materials and timelines collaboratively, balancing stakeholder expectations.
Group Work on Ethical Issues
Groups identify ethical issues such as safety, time constraints, costs, and stakeholder communications.
Stakeholders include students, faculty, alumni, company leadership, and the public.
Various solutions such as consulting a structural engineer, delaying the project, and redesigning the project are brainstormed and discussed.
Testing Solutions
Participants conduct tests on chosen solutions to assess their viability, legality, and ethical integrity.
Reflection on Ethical Decision Making
Emphasis is placed on remaining vigilant about the trade-offs in decisions, particularly in environments with regulations and standards.
The role of effective communication and collaboration is also emphasized in convincing stakeholders of the chosen path.
These notes provide a thorough foundation in understanding ethical decision-making processes, utilizing the STAR model to navigate complex dilemmas effectively. The session highlights the importance of character, community customs, and collaborative practices in forming ethical judgments and facilitating strong decision-making skills in professional environments.