Money, Prices, and Inflation

Foundations of Money and the Asset Market

  • The Asset Market Framework:

    • The asset market represents the set of markets in which real assets and financial assets are traded.

    • Money is a specialized asset within this framework, defined specifically as assets utilized to make payments (such as physical currency and checking accounts).

    • The prices of all goods and services are measured in units of money that must be surrendered in exchange for them.

    • The total money supply determines the aggregate price level and the rate of inflation.

    • In addition to nominal variables, fluctuations in the money supply can affect real economic variables, such as aggregate output and employment.

  • Distinction from Related Economic Concepts:

    • Money vs. Income and Wealth: Money is not equivalent to income (which is a flow of earnings per unit of time) or wealth (the total stock of accumulated net assets).

    • Money vs. Credit and Debit Cards: Credit cards and debit cards serve as transaction mechanisms, but neither represents an asset in itself.

    • Credit Cards: A credit card purchase constitutes a promise to pay at a future date and is a form of credit. The accumulated liability must ultimately be settled using money via paper checks or electronic fund transfers.

    • Debit Cards: A debit card purchase serves as an electronic instruction directing a bank to transfer existing funds directly from a buyer's checking account to a seller, functioning as an electronic check.

  • Forms of Money and the Value Paradox:

    • Commodity Monies: Physical goods possessing intrinsic value that serve as money. Examples include gold and silver coins, cigarettes, stones, and beads. Gold and silver retain intrinsic non-monetary value through applications in jewelry fabrication and dental fillings.

    • Paper Monies: Fiat currencies, such as United States greenbacks, that lack intrinsic physical utility.

    • Cost vs. Face Value Discrepancy: The physical production cost of a unit of paper currency (such as a United States $1\$1 bill) is approximately 7.5 cents7.5\,\text{cents}, yet its exchange value is 100 cents100\,\text{cents}. The willingness of individuals to surrender 100 cents100\,\text{cents} of purchasing power or real goods for a paper note relies entirely on collective expectations of future acceptability.

Core Functions of Money

  • Medium of Exchange:

    • In the absence of money, all economic exchange must occur through barter, defined as the direct exchange of goods for other goods.

    • Barter transactions require a double coincidence of wants: the condition where Party A possesses what Party B desires, and Party B simultaneously possesses what Party A desires.

    • The double coincidence requirement makes barter highly inefficient and severely restricts trade volume.

    • Money eliminates the necessity of a double coincidence of wants because individuals accept it knowing it can be exchanged with third parties for desired commodities.

    • Historical Illustration: Cigarettes served as an accepted medium of exchange and standard currency within World War II prisoner-of-war (POW) camps.

  • Unit of Account:

    • Money provides the basic baseline measure for quantifying economic value across an entire economy.

    • In the United States, the monetary unit of account is the dollar (\), against which prices, wages, asset balances, and debt liabilities are denominated.

    • Utilizing a standardized, single unit of account dramatically simplifies price comparisons between distinct goods and avoids the computational burden of tracking bilateral relative exchange values between multiple competing currencies.

    • The efficiency gained from establishing a unified unit of account served as a primary economic rationale for creating the European Monetary Union.

    • A unit of account is typically chosen based on value stability. In nations experiencing rapid or unpredictable inflation, market participants routinely abandon domestic units of account in favor of stable foreign currencies (such as the United States dollar) for pricing goods and settling debts.

  • Store of Value:

    • Money provides a mechanism for transferring purchasing power and wealth across time.

    • While virtually any financial or real asset can function as a store of value, nonmonetary assets typically yield positive interest rates or returns, whereas physical money yields zero or near-zero nominal return.

    • The Portfolio Puzzle: Individuals willingly hold non-interest-bearing money because its superior liquidity and simultaneous roles as a medium of exchange and unit of account make holding it worthwhile, at least over short time horizons.

Definitions and Measurement of Monetary Aggregates

  • Categorization Challenges and Monetary Aggregates:

    • The boundary between monetary assets and nonmonetary liquid assets is fluid because various financial instruments provide varying degrees of transaction capability.

    • Money Market Mutual Funds (MMMFs): Pools of capital invested in short-term corporate and government debt instruments. They represent liquid, low-risk investments that frequently permit limited check-writing capabilities each month, blurring the distinction between savings and transaction accounts.

    • To accommodate these gradations, central banks compile official groupings of money termed monetary aggregates.

  • Official Measures of the Money Stock:

    • Monetary Base (High-Powered Money): The sum of all currency and coins in circulation within the nonbank public plus the total reserves held by commercial and private banks.

    • M1 (Narrow Money): The most liquid official classification of money stock. It comprises:

    • Physical currency in circulation outside banks.

    • Transaction (checking) accounts against which demand checks and debit orders can be drawn.

    • Savings accounts (which were formally integrated into M1 in 2021 after the Federal Reserve ceased maintaining regulatory distinctions between transaction deposits and savings deposits).

    • M2 (Broad Money): A broader measure encompassing all components of M1 plus assets that are readily convertible into transaction money. Specifically includes:

    • All components of M1.

    • Small-denomination time deposits (interest-bearing certificates of deposit under $100,000\$100{,}000 that require funds to be committed for a fixed duration).

    • Noninstitutional holdings of Money Market Mutual Funds (excluding institutional shares held by entities such as pension funds).

    • M3: A broader monetary aggregate that was discontinued by the Federal Reserve in 2006.

FRED chart showing total Monetary Base from 1960 to post-2020FRED chart showing M1 Money Stock from 1960 to post-2020FRED chart showing M2 Money Stock from 1960 to post-2020
  • Empirical Observations from Historical FRED Data:

    • In September 1981, total United States M2 money stock stood at $1,706.0 billion\$1{,}706.0\,\text{billion}.

    • The monetary base remained low and stable for decades before experiencing massive step-increases beginning with the 2008 financial crisis and expanding beyond $6,000 billion\$6{,}000\,\text{billion} around 2020–2021.

    • The M1 series exhibits a dramatic vertical reclassification spike in 2020 from approximately $4,000 billion\$4{,}000\,\text{billion} to over $16,000 billion\$16{,}000\,\text{billion} and peaking past $20,000 billion\$20{,}000\,\text{billion}, reflecting the regulatory rule change that folded savings deposits into M1.

The Supply of Money and Banking Models

  • Key Institutional Entities Influencing Money Supply:

    • Central Bank (CB): Controls the monetary base and exerts indirect control over the aggregate money supply (operating analogously to supplying yeast for bread without determining the loaf's ultimate baking volume). Prominent central banks include the Federal Reserve in the United States, the European Central Bank (ECB) in the eurozone (which diminished the individual policy role of national European central banks), and the Bank of Japan in Japan.

    • Depository Institutions (Private Commercial Banks): Intermediaries that accept deposits and issue loans, directly influencing the money multiplier.

    • The Nonbank Public: Households and corporations that decide the relative proportions of cash versus bank deposits they wish to hold.

  • Model of an All-Currency Economy:

    • Explores money supply mechanics in a simplified setting without commercial banks.

    • The government establishes a central bank authorized to print standardized paper certificates (outside money, which does not represent an internal obligation of any private actor within the domestic economy), denominated for example as one florin (fl.\text{fl.}).

    • The central bank legally prohibits all other entities from printing certificates.

    • To inject money into circulation, the central bank purchases real physical assets from the public using printed florins (often initially accompanying these transactions with redemption promises).

    • Balance Sheet Mechanics: If the central bank purchases 1,000,0001{,}000{,}000 umbrellas from the public at 1 fl.1\,\text{fl.} each, the central bank's assets increase by 1,000,0001{,}000{,}000 umbrellas, while its liabilities increase by 1,000,000 fl.1{,}000{,}000\,\text{fl.} of printed certificates (technically debt obligations of the issuing bank).

    • Determination: In this all-currency economy, the total money supply (MM) is strictly equal to the monetary base (BASEBASE), granting the central bank complete, direct control over the money supply.

    • Enforcement of Currency Value: Paper currency maintains trade value because the belief that it has purchasing power is self-fulfilling. The state reinforces public demand for fiat currency by declaring it legal tender (an instrument creditors must legally accept in settlement of debt contracts) and by requiring its use in the payment of taxes.

  • Model of an Economy with Currency and Fractional-Reserve Banking:

    • More realistic model where the public utilizes both currency (CUCU) and bank deposits (DEPDEP):

M=CU+DEPM = CU + DEP

  • Commercial banks operate under fractional-reserve banking, retaining a reserve fraction (res<1res < 1) of customer deposits to service daily withdrawal demands and lending out the remainder.

  • The total monetary base (BASEBASE) is divided between public currency holdings and bank reserves (RESRES):

BASE=CU+RESBASE = CU + RES

  • Derivation of the Money Multiplier:

    • Taking the ratio of money supply to the monetary base:

MBASE=CU+DEPCU+RES\frac{M}{BASE} = \frac{CU + DEP}{CU + RES}

* Dividing both the numerator and denominator by total deposits (DEPDEP):

MBASE=CUDEP+1CUDEP+RESDEP\frac{M}{BASE} = \frac{\frac{CU}{DEP} + 1}{\frac{CU}{DEP} + \frac{RES}{DEP}}

* Defining the behavioral ratios:
  * **Currency-deposit ratio (cucu):** CUDEP\frac{CU}{DEP}, determined by the preferences of the public regarding cash holdings relative to bank deposits.
  * **Reserve-deposit ratio (resres):** RESDEP\frac{RES}{DEP}, determined by commercial banks' liquidity preferences and regulatory reserve requirements.
* Expressing the money supply as a multiple of high-powered money:

M=(cu+1cu+res)×BASEM = \left(\frac{cu + 1}{cu + res}\right) \times BASE

  • Multiplication and Money Creation:

    • Because res<1res < 1, the term cu+1cu+res\frac{cu + 1}{cu + res} (the money multiplier) is strictly greater than 11.

    • Commercial banks create money endogenously by issuing loans against unreserved deposits. These borrowed funds are spent and redeposited throughout the banking system, generating a cascade of secondary deposits and loans.

    • Comparative Statics: An increase in either the currency-deposit ratio (cucu) or the reserve-deposit ratio (resres) reduces the value of the money multiplier, reducing the money supply supported by a given monetary base.

    • Fractional-Reserve Vulnerability: Bank Runs:

  • Because bank reserves are strictly smaller than total deposit liabilities (res<1res < 1), sudden, large-scale, panic-driven withdrawal requests can exhaust a bank's liquid reserves.

  • Bank runs originate when depositors suspect a financial institution faces insolvency due to bad loans or asset devaluation.

  • Because an exhausted reserve position prevents a bank from meeting contractual cash obligations, a run can force an otherwise solvent bank into liquidation.

  • To stabilize banking systems and prevent contagion, governments institute deposit insurance (such as FDIC insurance in the United States).

  • Policy Trade-off: While deposit insurance halts self-fulfilling panics, it creates a moral hazard problem by reducing depositor scrutiny and encouraging banks to engage in excessive portfolio risk.

The Demand for Money and Portfolio Choice

  • Theory of Portfolio Choice:

    • Money demand (MdM^d) denotes the nominal volume of monetary assets that economic agents choose to retain within their broader portfolios of real and financial wealth.

    • According to portfolio choice theory, money demand is determined by the general price level, real income, nominal and real interest rates, liquidity needs, and risk preferences.

  • Determinants of Aggregate Money Demand:

    • Price Level (PP): A higher aggregate price level increases the nominal dollar value required to conduct everyday transactions. Therefore, nominal money demand is strictly proportional to the price level: doubling the price level (2×2\times) doubles nominal money demand, holding real variables constant.

    • Real Income (YY): An increase in real output/income expands the physical volume and average scale of transactions, elevating liquidity needs and raising money demand.

    • Non-Proportionality: The rise in money demand is less than proportional to the rise in real income. Higher-income individuals manage cash balances more efficiently (e.g., using cash-management accounts), and economically wealthier societies offer a broader variety of investment assets and noncash payment options.

    • Interest Rates (ii and rr): The demand for money depends inversely on the expected return on alternative interest-bearing nonmonetary assets.

    • As nominal interest rates on alternative assets rise, the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding money balances increases, inducing agents to economize on liquidity and reducing money demand.

    • Since interest rates across financial assets move together in financial markets, the expected real interest rate can be summarized as:

r=i−πer = i - \pi^e

* (where ii is the nominal interest rate and πe\pi^e is expected inflation).
  • Wealth: Increases in aggregate wealth can stimulate consumption, which may increase transaction demand for liquid assets. However, this effect is relatively weak because increments of wealth are preferentially placed in higher-yielding assets.

  • Risk: Elevated riskiness across alternative nonmonetary assets (such as stocks and bonds) increases the relative appeal and demand for money. However, money carries purchasing power risk because unexpected inflation erodes its real value.

  • Liquidity of Alternative Assets: Financial innovations that make it faster or cheaper to convert illiquid assets into cash reduce the need to hold money balances, lowering money demand.

  • Payment Technologies: The spread of modern noncash transaction instruments (such as credit cards and stored-value cards) allows consumers to bypass holding physical currency or intermediate checking balances throughout the month, dampening money demand.

    • The Mathematical Money Demand Function:

  • The nominal money demand relationship is modeled as:

Md=P⋅L(Y,i)M^d = P \cdot L(Y, i)

  • where LL is a liquidity demand function that responds positively to real income (YY) and negatively to the nominal interest rate (ii).

  • Expressed in terms of real expected interest rates:

Md=P⋅L(Y,r+πe)M^d = P \cdot L(Y, r + \pi^e)

  • Demand for Real Balances: Nominal money balances deflated by the price level reflect purchasing power demanded in terms of physical goods:

MdP=L(Y,r+πe)\frac{M^d}{P} = L(Y, r + \pi^e)

  • The nominal return on money itself is omitted from the function because it is nearly zero and demonstrates minimal variation over time.

    • Financial Innovation and Instability in Money Demand:

  • Structural innovations in banking alter the parameters of the money demand function over time.

  • Historical Illustration: During the late 1970s and early 1980s, the introduction of interest-bearing checking accounts (Negotiable Order of Withdrawal or NOW accounts) substantially elevated the demand for M1. NOW accounts constituted only 4%4\% of total M1 in November 1979, but surged to 21%21\% of M1 by December 1982, shifting historical money demand relationships.

Elasticities of Money Demand and Velocity

  • Income Elasticity of Money Demand (ηY\eta_Y):

    • Defined as the percentage change in nominal money demand (MdM^d) resulting from a 1%1\% increase in real income (YY):

ηY=ΔMdMdΔYY\eta_Y = \frac{\frac{\Delta M^d}{M^d}}{\frac{\Delta Y}{Y}}

  • Empirical Estimate: In the United States, ηY\eta_Y is positive and approximately equal to 23\frac{2}{3}.

  • Because ηY<1\eta_Y < 1, money demand increases less than proportionally with real economic growth.

  • Worked Example: If the income elasticity is 34\frac{3}{4} and real income increases by 2%2\%, the resulting percentage change in money demand is:

(34)×2%=1.5%\left(\frac{3}{4}\right) \times 2\% = 1.5\%

  • Interest Elasticity of Money Demand (ηi\eta_i):

    • Defined as the percentage change in nominal money demand (MdM^d) resulting from a 1%1\% change in the nominal interest rate (ii):

ηi=ΔMdMdΔii\eta_i = \frac{\frac{\Delta M^d}{M^d}}{\frac{\Delta i}{i}}

  • Important Percentage Calculation Caveat: A change in the interest rate from 4%4\% to 5%5\% represents an absolute increase of 1%1\% percentage point, but constitutes a relative percentage increase of 25%25\% in the interest rate (5−44=0.25\frac{5 - 4}{4} = 0.25).

  • Empirical Estimate: In the United States, ηi\eta_i is small and negative, falling within the range of −0.1-0.1 to −0.2-0.2.

  • Worked Example: If the interest elasticity is −0.4-0.4 and the nominal interest rate rises from 4%4\% to 5%5\% (a 25%25\% increase), the percentage change in money demand is:

−0.4×25%=−10%-0.4 \times 25\% = -10\%

  • The Velocity of Money:

    • Velocity (VV) quantifies the speed at which money circulates, defined as the average number of times a unit of the money supply changes hands to purchase final goods and services during a given period.

    • The Equation of Exchange:

Md×V=P×YM^d \times V = P \times Y

  • Solving directly for velocity:

V=P×YMdV = \frac{P \times Y}{M^d}

  • Velocity reflects the inverse of money demand relative to total economic activity. Factors that reduce the demand for real balances (such as higher interest rates, heightened expected inflation, or payment technologies that economize on money holdings) directly drive velocity upward.

Velocity of M1 and M2 in the United States from 1959 to 2014
  • Empirical Patterns in Velocity (1959–2014):

    • M1 Velocity: Trended steadily upward from approximately 44 in 1959, peaked above 10.510.5 around 2007–2008, and experienced a steep structural decline down toward 66 by 2014.

    • M2 Velocity: Remained remarkably stable over the same five-decade horizon, fluctuating within a narrow band between approximately 1.61.6 and 2.22.2.

Asset Market Equilibrium and the Determination of the Price Level

  • Aggregation into a Two-Asset Economy:

    • To model macroeconomic asset market equilibrium, all financial and physical assets are aggregated into two categories:

    • Money (MM): Transaction assets yielding zero nominal return.

    • Nonmonetary Assets (NMNM): Bonds, equities, and real assets that pay a positive nominal return (ii).

  • Equilibrium Across Asset Markets:

    • Aggregate household demand for assets is constrained by total nominal wealth:

Md+NMd=aggregate nominal wealthM^d + NM^d = \text{aggregate nominal wealth}

  • Aggregate asset supply is established by the central bank (MM) and by the issuance of bonds and equity by governments and firms (NMNM):

M+NM=aggregate nominal wealthM + NM = \text{aggregate nominal wealth}

  • Setting total asset supply equal to total asset demand:

Md+NMd=M+NMM^d + NM^d = M + NM

  • Rearranging terms yields:

(M−Md)+(NM−NMd)=0(M - M^d) + (NM - NM^d) = 0

  • Equilibrium Implication: If the money market clears such that excess demand for money is zero (M−Md=0M - M^d = 0), the market for nonmonetary assets must clear simultaneously (NM−NMd=0NM - NM^d = 0). Analyzing asset market equilibrium therefore requires evaluating only the money market.

    • Equilibrium in the Money Market:

  • Equating nominal money supply to nominal money demand:

M=P⋅L(Y,r+πe)M = P \cdot L(Y, r + \pi^e)

  • In real balance terms:

MP=L(Y,r+πe)\frac{M}{P} = L(Y, r + \pi^e)

  • Equilibrium Price Level Determination:

    • Solving the money market clearing equation for the aggregate price level (PP):

P=ML(Y,r+πe)P = \frac{M}{L(Y, r + \pi^e)}

  • The component variables are determined in their respective markets:

    • Real output (YY) is determined by clearing in the labor market and the production function.

    • The real interest rate (rr) is cleared by equilibrium saving and investment in the goods market.

    • Expected inflation (πe\pi^e) is taken as given in the short run.

  • With YY, rr, and πe\pi^e pinning down real money demand (LL), the aggregate price level (PP) is strictly proportional to the money supply (MM).

  • Dynamic Adjustment Mechanism: If the central bank injects excess money supply (M>MdM > M^d), households spend excess liquidity on goods and services. The resulting excess demand bids up prices (PP), increasing nominal transaction requirements until nominal money demand rises to match the expanded money supply (Md=MM^d = M).

Money Growth, Inflation, and Empirical Dynamics

  • Derivation of the Inflation Rate:

    • The inflation rate (π\pi) is defined as the percentage change in the aggregate price level (ΔPP\frac{\Delta P}{P}).

    • Differentiating the price level equilibrium equation (P=MLP = \frac{M}{L}) in growth rate terms yields:

π=ΔPP=ΔMM−ΔL(Y,r+πe)L(Y,r+πe)\pi = \frac{\Delta P}{P} = \frac{\Delta M}{M} - \frac{\Delta L(Y, r + \pi^e)}{L(Y, r + \pi^e)}

  • Expressing the growth rate of money demand (ΔLL\frac{\Delta L}{L}) in terms of its income and interest elasticities:

ΔL(Y,r+πe)L(Y,r+πe)=ηY(ΔYY)+ηi(Δii)\frac{\Delta L(Y, r + \pi^e)}{L(Y, r + \pi^e)} = \eta_Y \left(\frac{\Delta Y}{Y}\right) + \eta_i \left(\frac{\Delta i}{i}\right)

  • Substituting these elasticities yields the complete inflation equation:

π≡ΔPP=ΔMM−ηY(ΔYY)−ηi(Δii)\pi \equiv \frac{\Delta P}{P} = \frac{\Delta M}{M} - \eta_Y \left(\frac{\Delta Y}{Y}\right) - \eta_i \left(\frac{\Delta i}{i}\right)

  • Implications of the Inflation Equation:

    • When real income growth and nominal interest rates are stable, the domestic inflation rate is dictated by the rate of money supply growth (\frac{\Delta M}{M}$).\n * Under steady-state conditions where money growth, real output growth, and interest rates remain constant, expected inflation equals actual current inflation (\pi^e = \pi).\n * **The Expectations Channel:** If the public anticipates an acceleration in future money growth, expected inflation (\pi^e)increasesimmediately.Thisraisesnominalinterestrates() increases immediately. This raises nominal interest rates (i = r + \pi^e),reducingrealmoneydemand(), reducing real money demand (L) and triggering an immediate rise in the current price level, even before the money supply itself increases.\n\n![Graph of inflation rate and nominal interest rate in the United States from 1960 to 2021](https://assets.knowt.com/pdf-flow-prod/047892b0-edb8-4806-ba61-43d2e46af5ff-figures/3.jpg)\n\n* **Empirical Co-movement of Inflation and Nominal Interest Rates (1960–2021):**\n * United States macroeconomic data demonstrates tight empirical tracking between the nominal interest rate and the inflation rate.\n * Both series trended upward through the 1960s and 1970s, reached a simultaneous historical peak near 15\% during the 1980–1981 period, and followed a synchronized disinflationary downward trend through the 1990s and 2000s.\n * Following the 2008 recession, nominal interest rates hovered near the zero lower bound while inflation fluctuated at low rates, before both began ascending sharply around 2021.\n\n* **Application: Transition Economies in Eastern Europe (1990s):**\n * Following the collapse of the Soviet bloc, Eastern European nations experienced starkly divergent inflation rates.\n * *Cross-Country Analysis:* Differences in real output growth were relatively minor, and interest rates were uniformly high across these transition economies (producing comparable shifts in money demand). Therefore, disparities in money demand growth could not account for the wide inflation differentials.\n * Disparities in inflation were overwhelmingly driven by sharp differences in the growth rate of national money supplies.\n * *Underlying Fiscal Pressures:* Rapid monetary expansion stemmed from governments printing money to finance fiscal budget deficits, caused by an inability to issue and sell sovereign debt on international capital markets, combined with limited institutional understanding of monetary mechanics.\n * *Extreme Episodes (Russia, Ukraine, Belarus):* In the most severe inflationary episodes of the 1990s, annual inflation rates exceeded the domestic money supply growth rate ( \pi > \frac{\Delta M}{M}).\n * This divergence occurred because extreme, runaway inflation caused domestic money demand (L$$) to collapse. As local currencies rapidly lost purchasing power, domestic populations abandoned their national currencies entirely, fleeing into foreign hard currencies (such as the United States dollar) or resorting to direct barter.