Psychology - Gender
Themes in Psychology: Gender
Introduction
- Sex: Biological characteristics (male: XY, penis, testes; female: XX, vulva, uterus, ovaries; intersex: atypical combinations).
- Gender: Culturally associated attitudes, feelings, and behaviors (masculinity/femininity).
- Gender Identity: Internal recognition of being male or female.
- Gender Stereotype: Fixed, simplified beliefs about appropriate attitudes/behaviors based on sex.
- Sex-typed Behavior: Behavior aligning with cultural gender stereotypes.
- Sexual Orientation: Attraction.
- Hyde's gender similarities hypothesis (2005): Males and females are mostly alike in psychological variables.
Observed Sex Differences (Maccoby & Jacklin, 1974)
- Verbal Ability:
- Girls may have slightly higher verbal abilities, especially among poor readers.
- Visual and Spatial Abilities:
- Boys excel, particularly in mental rotation tasks.
- May be due to experience (video games) or hunter-gatherer theory (men's navigation skills).
- Females better at remembering object locations.
- Arithmetical Ability:
- Boys show greater ability during adolescence, especially in patriarchal societies.
- Aggression:
- Boys are more physically and verbally aggressive.
- Perceptions of emotional reactions differ based on gender labels (Condry & Condry, 1976).
- Women may have a higher tendency to experience negative emotions (Schmitt et al., 2008), more pronounced in egalitarian societies.
Cultural Influences
- Western societies encourage instrumental roles for boys (assertive, competitive) and expressive roles for girls (cooperative, sensitive).
- Haines et al. (2016): Gender stereotyping persists.
- Cultural expectations for boys and girls are similar across cultures, but pressure to comply varies.
Theories of Gender Development
1. Psychodynamic Approach (Freud)
- Children develop gender understanding through awareness of anatomical differences.
- Oedipal Complex (boys):
- Erotic impulses towards mother, rivalry with father, castration anxiety.
- Resolution through identification with father.
- Electra Complex (girls):
- Initial attraction to mother, then father due to penis envy.
- Identification with female gender role.
- Criticism: Lack of empirical evidence.
2. Social Cognitive Theory (Bandura)
- Gender identity through life experiences, copying behavior, rewards, and punishments.
- Forms of Learning:
- Observational Learning: Copying others, especially same-sex models (Perry & Bussey, 1979; Dill & Thill, 2007).
- Direct Tuition: Instruction about gender roles (Fagot & Leinbach, 1989; Tenenbaum & Leaper, 2002; Hupp et al., 2010).
- Enactive Experience: Learning from consequences of actions (Kowalski, 2007).
- Criticism: Effects may be small; doesn't focus on general learning.
3. Cognitive Theory: Self-Socialization Theory
- Gender cognitions guide behavior.
- Cognitive developmental theory (Kohlberg, 1966): Gender constancy motivates gender-stereotypical behavior.
- Martin et al (2004) & Halverson's (1987) gender schema theory: Gender schemas (organized beliefs about suitable activities and behavior for each sex).
- Learn specific knowledge about each gender.
- Children start linking together different information they come across to start constructing more complex gender schemas.
- Construct complex gender schemas about the other gender.
- Criticism: Behavior not always strongly linked to gender identity.
4. Biological Theories
- Chromosomes, hormones, and brain structure influence gender identity.
- Males (XY), females (XX).
- Batista family study (Imperato McGinley et al, 1974): 5-alpha reductase deficiency (genetic males raised as girls adopt male identity at puberty).
- Hormonal Activity: Testosterone and Estrogen
- Effects of Oestrogen:
- Body produces more 'good' cholesterol and makes blood vessels more flexible.
- Strengthens immune system.
- Causes fat tissue to form round hips to act like a cushion during pregnancy.
- Inhibits liver functioning, so women eliminate alcohol slower.
- Effects of Testosterone:
- When testosterone levels peak in males, they are more prone to use drugs, engage in violent/abusive behaviour and have behavioural problems.
- When a male becomes a father, testosterone levels decrease.
- Thus, hormones do influence behaviour which we associate with gender.
- Studies show that girls whose mothers had atypically high levels of testosterone during pregnancy favour trucks over dolls. On the other hand, males who were exposed to oestrogen experience a decline in normally strong spatial skills and increases in usually less strong verbal skills.
- Congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH): Affects girls and causes heightened levels of male hormones.
- Berenbaum and Beltry (2011):
- Play more with boys' toys than with girls' toys
- When adults they are more prone to choose male-dominant professions.
- They also are more likely to like rough sports.
- Also more likely to have a non-heterosexual orientation.
- Have higher levels of aggression than other girls and show superior ability in spatial tasks
5. Biosocial Approach (Money & Ehrhardt, 1972)
- Emphasizes socialization and nurture.
- David Reimer story: Case study of a boy raised as a girl after a botched circumcision.
- Initially promising results, but later rejection of female identity.
- Diamond (1982) Diamond found that at the age of thirteen the girl was 'beset with problems'.
- Diamond concluded from this follow up study that people's biology largely determines their gender.
Masculinity and Femininity (Sandra Bem)
- Bem believed that to be psychologically well-adjusted, one need to be androgynous, i.e. one needs to possess both characteristics.
- Bem Sex Role Inventory Test (BSRI): Measures masculine, feminine, and gender-neutral traits.
- Androgyny: Balance of masculine and feminine traits.
- Davison: Older women (who usually experience a lot of sexism and ageism) who scored high for androgyny also reported higher levels of subjective wellbeing than less androgynous women.
- Gana: Highly androgynous husbands showed greater participation in household tasks than those who were less androgynous.
- Cheng: Androgynous individuals were found to use the most appropriate coping strategies.
- Leftkowitz and Zeldow: People high on masculinity and femininity were both associated with good mental health. But people who were androgynous has the greatest mental health.
- Spence, Helmreich and Strapp (1974): Defined an androgynous individual as someone who had high scores on both the masculine and feminine scales of their new Personal Attributes Questionnaire (PAQ).