Psychology - Gender

Themes in Psychology: Gender

Introduction

  • Sex: Biological characteristics (male: XY, penis, testes; female: XX, vulva, uterus, ovaries; intersex: atypical combinations).
  • Gender: Culturally associated attitudes, feelings, and behaviors (masculinity/femininity).
  • Gender Identity: Internal recognition of being male or female.
  • Gender Stereotype: Fixed, simplified beliefs about appropriate attitudes/behaviors based on sex.
  • Sex-typed Behavior: Behavior aligning with cultural gender stereotypes.
  • Sexual Orientation: Attraction.
  • Hyde's gender similarities hypothesis (2005): Males and females are mostly alike in psychological variables.

Observed Sex Differences (Maccoby & Jacklin, 1974)

  1. Verbal Ability:
    • Girls may have slightly higher verbal abilities, especially among poor readers.
  2. Visual and Spatial Abilities:
    • Boys excel, particularly in mental rotation tasks.
    • May be due to experience (video games) or hunter-gatherer theory (men's navigation skills).
    • Females better at remembering object locations.
  3. Arithmetical Ability:
    • Boys show greater ability during adolescence, especially in patriarchal societies.
  4. Aggression:
    • Boys are more physically and verbally aggressive.
    • Perceptions of emotional reactions differ based on gender labels (Condry & Condry, 1976).
    • Women may have a higher tendency to experience negative emotions (Schmitt et al., 2008), more pronounced in egalitarian societies.

Cultural Influences

  • Western societies encourage instrumental roles for boys (assertive, competitive) and expressive roles for girls (cooperative, sensitive).
  • Haines et al. (2016): Gender stereotyping persists.
  • Cultural expectations for boys and girls are similar across cultures, but pressure to comply varies.

Theories of Gender Development

1. Psychodynamic Approach (Freud)
  • Children develop gender understanding through awareness of anatomical differences.
  • Oedipal Complex (boys):
    • Erotic impulses towards mother, rivalry with father, castration anxiety.
    • Resolution through identification with father.
  • Electra Complex (girls):
    • Initial attraction to mother, then father due to penis envy.
    • Identification with female gender role.
  • Criticism: Lack of empirical evidence.
2. Social Cognitive Theory (Bandura)
  • Gender identity through life experiences, copying behavior, rewards, and punishments.
  • Forms of Learning:
    1. Observational Learning: Copying others, especially same-sex models (Perry & Bussey, 1979; Dill & Thill, 2007).
    2. Direct Tuition: Instruction about gender roles (Fagot & Leinbach, 1989; Tenenbaum & Leaper, 2002; Hupp et al., 2010).
    3. Enactive Experience: Learning from consequences of actions (Kowalski, 2007).
  • Criticism: Effects may be small; doesn't focus on general learning.
3. Cognitive Theory: Self-Socialization Theory
  • Gender cognitions guide behavior.
  • Cognitive developmental theory (Kohlberg, 1966): Gender constancy motivates gender-stereotypical behavior.
  • Martin et al (2004) & Halverson's (1987) gender schema theory: Gender schemas (organized beliefs about suitable activities and behavior for each sex).
    1. Learn specific knowledge about each gender.
    2. Children start linking together different information they come across to start constructing more complex gender schemas.
    3. Construct complex gender schemas about the other gender.
  • Criticism: Behavior not always strongly linked to gender identity.
4. Biological Theories
  • Chromosomes, hormones, and brain structure influence gender identity.
  • Males (XY), females (XX).
  • Batista family study (Imperato McGinley et al, 1974): 5-alpha reductase deficiency (genetic males raised as girls adopt male identity at puberty).
  • Hormonal Activity: Testosterone and Estrogen
    • Effects of Oestrogen:
      • Body produces more 'good' cholesterol and makes blood vessels more flexible.
      • Strengthens immune system.
      • Causes fat tissue to form round hips to act like a cushion during pregnancy.
      • Inhibits liver functioning, so women eliminate alcohol slower.
    • Effects of Testosterone:
      • When testosterone levels peak in males, they are more prone to use drugs, engage in violent/abusive behaviour and have behavioural problems.
      • When a male becomes a father, testosterone levels decrease.
      • Thus, hormones do influence behaviour which we associate with gender.
      • Studies show that girls whose mothers had atypically high levels of testosterone during pregnancy favour trucks over dolls. On the other hand, males who were exposed to oestrogen experience a decline in normally strong spatial skills and increases in usually less strong verbal skills.
  • Congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH): Affects girls and causes heightened levels of male hormones.
    • Berenbaum and Beltry (2011):
      • Play more with boys' toys than with girls' toys
      • When adults they are more prone to choose male-dominant professions.
      • They also are more likely to like rough sports.
      • Also more likely to have a non-heterosexual orientation.
      • Have higher levels of aggression than other girls and show superior ability in spatial tasks
5. Biosocial Approach (Money & Ehrhardt, 1972)
  • Emphasizes socialization and nurture.
  • David Reimer story: Case study of a boy raised as a girl after a botched circumcision.
    • Initially promising results, but later rejection of female identity.
    • Diamond (1982) Diamond found that at the age of thirteen the girl was 'beset with problems'.
    • Diamond concluded from this follow up study that people's biology largely determines their gender.

Masculinity and Femininity (Sandra Bem)

  • Bem believed that to be psychologically well-adjusted, one need to be androgynous, i.e. one needs to possess both characteristics.
  • Bem Sex Role Inventory Test (BSRI): Measures masculine, feminine, and gender-neutral traits.
    • Androgyny: Balance of masculine and feminine traits.
    • Davison: Older women (who usually experience a lot of sexism and ageism) who scored high for androgyny also reported higher levels of subjective wellbeing than less androgynous women.
    • Gana: Highly androgynous husbands showed greater participation in household tasks than those who were less androgynous.
    • Cheng: Androgynous individuals were found to use the most appropriate coping strategies.
    • Leftkowitz and Zeldow: People high on masculinity and femininity were both associated with good mental health. But people who were androgynous has the greatest mental health.
  • Spence, Helmreich and Strapp (1974): Defined an androgynous individual as someone who had high scores on both the masculine and feminine scales of their new Personal Attributes Questionnaire (PAQ).