Panel Discussion on Research Methods and Career Paths

Career Skills and Research Methods

  • The point of the discussion is to explore career skills from research methods and how to turn the knowledge from this course into tangible assets.
  • The material discussed will be testable, so students should pay attention to key content.

Paths to Academia

  • Matt became an academic because he enjoys it and kept pursuing it.
    • He liked relationship science and finds it more interesting than other fields like maths or geology.
    • He values the autonomy in academic research, not being told what to research or when.
    • Academics are meant to be independent critics and not influenced by external entities like cigarette companies.
    • While autonomy is great, the downside is that researchers may become consumed by their work.
  • Tia initially studied education and mathematics before transitioning to psychology.
    • She was drawn to psychology because of the various phenomena to explore.
    • She recounts being intrigued by the correlation between hot weather, crime rates, and ice cream consumption.
    • She also became interested in the origins of statistical tests like t-tests, mentioning Fisher's work related to brewing and hops.
    • She emphasizes how statistics can help tell a story.
    • Her path to academia was accidental; after her master's, she was invited to pursue a PhD.
    • She values fresh ideas from students and the interaction with them.
    • She enjoys community service and research, aiming to make an impact on whanau (families).

Research Integrity

  • It is difficult to detect P-hacking unless researchers admit it.
    • P-hacking involves making sneaky decisions about what data to include or exclude to achieve significance.
    • Readers need to critically assess research papers for suspicious signs.
    • Examples include controlling for irrelevant variables or unexplained exclusion of participants.
    • Concerns arise if the pre-registration document doesn't match the actual methodology used.
  • Faking data is more easily detected, especially by "nerdy people" who use algorithms and calculators to identify impossible numbers.
    • Researchers caught faking data can be expelled from university.
  • Retraction Watch tracks papers that have been retracted due to serious misconduct like plagiarism or data fabrication.
    • Retractions can end a career, but they don't happen often.
    • Some researchers conduct "dodgy research" with fake data, which is ignored by others in the field.
  • Open science practices, like using the Open Science Framework (OSF), help identify questionable research.
  • A classic story involves researchers claiming data loss due to a laptop dying or records being lost in a flood.
    • In such cases, the community may stop citing the research.
  • There isn't an "FBI team" tracking down bad researchers; they often keep their jobs despite their misconduct.

Experience and Career Paths

  • Real-life experience is valuable as it provides perspective, even for basic surveys.
    • Researchers may lose touch with the experiences of survey respondents.
    • Real-world experience is especially helpful for qualitative interviews and community-embedded research to understand what's important to study.
  • Academia has shifted away from studying topics purely for personal interest.
  • Having real-world experience provides a grounding factor and helps balance one's perspective.
  • After being in the "real world" for a while, individuals may be more prepared for further study, such as a PhD.
  • Academics in New Zealand have relative job security; however, this may not be the case globally.
  • Funding for social sciences can be politically influenced.
  • Academics have autonomy, but diversity and equity issues in research should be considered.
  • The culture has changed, with more flexibility to align research with students' interests.
  • Psychology is a popular discipline due to its variety and applicability to real-world situations.

Clinical Psychology

  • There is a shortage of clinical psychologists, especially those with bicultural, Pacifica, and Asian expertise.
  • The bottleneck in clinical psychology is due to funding for academics and limited placements.
    • Universities are often asked to train more psychologists without additional resources.
    • Supervised internships are necessary but restricted by available positions and supervisors.
    • The clinical psychology program is often the most subscribed program, with many applicants for limited places.
  • When selecting candidates, it's essential to consider how well they will connect with diverse populations, such as Maori, migrants, and refugees.
    • Practical considerations, like appropriate attire in certain settings (e.g., prisons), are important.
    • It is important to assess the support needed and whether clinical colleagues have the capacity to provide it.
  • The government has proposed the creation of "assistant psychologists" with shorter training programs.
    • This raises ethical concerns about the level of training and competence required.
    • There is no clear system or definition for the role of assistant psychologists.
  • Counseling is a practical option with less theory and more therapeutic skills training.
    • However, it may not be suitable for serious or unusual cases.
    • Counseling programs also face limitations related to training and placements.
  • Titles and qualifications can be confusing; "therapist" is not a protected term, while "psychologist" requires specific training and accreditation.
  • It is more typical to choose either a counseling track or a clinical psychology track.
    • Universities tend to specialize in one or the other.

Academic Career Path

  • It is challenging to become a lecturer after obtaining a PhD.
  • One must be willing to apply for positions worldwide and accept opportunities wherever they arise.
  • A lecturer position is difficult to secure, and those who want to live in a specific city may face challenges.
  • The lower one's standards or requirements, the easier it becomes to find a position.
  • It is advised not to limit oneself to New Zealand when seeking a lecturer position.
  • Universities may consider the ranking of the institution where the PhD was obtained.
  • New Zealand universities rank highly, especially in psychology.
  • Having a PhD is the starting point, but publications and individual achievements are crucial for evaluation.

Longitudinal Studies

  • It is not easy to track people in longitudinal studies.
  • Buy-in and relationships are essential.
  • Participants need to enjoy the study and see its importance.
  • Building relationships with participants is vital to ensure they care and continue to contribute.
  • Researchers need to ensure participants are compensated enough to encourage continued participation.
  • The Dunedin longitudinal study is an example of a study that has been ongoing for over forty years, with efforts made to maintain relationships with participants who have moved to different parts of the globe.