7.5

Native American Support and the Shawnee Confederacy

  • Alcohol and Traditional Ways: The Shawnee leaders emphasized a return to traditional ways, resisting the influences of American western expansion and the introduction of alcohol.

  • Support from Other Nations: They found their greatest support among several Native nations of the western Great Lakes, including:

    • Kickapoo

    • Potawatomi

    • Ho-Chunk

    • Odawa

    • Ojibwe warriors who were relatively unaffected by U.S. expansion.

  • Prophetstown: Many of these warriors flocked to Prophetstown, Tenskwatawa's holy village located in the Indiana Territory.

Conflict with William Henry Harrison

  • Tecumseh's Mobilization: As Tecumseh organized his followers for conflict, Indiana Territory’s Governor William Henry Harrison opted for a preemptive strike.

  • Battle of Tippecanoe (November 1811):

    • While Tecumseh sought support from tribes in the south, Harrison attacked Prophetstown.

    • Harrison commanded a force of 1,000 troops and militiamen, resulting in heavy casualties for both sides.

    • Harrison’s forces ultimately destroyed Prophetstown.

The War of 1812

  • Context of the War: Britain assisted Indigenous nations in western territories while also seizing American ships in the Atlantic, severely straining U.S.-British relations.

  • Call to War: Key players pushing towards war included:

    • Henry Clay (Kentucky): Speaker of the House of Representatives.

    • John C. Calhoun (South Carolina): A rising congressman advocating for territorial expansion into British Canada and Spanish Florida.

  • Madison's Ultimatum: As elections approached, Madison issued an ultimatum to Britain. Upon lack of response:

    • A sharply divided Senate voted 19-13 in favor of war, the House passed the bill 79-49.

Causes of the War

  • Commercial Rights: The U.S. justified the war on the grounds that Britain violated its rights as a neutral nation.

  • Political Divisions: Federalists from New England opposed the war, leading to a significant electoral split:

    • Federalists championed neutrality and opposed the war effort.

    • Republican support for the war was strongest in the South and West, indicating a regional divide.

  • Historical Perspective: Historians often critique the War of 1812 as “a western war with eastern labels” reflecting underlying political tensions.

Early Stages of the War (1812-1814)

  • Initial Campaigns: Early American military efforts, such as invading Canada, largely ended in disaster, leading to retreats.

  • Key Events:

    • Burning of York: American raiders burned the Canadian capital of York (Toronto).

    • Battle of Lake Erie: Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry led a victorious engagement against the British naval forces.

    • Battle of the Thames: General Harrison defeated British and Native American forces, killing Tecumseh and marking a significant U.S. victory.

Challenges During the War

  • British Offensive: By 1814, American setbacks led to increased opposition:

    • British troops launched an attack on Washington D.C., burning the Capitol and White House in retaliation for the York destruction.

  • Stalemate on the Canadian Frontier: The U.S. found itself defensively stationed along the Canadian border.

  • Southern Victories: Noteworthy victories included General Andrew Jackson defeating British-supported Muscogees at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend, forcing them to cede 23 million acres of land.

Federalists and Opposition to the War

  • Decline of Federalist Support: Sharp military setbacks increased Federalist opposition in New England.

  • Hartford Convention (1814): Massachusetts Federalists proposed radical reforms, including:

    • Constitutional amendments limiting presidential terms.

    • A requirement for a two-thirds majority in Congress to declare war or restrict trade.

  • Financial Strain: The war had enormously impacted the national debt, growing to $127 million, complicating the war effort.

Treaty of Ghent and Aftermath

  • Negotiation for Peace: By 1815, Britain, worn from its war with France, sought peace, culminating in the Treaty of Ghent on December 24, 1814, which restored prewar borders without loss of territory.

  • Battle of New Orleans:

    • On January 8, 1815, General Jackson achieved a decisive victory over British forces.

    • The British suffered approximately 700 dead and 2,000 additional casualties, while only 13 Americans died.

  • Public Reaction: The victory raised national morale and obscured the Hartford Convention's calls for constitutional reform.

Republican Party Dynamics Post-War

  • Shift in Political Landscape: Following the War of 1812, the Republican Party adapted:

    • Division into two camps; the National Republicans pursued Federalist-like policies under Henry Clay.

  • Second Bank of the United States: Henry Clay successfully advocated for the formation of the Second Bank in 1816, further aligning with pro-Federalist policies.

  • Decline of the Federalist Party: The Federalist Party weakened post-war, overshadowed by the Republican Party's growing dominance.

Judicial Developments under Chief Justice Marshall

  • Judicial Review: Established in Marbury v. Madison (1803), asserting the Supreme Court's authority to overturn state laws.

  • Significant Cases:

    • McCulloch v. Maryland (1819): Confirmed the constitutionality of the Second Bank and denied Maryland's right to tax it, reinforcing national supremacy.

    • Gibbons v. Ogden (1824): Struck down a New York law granting a monopoly on interstate steamboat travel, enhancing federal control over interstate commerce.

  • Protection of Property Rights: Marshall's court employed the contract clause of the Constitution to safeguard property rights against state legislation perceived to infringe upon them.

Legacy and Historical Context

  • Impact of the War of 1812: Despite significant challenges, the War of 1812 defined national identity, leading to increased nationalism and paving the way for future political shifts.

  • Federalism vs. Republicanism: The evolution post-war saw increasing acceptance of Federalist policies among Republicans and a gradual fading of Federalist influence in American politics, leading to a distinct national character and a focus on expansion.