Analyzing Child Language Samples

Story Elicitation Task and Purpose

  • Story Content: The story involves a boy being late for school due to various problems:

    • His milk spills.

    • His shoelace breaks.

    • He misses the bus.

    • These issues collectively lead to his tardiness.

  • Ideal Resolution: The boy explains his tardiness to the principal.

  • Moral/Ending: The principal commends the boy, stating, "good job handling that," implying a positive resolution to the character's problem-solving.

  • Assessment Context: This story provides a context for observing a child's language abilities in retelling, which helps in identifying how much they remember and their narrative structure.

Language Sample Segmentation (C-Units)

  • Definition of C-Unit: A "communication unit" or "C-unit" comprises an independent clause and any associated dependent (subordinate) clauses or modifiers.

  • Segmentation Process: The primary goal is to identify and segment a child's continuous speech into these distinct C-units.

    • Each new independent clause typically marks the beginning of a new C-unit.

  • Challenges with Subordinating Conjunctions (e.g., "because"):

    • Children, especially those with language disorders, may use conjunctions like "because" as general connectors rather than as indicators of a true subordinate clause.

    • Segmentation Strategy for Ambiguous Use: If a child repeatedly uses "because" as a simple connector (e.g., twice in close succession without clear subordination),

      • The instructor might "split the difference," giving credit for one instance of a subordinating clause and not for the other.

      • Splitting the sentence before the redundant conjunction penalizes the child for not fully utilizing long utterances, effectively reducing the length of the C-unit.

      • This approach balances giving some credit for emergent use of subordinating conventions while also acknowledging errors.

  • Resources: Students are provided with supplementary materials:

    • A list of subordinating conjunctions.

    • "Segmenting utterances into C-units" documents.

    • A "transcription convention summary" cheat sheet.

Grammatical Analysis: Be-Verbs and Errors

  • Be-Verbs (Copula vs. Auxiliary):

    • "Be" verbs (e.g., is, am, are, was, were) are grammatical morphemes that can function in two ways:

      • Copula: A "linking verb" followed by an adjective or a noun.

        • Example: "The boy was hungry." (exthungryext{hungry} is an adjective). Here, "was" functions as a copula.

      • Auxiliary: A "helping verb" followed by another verb (usually a present participle or past participle).

        • Example: "The man was sitting." (extsittingext{sitting} is a verb). Here, "was" functions as an auxiliary.

    • Identifying Adjectives vs. Verbs (e.g., "tired"):

      • The context determines if a word like "tired" acts as an adjective or part of a verb phrase.

      • If it follows a be-verb and describes a state (e.g., "I am tired"), it's an adjective.

      • If it functions as a verb, it would typically imply an action (e.g., "The boy hired his father").

  • Common Errors/Omissions in Child Language Samples:

    • Third Person Singular Omission: The child might omit the "−s-s" ending for third-person singular verbs (e.g., "The boy want to not go to sleep" instead of "wants").

    • Incorrect Verb Forms/Phrasing: Complex errors involving multiple verb forms (e.g., "I guess the man want to go getting going there now" instead of "wanted to get going").

    • Transcription and Error Marking: Transcribers must carefully interpret intended meaning to identify and mark errors, which can influence credit given for utterance length or grammatical complexity.

Productivity in Language Samples

  • Minimum Utterance Count: For a reliable diagnosis based on a language sample, the field and research accepted minimum is approximately 5050 utterances per child.

  • Insufficient Samples: A sample of 1111 or 1212 utterances is considered insufficient for making an appropriate diagnosis.

  • Children with Language Disorders: Children with Specific Language Disorder (SLD) may yield fewer utterances spontaneously, requiring more extensive elicitation to reach the target of 5050 utterances.

Transcription Guidelines

  • Fillers: Words like "tired and tired" or repeated words are typically coded as a single instance for credit in segmentation or word count.

  • Audio Aid: Listening to the audio alongside the transcript can help determine utterance boundaries and intonation patterns for more accurate segmentation and error identification.