The Gig economy - week 4
The Gig Economy
Overview
The gig economy represents a significant transformation in organizational operations.
Organizations within this economy utilize platforms—often apps—to connect workers who sell their labor with those who need specific services.
This model operates on a ‘labour on demand’ basis, allowing organizations to engage workers only as needed, diverging from traditional 9-5 employment contracts, often resulting in zero hours contracts.
Workers in this economy are labeled as 'entrepreneurs' or 'self-employed contractors', meaning they aren’t considered employees in the traditional sense.
The core purpose of the gig economy is to pair individuals with specific skills to organizations requiring those skills.
Types of Gig Workers
Local Labor versus Platform-Based Labor
Local Labor: Workers who provide services that are transacted through platforms but necessitate physical presence, such as:
UBER (ride-sharing)
Deliveroo (food delivery)
MyBuilder (construction services)
Pimlico Plumbers
Platform-Based Labor: Workers who engage in tasks that are both transacted and delivered solely through digital platforms, such as Upwork.
On-Demand Work
Dynamics
On-demand workers operate under a system that prioritizes flexibility and immediate availability but often at the expense of traditional employment benefits.
Critical Perspectives on the Gig Economy
Positive Aspects
Proponents argue that gig work encourages a new mode of working that supports entrepreneurialism, potentially reducing unemployment and fostering a societal shift toward self-employment and creativity, as indicated by scholars Brynjolfsson & McAfee (2014).
This model promotes flexibility for workers to choose when and how to engage in work.
Negative Aspects
In exchange for flexibility, gig workers bear the burden of managing their own taxes, pensions, and lack guaranteed wages or defined working hours.
Critics highlight that this work often consists of low-skilled jobs, repackaged to appear innovative while undermining job security and benefits.
A 2017 government report noted that the rise of self-employment due to the gig economy resulted in an estimated loss of £5 billion annually in tax and national insurance contributions for the UK's treasury.
Major players in this space are accused of not innovating but exploiting existing legal loopholes to generate profits, relying on cost-cutting measures that detrimentally affect worker compensation and benefits, transferring economic risks to workers.
Worker Autonomy
Though marketed as a means of emancipation, providing workers with choices and flexibility, the reality for many gig workers is often starkly different. Many find themselves feeling trapped, controlled, dehumanized, and lacking support.