Vaccinations - SOSC 1801

Vaccinations: "To Prick or Not to Prick"

Edward Jenner: Vaccine Pioneer

  • Historical Context:

    • 18th Century England faced rampant smallpox infections, a highly lethal disease.

    • Estimated death toll of smallpox was 10-30% of all burials.

    • Caused by the orthopox virus, variola (VARV).

    • Transmitted mainly person-to-person; survivors developed lifelong immunity.

  • Disease Dynamics:

    • Smallpox described as a crowd disease, requiring a large population of susceptible hosts.

    • Historian William McNeill noted that population growth and migration increased disease frequency and host accumulation.

    • Continued epidemics led to fewer individuals escaping infection and greater childhood immunity.

Early Vaccination Practices

  • Variolation:

    • A primitive vaccination method where healthy individuals were infected with material from mildly affected patients.

    • Originated in China and India, but mortality and infection transmission risks existed.

  • Discovery of Cowpox Immunity:

    • Jenner observed that individuals with cowpox immunity did not contract smallpox, whether accidentally or intentionally exposed.

The Birth of Vaccination

  • May 1796:

    • Jenner found dairymaid Sarah Nelmes with cowpox lesions.

    • He inoculated 8-year-old James Phipps with matter from her lesions.

    • Phipps experienced mild illness but fully recovered.

  • Smallpox Challenge:

    • Jenner inoculated Phipps again with smallpox matter on July 1, 1796.

    • Phipps showed no symptoms, indicating complete protection.

  • Impact on Public Health:

    • In 1798, Jenner published "An Inquiry into the Causes and Effects of the Variolae Vaccinae."

    • Established the first free vaccination clinic at his home, prioritizing need over ability to pay.

    • This clinic symbolized hope and the emerging values of a public health system.

Vaccination Timeline: Canada

  • 1885: Dr. Alexander Stewart founded a vaccine farm in Ontario, supplying smallpox vaccine for 31 years.

  • 1918: Introduction of Canada's first pertussis vaccine.

  • 1924: 9,000 diphtheria cases reported; a leading cause of child mortality.

  • 1926: Diphtheria toxoid introduced for protection.

  • 1940: Tetanus toxoid introduced in Canada.

  • 1943: Routine immunization against pertussis approved.

  • 1953: Polio epidemic occurred with 9,000 reported cases; vaccine drastically reduced this.

  • 1955: Salk polio vaccine licensed in North America.

Expanded Vaccine Developments

  • 1963: First measles vaccine approved, previously having over 300,000 cases annually.

  • 1964: Formation of the National Advisory Committee on Immunizing Agents (now NACI).

  • 1969: Introduction of rubella vaccine; reduced incidence significantly.

  • 1972: Routine smallpox vaccination ceased.

  • 1977: Last indigenous smallpox case recorded in Somalia.

  • 1982: Hepatitis B vaccine introduced; school programs began in 1987.

  • 1983: MMR immunization program initiated, drastically reducing rubella cases.

  • 1994: Canada declared polio-free.

  • 1995: Switch from OPV to IPV to prevent vaccine-associated paralytic poliomyelitis (VAPP).

  • 2004: Inactivated influenza vaccine recommended for young children.

  • 2006: Approval of the first HPV vaccine for cervical cancer prevention.

Jonas Salk: Polio Conqueror

  • Polio Overview:

    • Poliomyelitis is an acute viral disease affecting the nervous system, primarily children under 5.

    • Mid-20th century polio caused hundreds of thousands of cases annually with no cure available.

  • Impact of Vaccination:

    • Widespread use of vaccines since the 1960s led to polio elimination in most areas.

    • Currently endemic in only three countries: Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Nigeria.

    • Reported polio cases have dropped by more than 99% worldwide since 1988.

Key Terms

  • Immunity: Protection against infectious diseases; can be acquired naturally or through vaccination.

  • Vaccine: A product that triggers immunity to a specific disease, typically given by injection, orally, or nasally.

  • Vaccination: The act of administering a vaccine to confer immunity.

  • Immunization: A process making a person immune, often synonymous with vaccination.

  • mRNA Vaccines: A new vaccine type teaching cells to produce proteins that provoke an immune response.

Vaccine Hesitancy & The Anti-Vaxx Movement

  • Public Acceptance:

    • Over 80% acceptance of vaccines worldwide (WHO, 2012).

    • Increasing parental refusal or delay of vaccines raises concerns over vaccine-preventable diseases.

  • Reasons for Hesitancy:

    • Religious objections, personal beliefs, safety concerns, and a desire for more information from healthcare providers.

Religious Objections: 3 Main Roots

  • Ethical dilemmas: Concerns about human or animal tissues in vaccine production (e.g., human tissues from aborted fetuses in rubella vaccines).

  • Spiritual beliefs: Some believe illness is divine and should be approached with faith rather than medicine.

  • Crusading agenda theories: In regions like Nigeria and Afghanistan, skepticism arises from perceived links to ulterior motives in vaccination efforts.

Personal Beliefs & Philosophical Reasons

  • Natural Immunity: Some parents believe that natural infections are more beneficial than vaccination-induced immunity.

  • Perceived Risks: Concerns about the vaccines’ side effects versus the perceived insignificance of preventable diseases.

  • Healthy Lifestyle Assumptions: Some believe that a healthy lifestyle decreases the need for vaccinations.

Safety Concerns

  • Media Influence: Many safety concerns arise from media reports, leading to doubts about short and long-term vaccine effects.

  • Specific Fears: Instances like HPV vaccine links to infertility and MMR’s alleged connection to autism

  • Government Interventions: The introduction of the Vaccine Injury Support Program in response to public concerns about vaccine safety.

Desire for Additional Education

  • Information Gaps: Parents often report wanting more accessible and balanced information about vaccination risks and benefits.

  • Access to Experts: Findings show one-third of parents feel they lack sufficient provider communication regarding vaccines.

  • Demand for Factual Sharing: Parents express the desire for straightforward, factual content about vaccines, aiming to facilitate informed decisions on childhood healthcare.