Sociology Notes

What is Sociology?

  • Sociological Imagination studies the relationship between individuals and society ( find quote) on exam! History and biography in society 

  • How people are shaped by the society they live in

  • How different societies interact in the current historical context

  • Pertaining to the government, society, economy, and the global

  • How social structures shape individuals and how individuals shape social structures 

  • What do we owe each other? Do we owe each other anything at all? 

  • How perspective shifts change you and the people around you

  • How our positions in society affect what we believe we are owed/what we owe to each 

  • other

  • Environmental and cultural factors 


Sociology vs. Economics 

  • “Economics is all about how people make choices, sociology is all about how they don't have any choices to make.” - John Duesenberry (American Economist)


What is sociology?

  • For Weber, sociology is a science concerning itself with the interpretive understanding of social action and thereby with a causal explanation of its course and consequences

  • For Mills, the sociological imagination enables us to grasp history and biography (the individual) and the relations between the two in society 

  • Social Structure: Patterned, institutionalized, social arrangements (ie race, class, gender, religion) 

How Does Sociology Distinguish itself from Common Sense?

  • Common sense: tactic knowledge from life experience 

  • Common sense is useful but is based on: non-rigorous rules, routine -> familiarity, limited experience and knowledge, bias in our decisions 

How Does Sociology Distinguish Itself from Other Social Sciences?

  • Diversity of methods

  • Diversity of theoretical approaches (ties to classical thinkers)

  • Interest in building sociological theory

  • Different emphases in related disciplines (anthropology, economics, political science)

  • Some areas of overlapping interests - ex. Political sociology, comparative historical sociology 


Where Did Sociology Come From?

  • Reaction to the ideas of the Enlightenment drawn from ideas in 17th century philosophy and science which suggested people could control the universe by means of reason and empirical research - physical (and social worlds) dominated by natural laws

  • Some foundational sociologists (Comte) shared the belief in need to look for natural laws governing social phenomena 

  • Sociology posited that society produced the individual 


Auguste Comte (1798 - 1857)

  • The first to use the term “sociology” - previously known as social physics (1839) 

  • Reacted against anarchy in French society and thinkers behind French Revolution

  • Created “Law of Three Stages” and scientific view called “positivism” way of thinking that it is possible to observe social life and establish reliable valid knowledge on how it works

  • Observing, counting, to help develop a general understanding of the world (quantitative science). This would affect positive social change and improve the human condition 

  • Stressed systematic character of society; influenced Durkheim and later Parsons 

Emile Durkheim (1858-1916)

  • Bothered by problem of social disorder 

  • Society: set of independent parts that work in harmony together (structural functionalism) specialization in jobs 

  • Work representative of “functionalist” theory and that we should be concerned with social facts 

  • In Rules, argues sociologists task is study of “social facts” as forces and structures external to and coercive of the individual

  • Suicide tried to link individual causes to social causes (facts)

Karl Marx (1818-1883) in the context of world events (capitalism = profit)

  • Did not consider himself a sociologist, but social theory is clearly articulated in his work

  • Tried to develop a theory to explain the oppression of capitalist system and wanted to use it to overthrow system 

  • Drew attention to the importance of social class

  • Has influenced sociology and the world even today 

Max Webber (1864-1920)

  • Focused on political, religious, and cultural effects on economy

  • Concerned with increasing rationalization of society- developed concept of the “iron cage” individuals become trapped in an iron cage because we are subject to systems based on efficiency, rationalization, and control 

  • Can be thought of as complementing or conflicting with Marx’ theories (both talk about how capitalism can lead to negative outcomes but have conflicting views on religion)

Ideal types: Abstract concepts representing “perfect” examples of a phenomenon that help put the seeming chaos of social reality in order

  • They act as measuring sticks against which we can think about and compare actual cases in the real world 

  • The concept lends itself to and allows for comparative understanding (how empirical cases compare to the abstract realities) 

Ideal types of authority: 

  • Traditional (“accepted because “it is how things have always been”)

  • Charismatic ( extraordinary leaders  who can appeal to large audiences with aura ie Ghanda)

  • Rational-legal (execution depends on a system of bureaucracy with set of rules and laws) 

W.E.B Du Bois (1868-1963) 

  • Deeply concerned with racism and involved in movement for equal rights for African Americans

  • Produced a number of important works 

  • Souls of Black Folk (1935): “The problem of the 20th century is the problem of the Color-line.”

  • Concept of double-consciousness pointed to the “sense of always looking at oneself through the eyes of [prejudiced whites], of measuring one’s soul by the tape of a world that looks on in Amused contempt and pity” (seeing themselves through their own eyes and the eyes of whites)

  • Once said “Either America will destroy Ignorance or ignorance will destroy the United States”

Modern Sociology

  • Classical thinkers influenced by events - Political Revolutions (France-1789), Industrial Revolution

  • Symbolic interactionism: Georege Herbert Mead (1863-1931) emphasized the study of language in analyzing the social world

  •  Structural functionalism: Talcott Parsons and Robert Mertorn (1950s and 1960s) - emphasized consensus 

  • Conflict theories (1960s/1970s) check ppt slide

Tenets of Sociology Today 

  1. Recognition that laws do NOT govern human behavior 

  2. Sociologists must deal with issues related to indicators, measurement, and casualty 

  3. Sociologist are part of what they study and bring their assumptions with them and are shaped by the world in which they live

  4. Sociologists make their assumptions about the world explicit as theory and seek to test it against “inconvenient fact”

Sociological Research Methods

Challenge of Doing Research

Figuring out a researchable question and how to look for the answers can be the most difficult part of doing research 

  • Some are too broad: Why did the chicken cross the road?

  • Some are too narrow: How many chickens crossed Broad Street in Durham, NC, on February 6, 2014? 

  • Some may open relative space for data collection and thoughtful analysis: What are some of the environmental factors that occurred in Durham,NC between January and February 2014 that would cause chickens to cross Broad Street?

Difficulty of doing “value-neutral” research 

  • Is it possible to be objective?

  • We often think of statistics as value-free - are they?

  • What about interviews?

  • If we have expectations about what our research will find, how do we prevent those expectations from coloring our findings?


Ethnography

  • Qualitative research method that comes out of the discipline of anthropology - in depth study of culture or a facet of culture - involves hands-on, on-the-scene learning 

  • Great for providing detailed information about how a sub-group lives,works, acts, relates 

  • Researcher-subject problems 

  • This research cannot be generalized for all cultures because they behave differently 

  • May witness illegal activities 

Interviews

  • Can help to get at “how” and “why” questions 

  • Importance of who you select and how many people you talk to 

  • Can quantify information - valuable? (cross check information with others to make sure that it is accurate) 

  • Overcoming tricky issues: People telling you what you want to hear, or worse, lying to you or trying to manipulate you

Conversation Analysis 

  • Builds on the tradition of symbolic interactionism 

  • Concerned with language and dynamics of interaction - explains individual in society and interactions with others and through that social order and change

  • Even though criticized for inattention to large-scale social structures, often powerful for examining conflict in micro-interactions

Comparative Historical Sociology

  • Use primary and secondary sources, sometimes interviews

  • Can elucidate patterns in history in a case or across cases

  • Problem of how we should treat/ think about history, cases 

Surveys 

  • Importance of random sample (recent phenomenon - improvements that allowed modern survey to develop only made in 1930s and 1940s)

  • Importance of well-designed questions 

Statistical Analysis 

  • Relatively new, very powerful

  • Often drives policy 

  • Assess the relationship between two variables 

  • Run experiments to find the way causality flows (or if it flows at all) 

  • But also plagued with assumptions (just like qualitative research)

Methodological Tools 

  • Not an exhaustive list 

  • Approaches can be combined - sometimes helps overcome these problems - “triangulation” 

  • Main point: provides an overview of some of the most often used tools and explains some of the problems researchers have to be very careful in dealing with as they go about their research process 

Culture and Conformity 

Culture 

  • Embodied in words, ideas, images, music, food, customs, traditions

  • Much of it flows relatively easily (especially when facilitated by structures like the internet) 

Important Terms 

Culture: the values, norms, language, revered symbols, and materials goods characteristic of a particular group

  • Backer: culture explains how people act in concert when they do share understandings

  • Culture shapes the outlooks of people but continually has to be remade

  • Makes some behaviors more likely than others!

Values: ideals held by individuals or a particular group about what is desirable, proper, good, and bad

  •  (Ex: monogamy in most western culture, multiple wives and husbands in some other cultures)

  • (ex individualism in the U.S, conformity in Japan)

Norms: Rules of conduct that specify appropriate behavior in a given range of social situations

  • (Ex: among Americans, direct eye contact when talking, among Navajo people, averting eyes is  assign of respect)

  • Norms can change over time (ex in 1964 42% of people smoked. Today, only 21% do)

Key Characteristics of Culture

Culture is shared

  • The shared nature of culture makes human society possible

  • We would not be able to get anything done if we couldn't communicate with one another using symbols 

  • Shared norms, values, and beliefs help maintain social order and create group consensus

Culture is learned

  • The main goal of socialization is teaching people a society’s or group’s culture 

  • Because humans have very few instinct, humans must learn culture in order to survive

Culture is taken for granted

  • Because we are immersed in culture and often interact with people on a daily basis, our culture becomes invisible

  • When we enter another cultural environment or interact with people from different cultures, we often experience culture shock

Culture varies across time and place

  • Culture develops as humans adapt to their material circumstances; since societies have different material circumstances, different cultural patterns arise 

  • (eg Hinduism’s Sacred Crow)

“Philisocphical” Approaches to Culture

  • Ethnocentrism: Believing that one’s own culture is better and morally right than other cultures

  • Cultural Relativism: believing that all cultures are legitimate and that behavior is moral or immoral depending on the cultural context in which it occurs 

Views of Culture in Social Science

Conception 1 

  • Primordial identities 

  • Static culture

  • Fixed laws determine behavior

  • tradition/modernity 

Conception II

  • Constructed identities

  • Dynamic, fluid

  • Culture resources deployed as needed

  • Cultural hybridity

How sociologists Think ABout It

Max Weber: rationalization as an “iron cage”

  • The Calvinist doctrine promoted a distinctive frame of mind that promotions rational, ascetic, economic behavior

  • Until recently, most sociologists took the importance of culture for granted

  • Believe we are so thoroughly shaped by culture that we can never escape its influence 

  • However , cultural explanations have also been criticized by sociologists as the lazy man’s interpretation - ex. Oscar Lewis’ “culture of poverty” thesis

  • In economics, culture is often “the residual” (what's leftover, unimportant)

Ann Swidler (1986): culture is a “tool kit” from which people select different understandings of behaviors 

  • Toolkits are made up of various “scripts” or roles that we can choose to draw on, or improvise on, in certain circumstances

  • The more appropriate it is to certain circumstances the more likely we are to follow it

Why and When Do People Conform?

Culture plays a role in establishing conformity to norms, but particular situations, contexts, and dynamics of power and authority also matter

  • Sometimes people convince themselves that actions they would otherwise find morally wrong are acceptable, why?

  • Unequal power relations and being subject to authority can also influence behavior 

  • The power of beliefs and norms can reinforce behavior

  • Classic example: Asch (subject chooses the same answers as the actors even though they are incorrect because he wants to conform), Milgrim experiments (people obeying authorities “unethical” commands) 

Deviance and Social Control

What Is Deviance?

  • Who do we consider deviant? Criminals? People who do “weird” things? Or things that are not usual?

  • But think about this: We all break the law sometimes (e.g. speeding)

  • Some crimes are not seen as deviant by many people (e.g. smoking pot, illegal downloads)

  • Contextual nature of deviance (i.e. variation across time and space)

  • Deviance in the context of normalcy (e.g. Ted Bundy)

  • Disagreement about deviant behaviors (e.g hackers)

  • Deviance: nonconformity to a given set of norms that are accepted by a significant number of people in a community or society for which the violator is likely to be censured or punished 

  • But there is no simply way in any society to identify the border between deviance and non-deviance, often a moving target

  • Powerful 

Social norms are internalized through socialization ( repeated interactions)

  • All social norms are accompanied by sanctions that promote conformity

  • Sanction: any reaction from others to the behavior of an individual or group that is meant to ensure that the person or group complies with a given norm

  • They may be positive or negative

Laws: norms defined by governments as principles that their citizens must follow 

  • Laws are codified, written down, and formally enforced through institutions such as the state (police)

  • Crime: any type of behavior that breaks a law

  • Criminalization: the process by which 

Perspectives on Deviance form other Disciplines

Biological view

-Cesare Lombroso (Italian criminologist)

  • In the 1870s he advanced the theory that criminal types could be identified by the shape of the skull 

  • Studies on the 1950s about body types

  • Muscular, active types are more likely to become delinquent than thin or fleshy people 

New Zealand (1996) study linking a child’s propensity to aggression to biological factors present at birth 

  • The biological view has largely been discredited 

Psychological View

  • This view associates criminality with particular types of personality 

  • Psychopaths: withdrawn, emotionless characters who delight in violence for its own sake

But are psychopathic traits inevitably criminal?

  • Most studies on psychopaths have been done in prison environments with convicted criminals

But what if we looked at the same traits positively?

  • Adventurous, carefree people who live exciting, impulsive lives would do anything for a good thrill 

  • Some criminals may possess personality characteristics distinct from the remainder of the population

  • But it is highly unlikely that all criminals share some specific psychological characteristics

  • A lot of diversity in criminal activities (violent and non-violent crime, individual and collective crime)

  • Both biological and psychological approaches presume that deviance is a sign of something wrong with the individual  

Functionalist Theories 

  • Crime and deviance result from structural tensions and a lack of moral regulation within society 

Emile Durkheim 

  • Anomie leads to crime and deviance

  • Crime and deviance are inevitable in a society 

Deviance plays two functions: 

  • Adaptive: by introducing new ideas into society, deviance is an innovative force

  • Boundary maintenance: criminal events provoke collective responses that heighten group solidarity and clarify social norms

Robert Merton 

  • Focus on the strain put on individuals when accepted norms conflict with social reality 

  • Industrial societies (particularly the US) emphasize material success

  • Self discipline and hard work are the means to achieve material success

  •  Yet material success is not really possible for everybody, and the most disadvantaged face limited opportunities for advancement 

  • Pressure to try to get ahead by any means legitimate or illegitimate 

Conflict (Critical Theories)

  • Functionalists trace the source of deviance to broader social structures and the strains they produce, or the fact that they do not exercise adequate control over people

  • Conflict theorists also believe broader social structures are important, but focus on the inequality within those structures and its impact - inequality causes people to act in deviant ways!

  • More emphasis on the way those in power create rules defining deviance in ways that advantage them and disadvantage others!

Interactionists Theories

  • Deviance is a socially constructed phenomenon 

  • There is no such thing as inherent deviant conduct 

  • Less interested in trying to explain deviance (like functionalism)

  • Instead explores the process by which people define some behaviors as normal and some as deviant

  • What is deviant changes over time!

  • Ethnomethodologists are concerned with what people do, rather than what people think

  • So they explore how people “do” deviance - the everyday behaviors people engage in that produce deviance 

Labeling theory

  • Suggests that (at least) two things are needed for deviance to occur - symbols (a label) and interaction

  • For this theory, a deviant is someone to whom a deviant label has been successfully applied (instead of focusing on what the individual does)

  • Howard Becker’s (1963) study of marijuana smokers

  • Becoming a mariquana smoker dependent on one's acceptance into the subculture, close association with experienced users, and one’s attitude towards non-users

  • Deviance as a process of interaction between deviants and nondeviants

  • It is not the act of marijuana smoking that makes one deviant, but the way others react to marijuana smoking that makes it deviant

  • The key question is, then: why are some people tagged with the ‘deviant’ label?


  • Social Control: the process by which a group enforces conformity to its demands

  • Social control agents do the labeling 

  • Who has the capacity to do the labeling?

  • Labels that create categories of deviance express the power of structure society

  • Wealthy, men, older people, ethnic majorities

  • Labels stigmatize people, that determines other people’s behavior towards them, and that reinforces defiant behavior 

Social Psychology Theory

  • The power of the situation 

  • Rosenhan (2004)

  • The hospital imposes a social environment in which meanings of behavior can easily be misunderstood 

  • Inclines physicians towards Type II Error (false positive)

  • Has consequences on patients, including powerlessness, depersonalization, segregation, mortification, and self-labeling

Crime and Criminology

  • Crime: violation of the law

  • Criminology: filed devoted to the study of crime

  • Includes not just sociologists but economists, psychologists, biologists, anthropologists, and justice officials (interdisciplinary)

  • Has recently shifted from a focus on criminals and their defects to a concern with the social context of criminal actions and the effect on broader society

Why important?

  • Almost 2.3 million in jail in 2016

  • US has highest incarceration rate in the world 

  • 77% of prisoners are re-arrested within 5 years

  • Restorative justice: aims to repair harm caused by crime rather than punish people ( used by low incarceration rate countries such as Norway)

(check ppt)

Pager’s Experiment

  • Used black pairs and white pairs (all male)

  • For Whites the criminal record chances were reduced by half but for blacks it was a 3x disadvantage.

  • White men with a criminal record were more likely to get a call back than black people without a criminal record.

  • Penalty not just for imprisonment but for race as well

Social Class and Inequality

  • The appearance of classlessness in America

  • The idea that anyone can be president with enough smarts and ambition - an idea that dates back to Franklin!

  • Class inequality is America IS certainly less rigid than the categories of some caste-based societies



What is Social Class?

  • Social class: a category or group of people who have approximately the same amount of wealth, status, and power in society

  • Classes are ranked in a hierarchical way

  • Class helps determine personal opportunities and life experiences

  • Often used interchangeably with socioeconomic status, which refers to a person’s place in a stratified social order

Cultural capital: the accumulation of knowledge, behaviors, and skills that a person can tap into to demonstrate one's cultural competence and social status

  • Includes skills, tastes, posture, clothing, mannerisms, material belongings, credentials, etc that one acquires through being part of a particular social class - things that are highly symbolic!

  • Creates a sense of collective identify group position 

  • Major source of inequality 

Some Properties of Class

  1. Class systems are more fluid than a caste system or slavery

  2. Class is principally derived from our economic position

  3. Class is not irrevocably assigned to us at birth. 

Social mobility - the movement from one level to another - is possible, though it can be difficult

  1. Class is large scale construct that is difficult ot see or smell

  2. Class affects everything from the neighborhoods we live in to the lifestyles we follow to the marriage partners we choose

Models of Class

  • Simplest: upper, middle, lower

  • US medical sociologists:

- UC: extremely wealthy top corporate execs

- UMC: affluent well educated professionals and high-level managers

- LMC: office and sales workers, small business owners, teachers, managers

- WC: skilled and semi-skilled, lower level clerical workers

- LC: semi and unskilled, chronically unemployed

- wealth is an objective dimension, status is subjective related to the esteem accorded by other people 

SES Socioeconomic Status (also known as social class) know all this for exam!!

  • Today, Weber's influence is felt through the widespread use of socioeconomic status (SES) in sociological research which refers to income, occupational prestige, and level of education 

  • Income reflects spending power, housing, diet, and medical care

  • Occupation measures status, responsibility at work, physical activity, and health risks

  • Education reflects a person's skills for acquiring positive social, psychological and economic resources such as good jobs, nice homes, health insurance, access to quality healthcare, and knowledge about healthy lifestyles (better educated people have the best health, current most determining factor)

Important to Remember!
- Wealth is not income - wealth is not included in SES!

Income: amount a person earns in a given year from a job, business, or asset/investment income

Wealth: total amount of a person’s assets (savings, investments, home, auto) minus the total of his debts (mortgage, car loan, credit cards, etc)

  • Wealth and income inequality are both growing

  • Wealth inequality is much bigger however

Social Class in America

The Upper Class:

  • The people at the top of the socioeconomic food chain - the economic elite

  • Associated with income, wealth, power, prestige

  • Ceos, doctors, lawyers, scientists, entertainers, professional athletes

  • Significant amount of income derived from investment s

  • Don't have to work but may (eg CEOs)

  • Politically active

The Middle Class

Middle class is often a catchall for a diverse group of occupations, lifestyles and people who earn stable incomes at primarily white collar jobs (office workers) - jobs that pay significantly more than the poverty line 

  • No consensus on what it means

  • Generally vote

  • Often own homes

  • In the US, broad swaths of the population consider themselves middle class

The Upper Middle Class

  • Generally high income professionals

  • College educated with advanced degrees

  • Secure retirement and health insurance

  • Active civic and political orgs

The Lower Middle Class

  • Typically include HS teachers, police, firefighters, nurses, sales people, office workers

  • Rarely politically active besides voting

  • May rent but some have modest house

  • Want children to attend college but requires work study or loans

Working Class

  • Composed of individuals who work manually (using hands or bodies) 

  • Factory workers, mechanics, sales clerks, restaurant and hotel workers, blue collar jobs

  • Both parents typically work to make ends meet

  • Family income just covers expenses

  • Racially and ethically diverse

  • Likely to rent rather than own

  • Not politically active - might vote

The Poor

  • Poverty line for HH of 4: $26,200; for one person: $12,760 (2020)

  • Work part-time or not at all

  • Often live in cities and work in semiskilled or unskilled manufacturing

  • Jobs unlikely to lead to promotion or come with insurance

  • Less active in politics 

Underclass and Working Poor

Underclass: those caught in the highest poverty neighborhoods of the inner city - trapped in poverty that is difficult to escape 

  • Nonworking poor sometimes referred to as underclass

  • Working poor: those whose earnings are not enough to lift them out of poverty

Sociologists: Interested in the life and experience of the poor

  • Because poverty has generally remained hidden from most Americans’ view!

  • Mitch Duneier’s Sidewalk - Why do people sleep on the sidewalk?

  • The poor are complex - cant make easy assumptions about them

  • Street vendors defined themselves through their entrepreneurial work, not through their condition of homelessness

  • Had money to stay in hotel but didnt

  • Reasons: everything in one place, save money or vending space, used to it, feeling of safety, support drug use 

  • $2,00 a day: a similar kind of study in that it provides a window into the life of the poor

  • However, about different issues:

On a micro-level explores what it actually takes to survive with virtually no cash in the world’s richest economy

But more broadly, what happens when a government safety net built on the assumption of full-time, stable employment at a living wage combines with a low-wage labor market that fails to deliver promise of a better life and in fact creates many indignities

  Aim at the broader context of a welfare reform that pushed millions of low-income                single moms into the workforce while doing nothing to improve their conditions

Why is Class Important?

Four Main Reasons:

  • Because research shows it is sticky, particularly at the bottom ( it can be hard to pull yourself out)

  • Because inequality is increasing dramatically in our society 

  • Because it has intersections with other important factors that produce inequality (race, gender, education, occupation)

  • Because the American Dream may not be as accessible as we imagine it to be

Part II - Class Mobility, or Is it Possible to Pull Myself Up by my Bootstraps?

  • Income inequality has grown especially between the top 1% and the rest of society

The American Dream

  • Horatio Alger (1832-1899)

  • The idea that you can “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” is a very American one

  • How much mobility is possible? Is the American dream open to anyone? 

Intergenerational Mobility: Myth or Reality?

  • Hauser and Featherman (1973) compared fathers’ and sons'occupations (farm/blue-collar/white-collar):

  • 25 percent upwardly mobile

  • 10 percent downwardly mobile

  • About 50 percent in same strata as father

Wysong et al (1998) compared the incomes of 2,749 father-and-son pairs between 1979 and 1998:

  • Fewer sons had moved up the class ladder in 1998 compared to 197-

  • Nearly 70% of sons at the same level or worse than fathers in 1998 

  • The biggest increase in mobility was at the top of society, with affluent sons moving upwards more often than their fathers had

  • Only 10% of the adult men born in the bottom quarter made it to the top quarter

Unequal Childhoods: A Study of Intergenerational Mobility

  • Concerted Cultivation of the MC: ‘Developing’ a child through organized activities, which lead to a sense of entitlement and an ability to question adults and see relations as equal 

  • Accomplishment of Natural Growth: Working class and poor families allow children more control over leisure time

  • Argument: These different childrearing approaches lead to THE TRANSMISSION OF DIFFERENTIAL ADVANTAGE (specifically help us to navigate institutional worlds)

PART III Class and Power

Sociologists: Investigating how UC retain control of wealth

C Wright Mills - “The Power Elite” (1956)

  • Socialization (schools, clubs)

  • Intermarriage (debutante balls, social registers)

  • Interlocking directorates (corporate links)

  • Revolving door between business and government

Sociologists: Examining the role of UC in political process

WIlliam Domhoff - Who Rules?

  • Reacted to work of political scientists Robert Dahll (1961) - Who Governs?

  • “Pluralists” like Dahl believed that the political process is worked out among a wide range of interest groups - no one dominant group 

  • Following Mills, Domhoff argued that power is concentrated among a tight-knit corporate community which has similar interests

  • Argument was founded on facts (ex: top 20% control 85% of the wealth and 93% of the financial wealth)

Sociologists: Interested in how inequality is maintained

  • Insights from Marx influence sociology even today

  • The wealthy have the ability to influence important social institutions (government, media, schools and courts) and can create and promote a reality that justifies exploitation

  • False consciousness: when this version of reality becomes so influential that those who are harem by it accept it 

  • Originally formulated by Marx and Engels

  • Important bc it is the primary means by which powerful classes in society prevent protest and revolution 

Sociologists: Interested in how inequality is maintained: 

  • Mantsios (2003): importance of the media!

  • Owned by the upper class

  •  Powerfully shapes our perception in ways we are not aware of

  • Average american watches 28 hrs of TV/week

  • Lionizes the UC or treats interests of UC as same as those of the MC, even though they are distinct (dividends vs employment)

  • Ignores the poor or sees as undeserving

Parting Snapshots of Inequality in the U.S

  • High levels of inequality by historic standards

  • Increase in inequality since the 1980s

  • The very rich are the only ones who have benefited from economic growth - and are getting richer!

  • More inequality in the US than in other advanced nations

  • Increasing inequality in the last 30 years: an American phenomenon

Is equality feasible or even desirable?

  • Some economists believe that equality comes at high cost - a high minimum wage = fewer jobs, generous benefits discourage job seeking, high taxes reduce savings and investment

  • However, comparatively equal countries grew just as fast as the US since the 1970s

  • Evidence” Don't need to be an unequal society to contribute to affluence (against Kuznets curve theory - 1955)

  • Denmark, Norway, and Sweden have high levels of public employment - sustainable?

What Can We Do?

  • Remember the words of Joseph Stiglitz: inequality in America didn't just happen - it was created!

  • Can become a more informed citizen (and voter)

  • Can organize to demand the situation change 

  • Can push for taxation policies and social programs that directly address deep inequalities

  • Some new models are coming from the Global South

Conditional Cash Transfers

  • CCTs: give poor cash incentive to do things that have social benefit, like ensuring kids attend school and immunizations 

Race and Inequality

  • Age and education affect peoples attitudes towards interracial Marriage ( people of older age and less education more inclined to disagree with interracial marriages) 

American Sociology has long recognized that racial dynamics shape inequality 

  • Alexis de Tocqueville, 1835-1840: legacies of slavery threaten US democracy 

  • WEB DuBois, 1903: ‘The problem of the twentieth century is the problem of the color-line’

  • Gunnar Myrdal, 1944, An American Dilemma: tension between ideology of equality and realities of racial exclusion

Race and Discrimination

  • Stereotype: generalization about an entire category of people (eg, does not have to involve race but can serve as the basis for prejudice and racism)

  • Prejudice: negative opinions or attitudes held by members of one group toward another, whether conscious or unconscious (eg, being afraid of black people)

  • Racism: beliefs or practices that confer negative status and/or disadantages on racial or ethnic group ( a system of domination/stratification)

  • Discrimination behavior or policy that disadvantages a racial ro ethnic group 

  • Can take place formally or informally (in a job or social settings)

  • Institutional discrimination routine practice that disadvantages a racial or ethnic group

  • But what is race?