Urban Ecology and Social Structure

Urban Ecology and the Theory of Robert Park

  • The City as a Natural Ecosystem: According to the theories of Robert Park, the city is viewed through the lens of urban ecology, where the urban environment acts as a natural ecosystem.
  • Space and Resource Dynamics: Within this ecosystem, people and various groups are in constant competition for both physical space and limited resources.

Key Ecological Processes in Urban Development

  • Invasion: This occurs when new groups of individuals move into an existing residential or commercial area.
  • Competition: This refers to the active struggle or fight between different groups for control over specific spaces within the city.
  • Dominance: A stage where one specific group successfully takes over an area, establishing control or prevailing over others.
  • Succession: The final stage of the cycle where the original or older residents of an area leave, completing the transition as the new group fully occupies the space.

The Shaw and McKay Studies

  • Subject Population: Shaw and McKay conducted extensive research focusing on boys under the age of 1717 who were involved in the following sectors of the justice system:
        - Police contact or arrests.
        - Juvenile court proceedings.
        - Placement in correctional institutions.
  • Socio-Economic Factors Analyzed: Beyond criminal involvement, the study investigated various environmental stressors, including:
        - Poverty levels.
        - Health issues within the population.
        - Population changes and migration patterns.
        - Race and ethnicity factors.
        - Housing conditions.

Burgess’s Concentric Zone Model

  • The Target Analogy: Developed by Burgess, this model posits that the city is shaped like a target, consisting of concentric circles.
  • Direction of Growth: Urban growth is characterized as happening from the inside out, where development pushes from the center toward the outer rings.

The Five Zones of the City

  • Zone I: The central business district, primarily consisting of businesses and offices.
  • Zone II: Known as the zone in transition, characterized by poor housing, high immigrant populations, and low income. This zone historically exhibits the highest crime rates.
  • Zone III: The area populated by the working class.
  • Zone IV: A residential area primarily housing the middle class.
  • Zone V: The commuter zone, inhabited by the wealthiest residents who travel into the city for work.

Key Findings on Crime and Geography

  • Non-Random Nature of Crime: The research concluded that crime is not random; it follows specific geographic patterns.
  • Geographic Concentration: The highest concentration of crime consistently occurs in Zone IIII.
  • Persistence Over Time: High-crime areas tend to stay the same over long periods, regardless of which specific groups are living there.
  • Environmental Causality: A central finding of these studies is that crime is a product of the area itself, NOT the specific people living in it.

Social Structure and Crime Rates

  • Big Idea: Research following the work of Shaw and McKay shifted focus toward the relationship between specific neighborhood conditions and their corresponding crime rates.

Urban Changes and the Creation of the Underclass

  • The Suburban Shift: Significant urban changes occurred as middle-class individuals and businesses migrated away from the city centers to the suburbs.
  • Resulting City Conditions: This migration left inner cities with several critical issues:
        - High levels of poverty.
        - Urban decay and deteriorating infrastructure.
        - A significant reduction in available resources.
  • The Disadvantaged ‘Underclass’: These conditions fostered the creation of a permanently disadvantaged group, often referred to as the underclass, characterized by:
        - High rates of unemployment.
        - Chronic welfare dependence.
        - A prevalence of single-parent families.
        - Increased rates of drug use and violence.