Notes on Empirical Falsifiability, Theory, and Scientific Method
The nature of theories and empirical falsifiability
Theories are empirically falsifiable and have withstood attempts to falsify them; they have empirical support.
You cannot prove a theory correct with statistics; you can only fail to falsify it (or fail to disprove it).
Observations in most sciences are probabilistic, not deterministic.
The null hypothesis framework tests causation: reject (no relationship) to accept (relationship).
Statistics assess the probability of a result occurring by chance, not ultimate proof.
Anecdotes are not proofs; systematic evidence is needed to falsify a theory, not isolated cases.
Falsification, not definitive proof, is central to scientific progress.
Determinism, realism, and the object/subject distinction
Objects (e.g., rocks) obey physical laws, while subjects (humans) have cognition, can resist, and react to being studied (reactivity/Hawthorne effect).
Reactivity complicates control of environmental and belief factors.
Social sciences face greater complexity due to studying subjects with cognitive constraints and social contexts.
The scientific process in criminology: causation, prediction, and theory-building
Criminology aims to explain and predict crime rates through plausible causes and mechanisms (e.g., low self-control leading to delinquency).
The process involves observing patterns, proposing explanations, testing predictions, and refining theories.
Conceptualization and the ontology-epistemology pair
Ontology: Questions about what is real (the nature of reality).
Epistemology: How we know what we know; the scientific method.
The scientific approach assumes realism: an external reality exists, and our knowledge is refined through definitions and observation.
Nominal, operational, and theoretical definitions; measurement and observation
The pathway from concept to measurement involves:
Concepts (e.g., low self-control, delinquency).
Nominal definitions: Lay terms or precise definitions of concepts.
Theoretical proposition: Link between concepts (e.g., low self-control leads to delinquency).
Operational definitions: Concrete, measurable indicators (e.g., questionnaires for self-control).
Observation/measurement: Collecting data; ensuring measurement validity.
Hypothesis: A testable statement about relationships between variables.
The empirical test cycle: replication, falsification, and robustness
Science progresses through replication; a single study rarely settles a question.
Replication across contexts and populations is crucial, as early findings may not generalize (e.g., domestic violence arrest experiment).
Robust science relies on ongoing testing and refinement.
The role of theory and policy implications in criminology
The ultimate goal is to identify influenceable factors to reduce crime and improve social welfare.
Policymakers should rely on robust, replicated evidence before large-scale implementation of interventions.
Practicalities of scientific modeling in criminology
The modeling process defines concepts, proposes theoretical links, operationalizes variables, collects data, and tests hypotheses.
Assumptions: Taken as given (e.g., reality, human nature).
Propositions: Asserted relationships between constructs.
Hypotheses: Testable predictions from propositions.
Social order, human nature, and the structure of society
Consensus model: Society organized by agreement on shared values.
Conflict model: Social order arises from negotiation and conflict among groups.
Pluralism: Society is diverse; social order emerges through negotiation and adaptation (analogy: tossed salad, not melting pot).
Key formulas and formal notations (to be used in study and exams)
Null and alternative hypotheses:
Correlation/association measure:
Conceptualization-to-measurement pipeline (summary): concept (\rightarrow) nominal definition (\rightarrow) theoretical proposition (\rightarrow) operational definitions (\rightarrow) observation/measurement (\rightarrow) data (\rightarrow) hypothesis (\rightarrow) test/replication
Determinism vs probabilistic science: science often tests probabilistic relations, with replication and counter-evidence shaping confidence in findings.