Study Notes on Shaw v. Reno
Redistricting and District 12
North Carolina General Assembly created District 12 as a second majority-minority district, spanning 160 miles along Interstate 85.
District 12 aimed to connect minority voters across disparate areas, yet was rejected by the attorney general initially for only creating one majority-minority district.
Historical Context
Post-Civil War amendments (13th, 14th, 15th) aimed to end slavery and secure voting rights for African Americans.
"Black Codes" and Jim Crow laws suppressed African American voting rights post-13th and 14th Amendments.
Voting Rights Act of 1965 prohibited discriminatory voting practices and required pre-clearance from the federal government for certain jurisdictions.
Case Summary: Shaw v. Reno (1993)
Court case arose from the creation of District 12, claiming it violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment due to racial gerrymandering.
District Court dismissed claims stating that race-based districting for minority benefit does not violate the Constitution.
Legal Arguments
Petitioner (Shaw)
Concept of color-blind legislation was emphasized; racial classifications perceived as unconstitutional.
District's bizarre shape indicated it was drawn solely based on race, violating traditional criteria of compactness and contiguity.
Respondent (Reno)
Argued that race-conscious districting can promote representation of minority groups.
This does not violate constitutional norms unless it is done to limit minority representation.