Study Notes on Shaw v. Reno

Redistricting and District 12

  • North Carolina General Assembly created District 12 as a second majority-minority district, spanning 160 miles along Interstate 85.

  • District 12 aimed to connect minority voters across disparate areas, yet was rejected by the attorney general initially for only creating one majority-minority district.

Historical Context

  • Post-Civil War amendments (13th, 14th, 15th) aimed to end slavery and secure voting rights for African Americans.

  • "Black Codes" and Jim Crow laws suppressed African American voting rights post-13th and 14th Amendments.

  • Voting Rights Act of 1965 prohibited discriminatory voting practices and required pre-clearance from the federal government for certain jurisdictions.

Case Summary: Shaw v. Reno (1993)

  • Court case arose from the creation of District 12, claiming it violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment due to racial gerrymandering.

  • District Court dismissed claims stating that race-based districting for minority benefit does not violate the Constitution.

Legal Arguments

Petitioner (Shaw)

  • Concept of color-blind legislation was emphasized; racial classifications perceived as unconstitutional.

  • District's bizarre shape indicated it was drawn solely based on race, violating traditional criteria of compactness and contiguity.

Respondent (Reno)

  • Argued that race-conscious districting can promote representation of minority groups.

  • This does not violate constitutional norms unless it is done to limit minority representation.

2