1/141
Looks like no tags are added yet.
faction
group of people with the same interest
what is bad about a faction?
will try to get what they want even if it hurts others
"enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm"
don't have a government based on good leaders
what form of government does Madison want to create?
republic
what does a large republic protect us from?
factions
why is the majority not always right?
the majority can be a faction
pure democracy
all power to the people to decide for everyone
two examples of a faction
creditors and debtors
How to prevent factions?
destroy liberty
What kind of government controls factions effect?
federal republic
how do we make decisions with a republic?
laws and ideas go through a filter with a board of chosen representatives
a wise, trusted representative
trustee
What are The Federalist Papers?
A collection of eighty-five essays written to explain the theory behind the United States Constitution.
Who were the three authors of The Federalist?
James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay
What was the authors' main objective in writing The Federalist?
To promote ratification of the Constitution
Federalists
Supported the constitution and Anti-Federalists Opponents of the Constitution
Who wrote The Federalist 10?
James Madison
Among the numerous advantages promised by a well constructed union, none deserves to be more accurately developed, than its tendency to break and control the violence of faction.
Factions. Madison argues for the general political importance of breaking and controlling factions and points in particular to the "factious spirit" of the time.
Define faction
A group of citizens united by a common feeling, idea or opinion
Why factions are considered dangerous to republican government.
Madison believed that factions operate in their own interest and ignore the rights of other citizens and/or the interest of the community.
What are two ways in which factions can be cured?
By removing the causes of factions OR by controlling the effects
How does the author "shoot down" the possibility of removing the causes?
You cannot remove the causes of factions because to do so, you would have to destroy liberty and freedoms that allow them to exist. If you destroy liberty and freedom you destroy government.
What is the most common cause for the development of factions?
the unequal distribution of property
The author states "No man should be judge in his own case." However, legislators ("a body of men") are inevitably interested in much of the legislation that they consider. Is there a remedy for this?
Only if it were possible to have "enlightened statesmen" who are only concerned with justice and public good. BUT enlightened statesmen will not always be available or in power.
In ruling out removing the cause of factions (freedom), Madison implies that if the causes of factions cannot be eliminated then the only alternative is to:
Control its effects ( Control Factions)
How can a minority faction be controlled?
It will be defeated by a regular vote
How can a majority faction be controlled?
either by preventing it in the first place or by making it incapable of putting its schemes (opinions/plans) into effect by creating a large republic
What is pure democracy ?
In a pure democracy each citizen represents himself or herself. Majority rule.
Why is pure democracy often considered the ideal government?
It would seem best for each person to speak and vote for himself
Why can't pure democracies deal justly with majority factions?
There is nothing to control a majority interest. In Madison's day, the debtors were using their majority power to take from the creditors. Pure democracies are based on majority rule.
Madison presents his solution to the problem of factions. What does he state is the cure? (hint: type of government)
A large republic or representative government
How is it that republics, especially large ones, can deal more effectively with the problems generated by majority factions? (two reasons).
Republics can represent larger numbers of citizens and recruit the best from a larger pool of talent.
What is the major advantage of having Republics represent larger number of citizens?
The effect of having elected representatives is to refine and enlarge the public views by passing them through the medium of a chosen body of its wiser citizens. .
What might be the major disadvantage of a large republic?
The representatives may not be well acquainted with local circumstances and with the minority's interests
Why does the author believe that the new federal constitution provides the necessary balance?
The Constitution provides for two distinct legislatures and leaves state and local governments in place (creates federalism system)
The Constitution provides for two distinct legislatures, name the two
A national legislature to decide "great and aggregate interests" A state legislatures for local and particular interests.
Identify the principle that the author is defending when he refers to national legislature to decide "great and aggregate interests" and a state legislatures for local and particular interests.
Federalism
What arguments does the author make to support his claim that large (number of electors) and extensive (territory) republics afford the best control of factions?
Extended republics encompass a greater variety of parties and interests, making it less probable that a factious majority can be formed or that it can act
Purpose:
One of the most famous of the Federalist Papers, No. 51 addresses means by which appropriate checks and balances can be created in government and also advocates a separation of powers within the national government.
What question does Madison ask in his first? How does he answer it?
"What method should we use, then, to maintain the necessary partition of power between the difference branches as laid down in the Constitution?" = All outside provisions are inadequate, must have 3 branches
Madison lists three ways to protect the "separate and distinct exercise of the different powers of government". What are those?
Each branch has its own abilities in government. Each branch should not be able to appoint members of other branches.
Three ways that the different powers of government are kept separate and distinct:
When appointing judiciary members, they must meet qualifications
All members of each branch must be appointed by the people
In what is "government itself the greatest of all reflections on human nature"?
Madison is recognizing that humans are capable of great things but are just as easily susceptible
What does Madison mean when he refers to "the policy of supplying, by opposite and rival interests, the defect of better motives"?
It means the policy of correcting wrong and opposite interests or checks and balances
What does Madison say is one remedy to ensure that the legislative branch, the strongest branch, does not abuse its power?
To divide the legislative into two groups w/ different means of election and different representatives
What is a compound republic? What is this double security?
**Compound republic: where power is divided into state and federal governments. That are divided into separate branches The government will control themselves and each other (double security)
How does the federal organization of the American republic protect against the tyranny of the majority?
By creating a community and by recognizing society as diverse as possible to prevent such events
What lines in Federalist 51 echo Hobbes' words in Leviathan?
Humans=inherently bad If men were angels, we wouldn't need government
Brutus claimed our government was
Weak
Brutus urges people to fully read the proposal for the constitution because
This form of government will get rid of their liberty
What rarely happens once people part with power
They can never resume it again, only by force
Brutus was an
Antifederalist
Brutus was named after what
A Roman senator who killed Caesar
How did antifederalist view themselves
Protecting republic tyranny
Brutus feared what type of government would become irrelevant
State government
Dangers
No representation of people, tyranny, clash of opinion
Brutus preferred a what type of democracy
Participatory
According to Brutus what may happen to the power of 13 states
Power may decrease
What clauses in the constitution may lead to states having less power
Supremacy clause and necessary and proper clause
The proposed legislatures power to tax is virtually what
Unalienable
What idea is totally lost since the proposed constitution provides the power to tax to the federal government
Idea of confederation
What warning Cora Brutus issue about the possible future of state governments
State government could lose power
Why might a standing army be a danger to liberty
Take away freedom
What will a powerful system of federal courts do to the courts of the 13 states
States will be independent, government will have more power
What potential danger lies in the necessary and proper clause
Government could create any law they want it
Why must the power of the states be retained
No one over powers
Against what element of human nature does Brutus worn
Power
Buddhist believe that our republic maybe be doomed because of what simple fact
Not everyone participates as well as big populations
Both Montesquieu and the Beccarari both contended that what type of a republics are the most successful
Small
What is the logical end of our future public
Republic will begin to become too big in fall
What does Brutus think will be the result of a large and growing republic
Policy gridlock will prevent progress
To what future historical event is Brutus perhaps alluding
The Civil War
What form of democracy is Brutus against
Pluralist, lead to an decision
Where does confidence rest and a small republic
People knowing rulers, holding them responsible and the ability to remove them
How my last being forced wants the people have no confidence in their government
Armed Forces
What will eventually happen to the relationship between the representative and the government
Representatives above people leading to abuse of power with only self in mind
What fact about humanity is Brutus acknowledging
When given power people use it to get what they want despite how it affects others
Curtis is an anti-federalist FaceTime his statements would you say he is more conservative or liberal
Conservative, he didn't want the constitution to be adopted
As a result of our new government structure, what governments will soon become irrelevant
State governments
What power of our new government will destroy the confederation
Power to tax, supremacy clause
What are the two clauses of the proposed Constitution Brutus find most frightening
Supremacy clause and the necessary and proper clause
what type of government is the eventual result of Republicans that have grown too large
Tyranny
Our new government cannot function in the pluralist or elitist model because
Pluralist leads to indecision Elitist was feared because of to much national power
What size of republic is most desired for the people of United States
Small
For how long does Brutus believe our new republic will exist
Not very long, will lead to tyranny
Articles of Confederation
The first Constitution of the United States
Articles of Confederation did not establish...
Courts, Executive / President
Under the Articles of Confederation who had the final authority in all matters?
The States
Why were the Articles of Confederation replaced by the U.S. Constitution?
to form a stronger government
When were the Articles of Confederation ratified?
During the American Revolution.
Powers granted to the federal government under the Articles of Confederation.
determine peace & war; decide disputes between states; establish and regulate interstate post offices.
Collecting taxes
Power denied to the Federal Government under the Articles of Confederation
Shays' Rebellion
conflict in Massachusettes that demonstrated the need to change the Articles
The authors of the Articles of Confederation...
feared concentration of power in national government
Which important legislation was passed while the Articles of Confederation were in effect?
The Northwest Ordinance
The Northwest Ordinance
provided the basis for governing much of western territory. the law created a new territory north of the Ohio River which would eventually be divided into three to five states.
13
How did voting work in Congress under the Articles of Confederation?
Each state received one vote.
The Articles of Confederation weak government can be best described as ...
"a firm league of friendship"
How many branches of government were created under the Articles of Confederation?
One